Why My 8-Year-Old Keeps Playing With The Friend Who Hurts Her Feelings: Parenting Tips
The vanilla ice cream was dripping down Lila’s wrist onto her new white sneakers when she told me, halfway to the car after school last Tuesday, that Mia had pushed her off the slide at recess that day. She swiped at her wet cheeks with the sleeve of her faded unicorn hoodie, sticky ice cream smearing the fabric, and looked up at me. “But Mia saved me a seat at lunch yesterday,” she said. “Can I still get the sparkly slime kit for her birthday this weekend?”
Mia is the girl who lives two blocks over, in the same third-grade class as Lila. I’ve watched their friendship cycle through the same rhythm for 18 months: one Saturday they’re drawing chalk rainbows all over our driveway, sharing a bag of gummy bears, and by Sunday evening Lila’s barricaded herself in my car crying because Mia said her pigtails looked stupid and refused to let her join hopscotch. I’ve had the same reaction a hundred times: I suggest she call her other friend, the sweet, even-tempered girl she did ballet with last year. I say, “Why do you want to play with someone who treats you that way?” Lila just shrugs, and the next day she’s knocking on Mia’s door before breakfast.
I brought it up at parent-teacher conferences a few weeks back, because I was starting to worry I was doing something wrong. Ms. Henderson, Lila’s teacher, leaned back in her chair and nodded like she heard this every week. She said that for kids around 8 or 9, friendships aren’t about being consistently nice yet. They’re about intensity. A friend who laughs at your jokes and shares her candy one day, and yells at you the next, is way more interesting than a friend who’s always steady and kind. That messy back-and-forth is how they learn what they like, what they don’t, and what they’ll put up with. If we yank them out of that situation the second it gets hard, they don’t get to practice figuring it out themselves.
That hit me. I’d always jumped in to fix it before, badmouthing Mia to Lila, offering up alternative playdates, even once gently hinting to Mia’s mom that maybe they work on the pushing (that was awkward). But after talking to Ms. Henderson, I tried three small, specific changes that didn’t require big fights or banning playdates.
First, I stopped badmouthing Mia. I used to say “That’s such a mean thing for her to do” the second Lila told me a story, and I realized that just made Lila defensive. She loves Mia when things are good, so if I say Mia’s a bad friend, she feels like she has to choose between me and her, and she stops telling me when things go wrong. Now I just name her feeling instead of judging her friend. If she says Mia pushed her off the slide, I say “That sounds really frustrating. You wanted a turn, and she pushed you instead of waiting. That hurts, doesn’t it?” That’s it. No lecture, no taking sides. More often than not, that’s all she wanted anyway—she just wanted me to listen, not fix it.
Second, I set gentle boundaries when they play at our house, instead of letting them work it all out alone or stepping in with a big lecture. If I hear Mia telling Lila she can’t come to her birthday party unless Lila gives her the beaded bracelet Lila made, I just wander over like I’m checking to see if they want apple slices, and say “At our house, we don’t trade invitations for toys. Everyone gets invited if they’re asked, regardless of what they share. Want any lemonade?” It’s low-key, it doesn’t shame anyone, and it models what fair behavior looks like for both of them. I don’t have to yell or make a big deal out of it.
Third, I leave the door open for her to leave or change her mind, no “I told you so” allowed. I told her any time she’s at Mia’s house or at a party with her and she wants to come home, she can text me or call me, and I’ll come get her immediately, no questions, no sighing, no side comments. Just pizza and a movie when we get home. That takes the pressure off her to stick it out if it’s too much.
A couple of weeks ago, I got to see what that practice looks like. Mia came over to play, and after 20 minutes I heard her say that Lila’s new stuffed rabbit, the one she sleeps with every night, was garbage, and if Lila didn’t put it away she wouldn’t play. I was already standing up from the couch to go in, when I heard Lila say “He’s not garbage, he’s my favorite. If you don’t want him out here, you can sit on the other side of the room. We play my game for 15 minutes after yours, or you can go home. Your call.” I sat back down. A minute later I heard them both laughing over a puzzle.
It’s not perfect. There are still days Lila comes home red-eyed, and I still have to bite my tongue to keep from marching down the block to say something to Mia. This weekend, Lila is going to Mia’s birthday party, just like she asked. I put an extra pack of gummies and a pack of tissues in her jacket pocket, just in case. I don’t know if this friendship will last. Next year they might go to different classes, or find new friends, or have a big fight and never speak again. That’s fine. Right now, Lila’s learning how to say what she needs, how to stand up for herself, and how to be with people even when they’re not perfect. That’s more than any drama-free, perfect friendship could teach her right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why My 8-Year-Old Keeps Playing With The Friend Who Hurts Her Feelings: Parenting Tips