Is Unstructured Loose Parts Play A Waste Of Time? A Teacher’s Real Experience
I’m stacking math workbooks on my desk after school last month, wrapping up for parent-teacher conferences, when Mia and her mom show up 10 minutes early. They pause by the low art table in the back, where I keep a big blue Rubbermaid bin labeled “junk draw” – full of cardboard tubes, clean bottle caps, scrap fabric, old cereal boxes, and extra pipe cleaners left over from holiday crafts. Mia’s mom nods at the bin, then at Mia, who’s already drifted over and is twisting a bottle cap between her fingers. “Can I ask you something?” she says. “Is this… is this just a waste of time? Mia spends almost the entire free period on Fridays here, and she never makes anything you can hang up or keep. I’ve been thinking about pulling her from after-school art to do extra math, since her scores are just a little below benchmark. Every minute counts right now, doesn’t it?”
My chipped ceramic coffee mug, the one I got at a local craft fair three years ago, is sweating on the corner of my desk, and rain streaks the classroom window. It’s mid-October, and the whole room still smells like the apple cider donuts we had for the fall party that morning. I don’t blame Mia’s mom for asking. I used to ask the same question, actually, when my own oldest was in second grade. I’d get frustrated when he’d sit on the living room floor sorting his rock collection for 40 minutes instead of knocking out his 15-minute spelling homework. I thought that was a total waste of time that could be spent on something that actually mattered. It took me a couple years of teaching to see what was actually happening right in front of me.
I gestured for her to sit, and told her about Javi, a student I had two years ago. Javi was obsessed with the squirrel that kept sneaking into our classroom through the cracked window by the cubbies and stealing goldfish crackers out of kids’ lunch bags. For two straight weeks, he spent every free minute working on a trap out of my junk bin. His first frame, made out of a Cheerios box, collapsed when he tested it, so he cut extra strips of cardboard to glue on as supports. He tried yarn first to hold the trap door shut, but it was too stretchy, so he swapped for twist ties he brought from home. When he finally caught the squirrel (we released it out by the playground, of course), he insisted on writing a whole five-paragraph story about it for our weekly writing assignment – no reminders, no complaining about how long it had to be. That’s the same assignment half the class begs to turn in with just three sentences.
Mia had wandered back to the shelf where I keep unfinished projects for a week, and she pulled out her tooth hospital, the one she’d started after losing her first tooth at recess the week before. She tugged her mom over to show her the little bottle cap bed where her tooth rested, the scrap felt she glued to the walls to keep it warm, the tiny paper sign that said “TEETH GET BETTER HERE.” Her mom knelt down, and I saw her soften. She said she had no idea that’s what Mia was working on – she’d seen Mia cut up cardboard at home a few nights before and just assumed it was mindless mess.
The thing most of us miss when we’re asking “is this a waste of time” is that learning doesn’t always have to look like a finished worksheet or a grade on a test. You don’t have to throw out your math flashcards or skip homework to let kids do this kind of play, either. There are small, concrete changes I tell parents to try when they’re torn:
First, swap the question you ask. Instead of “What are you making?” which puts pressure to produce a polished final product, ask “What are you working on right now?” That small shift lets kids talk about the process, which is where all the learning lives. When I asked Mia that question the day she started the tooth hospital, she rambled for 10 minutes about how falling out hurts and teeth need rest, something I never would have gotten if I’d pushed her to show me a finished craft.
Second, set a clear time limit that lets them wrap up, instead of cutting them off mid-thought. Instead of barking “Put that junk away right now, we have homework to do,” try “You have 20 more minutes to work on that, then we’ll clean up for math practice.” That way they get the benefit of seeing their idea through, without throwing off your whole evening’s schedule.
Third, if you’re worried about missed academic practice, tie their play to the skills they need without ruining the fun. If they’re sorting bottle caps by size, ask them how many blue caps there are, or how many more red caps than green. That’s addition practice that feels like play, not homework. If they’re building ramps for toy cars, ask them why the steeper ramp makes the car go faster. That’s basic science, no textbook required.
A couple weeks later, Mia’s mom sent me a quick email. She rearranged Mia’s after-school schedule to keep art class, added one 30-minute “junk build” time every Sunday at home, and kept math flashcards for twice a week after dinner. Last week, Mia brought in a new addition to her tooth hospital: a waiting room with tiny paper chairs for all the other teeth that are going to fall out soon.
I still get asked this question at least once a month from parents: is this thing a waste of time? Sometimes it is – I’m not here to say mindlessly scrolling for hours or doodling through the whole math lesson when you’re supposed to be solving problems is useful. But most of the time, when kids are choosing to spend time on something that doesn’t look like “real learning,” it’s not wasted. It’s just learning that doesn’t show up on a progress report yet. It’s still too soon to say if Mia’s math scores will jump up to where her mom wants them by the end of the semester. But last week, she told me she got a B on her latest quiz, and it’s because she practiced counting bottle caps for her hospital. That’s enough for me, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is Unstructured Loose Parts Play A Waste Of Time