Why I Can’t Trust My Boomer Dad to Watch My Kids (And What I Do About It)
It was 8 a.m. last Tuesday, and my chipped molar was throbbing so bad I could barely talk. My husband was out of town for a work conference, my regular sitter was sick, and I was this close to canceling the emergency dentist appointment when I remembered my dad lives 10 minutes away. He picked up on the first ring, said he’d be over with coffee for me before I even finished asking. I grabbed my bag and headed out, already feeling guilty for the knot of anxiety in my stomach. I knew this wouldn’t be the first time I’d left the kids with him and spent the whole appointment checking my phone every two minutes.
When I got back two hours later, the front door was unlocked, the house smelled like burnt popcorn, and I could hear the theme from an old John Wayne movie playing from the living room before I even stepped inside. Lila, my 4-year-old, was perched on the kitchen counter licking a bright blue popsicle that definitely didn’t come from my freezer. The back gate, which I lock every single time the kids are outside, was propped open a foot because dad had let our golden retriever out and forgotten to close it. Our backyard backs to a four-lane road. When I walked into the living room, Jax, my 6-year-old, pulled a handful of tiny peppermints out of his sweatshirt pocket to show me—the same kind dad keeps in his jacket pocket, the ones the American Academy of Pediatrics lists as a top choking hazard for kids under 5.
Dad just laughed when I tensed up, said “They’re fine, quit worrying. You ate these all the time when you were their age, didn’t you?” He’s said that same line a hundred times: after he took Jax’s training wheels off without asking and let him ride down the block alone, after he gave both kids root beer at 10 a.m. during my last parent-teacher conference, after he left a bottle of bleach sitting by the laundry room sink when the kids were playing down there. He’s not mean, he’s not careless. He’s a wonderful grandpa when I’m around—builds Lego castles for an hour straight, tells terrible jokes that make the kids snort, brings me a slice of his homemade peach pie every time I visit. He just genuinely doesn’t see what the big deal is. He raised three kids, all of us turned out alive and mostly okay, so why am I so overprotective?
I used to fight about it. I’d go home after a visit, fuming, and vent to my husband about how he never listens, how he doesn’t care about our rules. I’d lie awake at night feeling guilty too—guilty that I can’t just trust my own dad, guilty that I’m keeping him from having the grandparent relationship he wants, guilty that I’m the only one of my friends who can’t just hand the kids off to their parents for a weekend away. It sucks. There’s no other way to put it. You want your parents to be the safe, easy backup you can count on, and when they’re not, it leaves this weird, uncomfortable hole.
Over the last year, I’ve stopped fighting and started making small, concrete changes that take a lot of the stress out of it. First, I stopped leaving them alone with him for any long outings. If I need to go somewhere that’s more than an hour away or will take my full attention, I book my trusted sitter, even if it means paying $50 I didn’t plan for. It’s worth it to not spend the whole time panicking that something’s going to happen. Second, when I do leave them for a quick trip to the store or a short doctor’s appointment, I do a quick, casual safety walk-through before I leave. I don’t frame it as “you’re doing this wrong.” I just walk to the back gate, latch it, and say “These two are so fast, this is just so I don’t stress the whole time I’m gone.” I go through his candy bowl, pull out any small hard candies or toy parts that fit through a choke tester, put them on the top shelf above the fridge, and say “Lila still shoves everything in her mouth, this keeps us both from having to run to the ER.” Third, I always pre-pack all their snacks and drinks, mark them with their names, and tell him “I packed their favorites so you don’t have to mess with digging through your pantry when they ask for something.” I don’t leave it up to him to remember our rules about no soda before dinner.
The trick I’ve found that works the best is shifting the “blame” from him to a third party, usually their pediatrician. Instead of saying “I don’t want you to give the kids hard candy,” I say “Their doctor says no hard candy until they’re 5, so I’m just following her orders.” That takes the personal sting out of it. He doesn’t feel like I’m attacking his parenting skills, he just thinks I’m being a good mom following the doctor’s orders. He nods, agrees, and we move on without the awkward tension.
It’s not perfect. I still feel that twinge of guilt sometimes, when I see my best friend post photos of her kids on a weekend camping trip with her parents and I think about what I’m missing. Last week, dad asked if he can take the kids to the zoo next month for his birthday, and I haven’t given him an answer yet. I’m thinking I’ll tell him I want to come along, drive my own car, so he gets to have all the fun of buying them cotton candy and seeing the elephants, and I’m there just in case someone climbs a fence or the exit gate gets propped open by accident. It’s not the independent grandpa day he probably wants, but it’s better than saying no entirely.
I wish I could trust him. I wish I could just hand over the car seats and the snack bags and head off for a weekend away with my husband like all those other parents. It sucks that I can’t. But right now, these small, boring compromises work for us. No big family blowup that fixed everything, no perfect resolution. Just adjusting, one visit at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I Can’t Trust My Boomer Dad to Watch My Kids (And What I Do About It)