Is Dedicated Asynchronous School Assignment Time Enough? A Parent’s On-the-Ground Experience
Last Tuesday, I leaned against the kitchen doorframe at 2:15 p.m. holding a loaded laundry basket, and watched my 7th grader, Milo, snap his math notebook shut and slide off his chair. Half a strawberry Pop-Tart sat crumbed on a plate next to his Chromebook, his soccer cleats were already by the front door, and he was asking if we could go shoot goals before dinner. Three years ago, that same time of day would have found me nagging him to get off the couch, digging through his backpack for lost assignment sheets, and talking him off a ledge because he “didn’t understand any of the science homework.” His middle school built 2 hours of dedicated, scheduled asynchronous assignment time into every school day right after morning live classes, and it’s changed everything for our family.
I was skeptical at first, when they rolled this model out post-pandemic and kept it. I thought, 2 hours of unsupervised time at home? He’ll just scroll TikTok all day. The school set clear structures: kids log into their class hub, keep their camera on if they’re working, and core subject teachers stay available the whole time for one-on-one questions. They also set a hard rule: no regular assignments get sent home to finish unless a kid doesn’t use their async time appropriately, or it’s a long-term project that needs extra work.
A month into the school year, I learned first-hand how much easier things are when you actually stick to the scheduled time. I scheduled a routine dentist appointment for 1 p.m., cutting 45 minutes out of Milo’s async block. I didn’t think much of it—figured he’d just finish the work after dinner. That night, he sat at the table fuming for an hour. He’d gotten stuck on a set of pre-algebra equations, and his teacher wasn’t online to answer the question he’d posted in the chat. By the time I (who hasn’t done 7th grade algebra in 20 years) tried to muddle through explaining it to him, he was too tired to focus. He got half the problems wrong, and went to bed grumpy. After that, I stopped scheduling anything non-emergency during his async time. That’s one concrete thing I tell other parents: protect the time the school has set aside, don’t fill it with errands or extra tutoring just because it looks like “free time” on your calendar.
The big question, of course, is whether that dedicated block is actually enough time. For most regular daily assignments, yes, in our experience and that of other parents I’ve talked to. Last year, the school tried 90 minutes of async for 6th graders, and that was too tight for most kids, so they upped it to 2 hours this year. That’s the right amount for Milo, who works at an average pace. He usually finishes 10 to 15 minutes early, which he uses to chat with friends or draw before he’s done for the day. It’s not enough for everything, of course. When he had to outline his historical fiction book report last month, he waited until the last 25 minutes of async to start (pre-teen procrastination, what can you do) so he had 10 minutes of work to finish after dinner. Big projects, like the upcoming science fair, take more than 2 hours a day, but the school frames async time as a chance to make steady progress, not finish the whole thing, so that’s fine.
I talked to my neighbor Sarah, whose 8th grader has ADHD, to get her take. Her son gets an extra 30 minutes added to his async block as an accommodation, and she says it’s night and day from the old homework system. Before, he’d come home overstimulated from a full day of in-person school, and couldn’t sit still to do 20 minutes of reading. Now, he does his work while he’s still in the school routine, and his teacher is there to redirect him if he gets off track. It cuts her evening work helping him from an hour and a half down to 15 minutes, if that.
What’s the biggest practical takeaway I have? If your school offers this dedicated time, don’t add extra work to it just because your kid is done early. I made that mistake the first month: I added 20 minutes of extra reading practice and a set of math problems because I thought 2 hours shouldn’t be enough for a 7th grader. Milo started rushing through his actual assigned work to get to the extra, and ended up making careless mistakes just to be done. Now, if he finishes early, that’s his time to do whatever he wants within the block—game, draw, chat, whatever. It doesn’t cut into my evening, and he doesn’t burn out. Another small, low-effort trick: have your kid spend the first 2 minutes of async time writing down what he needs to finish that day. Milo’s teacher requires this, and it cuts down on the 20 minutes of “what do I do first?” wandering that most kids do when they sit down. If you’re a parent of a kid who struggles with that, just ask them to show you their quick list before they start—it takes 10 seconds, and makes a big difference.
Of course, it doesn’t work for every kid automatically. Milo’s friend Jace spends most of his async time playing games and chatting, so he has an hour or more of homework every night. His mom started checking in once, at the 1-hour mark, just popping in and asking to see what he’s finished so far. She doesn’t hover, just a quick check-in, and that’s cut down on how much work he brings home by a lot. It’s a low-friction adjustment that works for them, no big fights.
For us, right now, the scheduled async time is enough, and sticking to it has made everything easier. We don’t have homework fights every night, we get to eat dinner without a Chromebook at the table, and Milo has more time to hang out with friends and play soccer after school. We still have bad weeks—last week, he spent half his async time talking to his friend about the new Minecraft update, and ended up doing an hour of work after dinner. We’re still working on setting up website blockers for social media during work time, it’s a work in progress. I don’t know if this system will stick when he gets to high school next year, where workloads get heavier, but for right now, it’s the best setup our school has ever had for middle schoolers. It’s not perfect, but it’s good enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is Dedicated Asynchronous School Assignment Time Enough