What I’ve learned about the current state of education as a 4th grade teacher and mom
The cold coffee on my kitchen table had been sitting there long enough for a skin to form last night, when Leo pushed his homework folder across the table and asked the question that made me pause. “Can I do my science project on skatepark drainage instead of the plant life cycle thing?” he said, nodding at the assignment sheet the school sent home. Before I could answer, my phone buzzed: it was a text from Mia’s mom, one of my students. “She cried for 20 minutes after math tonight. Got three problems wrong and said she’s dumb. No grades this year, so I don’t even know how to tell her what to fix.”
Leo’s beat-up skateboard is propped against the fridge, there are goldfish crumbs ground into the tablecloth, and I’ve got 27 exit tickets to grade stacked next to my laptop. I’ve been teaching 4th grade for 12 years, and Leo’s my oldest, so I get to see this from both sides: what’s expected of me in the classroom, and what it’s like to sit at the kitchen table with your own kid’s homework. I’ve thought a lot about the state of education lately, and it mostly just feels like we’re all stuck between two loud, opposing sides that don’t leave much room for what kids actually need.
Lately, it feels like every education conversation is two groups yelling past each other. One side says kids don’t work hard enough, we’ve gotten rid of all standards, they can’t even do basic multiplication by middle school. The other side says we’re burning kids out with too much testing and homework, we’ve sucked all the joy out of learning. I hear both at every parent night: half the room is upset about too much pressure, the other half upset about not enough accountability. No one seems to be talking about the middle ground that actually works for most kids.
Leo’s question isn’t new. I’ve had a dozen kids ask me the same thing this semester: can I do my project on this instead of that? For a long time, I’d say no, because we had to hit the standard by the end of the unit, admin checks our lesson plans to make sure we’re on pace. But a few years ago, I had a kid named Javi who wouldn’t do any independent reading. He was two levels behind, refused to touch any of the books on our approved list, got detention every week for not turning in reading logs. I found out he collected vintage Pokemon cards, could tell you the hit point of every first generation card from memory. I told him he could read the official Pokemon collector’s guide for his reading log, just write one sentence a night about what he learned. He turned in every single log that semester. By the end of the year, he was testing just a half level below grade level, and he’d moved on to reading graphic novels about BMX riding. That’s when I stopped saying no automatically.
So I told Leo he could do skatepark drainage, but he had to include how the native plants planted around the new local park help hold soil and filter water, which means he’s still covering plant life cycles and how they interact with ecosystems. That’s the thing people on both sides miss: you don’t have to choose between teaching required content and letting kids care about what they care about. This isn’t some big, fancy curriculum change. It’s a 30-second adjustment any parent or teacher can make: every week, tweak one assignment to fit your kid’s interest. If they have to write a paragraph about a community helper, let them write about the skatepark maintenance guy instead of the fireman example in the textbook. It doesn’t take extra time, and it turns a chore they’ll drag their feet on into something they actually want to finish.
Mia’s situation with grades is the same kind of false choice. People act like you have to pick between shaming kids with failing letter grades that crush confidence or getting rid of grades entirely to keep kids happy. But what I’ve seen over and over is that vague feedback like “you’re growing” doesn’t help kids who already know they’re struggling. They just fill in the gaps with their own worst assumptions: if I’m still growing, that means I’m behind, I’m bad at this.
The concrete fix I’ve been using for the last three years is simple: every time you check a kid’s work, name one thing they got right, and give them one specific thing to work on next. For Mia, that meant instead of saying “it’s okay, you tried really hard”, you say “You got the first step of every division problem right. Next time, just remember to carry over the remainder to the second step.” It doesn’t overwhelm them with 10 things to fix, and it tells them exactly what to practice instead of leaving them guessing. I suggested that to Mia’s mom, and she texted me back an hour later saying they tried it, and Mia stopped crying and went back to work on her own.
The state of education right now feels messy, because the system is still trying to fix all the old mistakes, and it’s swinging too far in one direction or another. Most teachers don’t want to teach to the test, but most also don’t want to leave kids with no clear expectations. Most parents want their kids to be happy, but they also want them to be prepared for what comes next. No one is really happy with the big system, and it’s going to take years to sort that out.
After Leo packed up his homework and went outside to skate, I pulled up my lesson plan for next week’s science unit, and I changed the unit test to let kids pick between three different ways to show what they know: a traditional written test, a poster, or a short video explaining what they learned. I don’t know if admin will say anything about it. I don’t know if some parents will email me saying it’s not fair or not rigorous enough. But so far this year, the kids who have had that choice turn in better work, and I get a much clearer picture of what they actually understand. There’s still a lot that’s broken, a lot that I worry about. I still have days where I leave school exhausted, wondering if I’m doing more harm than good. But the small stuff, the 30-second adjustments, the specific feedback, that’s what actually matters for kids right now. We don’t have to wait for the system to fix itself to do that.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I’ve learned about the current state of education as a 4th grade teacher and mom