Why Do Schools Have Dumb Rules? A Parent’s Take On Strange School Policies And How To Talk To Kids About Them
Last Tuesday, I watched my 8-year-old Lila yank my passenger door open so hard the side mirror wobbled. Her sparkly unicorn hood was pulled tight over her braids, a dinosaur band-aid peeked out from under her jeans knee, and a crumpled pink conduct slip was bunched in one fist. She’d gotten her second demerit of the month, she mumbled while clicking her seatbelt, for wearing her hood inside the building. The heater along the 3rd grade hallway had been broken for three days, the custodian had propped the exterior fire door open to run a ventilation hose, and she’d been freezing standing in the nurse’s line after scraping her knee at recess. The rule, printed on page 17 of the student handbook: no head coverings of any kind inside school, no exceptions, for “safety and identification.”
That night, I dropped the story into our class parent group chat and asked if anyone else had run into rules that felt totally unhinged from actual kid life. The replies rolled in for an hour. One mom said her 1st grader got a warning for bringing a smooth pinecone he’d found for show and tell, because district policy bans “unprocessed natural objects” after a kid brought poison ivy to school four years ago. A dad shared that his 5th grader served 15 minutes of after-school detention for walking backwards in the hallway, a rule put in place after one kid tripped and chipped a tooth in 2019. There’s the birthday treat policy that bans all homemade food but counts neon fun dip as an acceptable, allergy-safe snack. My 11-year-old 6th grader Javi already had his own story: he’d gotten a warning two weeks prior for asking a friend for an extra napkin after the first five minutes of lunch, when all talking is required to stop.
I was halfway through typing an angry email to the principal when Lila’s teacher, Ms. Henderson, replied to the thread and said she hated the hood rule too, and had already asked twice for an exception for that cold hallway. I stopped by her classroom after pickup the next day, and she leaned against her desk stacked with half-graded math worksheets dotted with dinosaur and unicorn doodles in the margins (which she never marks kids down for) and broke down where most of these rules come from. Almost none are thought up by teachers, or even building principals. Most are district-wide blanket policies, written in a rush after one bad incident, designed more to cover the district from liability than to help kids learn.
The hood rule, she said, went into place two years ago, after two 8th graders skipped math, pulled their hoods up to avoid being seen, and hid in an unlocked unused stairwell for two periods. Their parents threatened to sue the district for failing to supervise. Instead of paying to fix the stairwell lock or add one part-time hall monitor, the school board voted for a total ban on all head coverings, kindergarten through 8th grade, no exceptions. Silent lunch started after a 4th grader with a severe peanut allergy had a reaction at a noisy table, and staff couldn’t hear him coughing for help. Instead of budgeting for one extra cafeteria aide to walk the tables, they banned talking after five minutes.
That night at dinner, Lila was still pushing pasta around her plate, huffy that she’d gotten in trouble for being cold. My first two instincts were equally unhelpful: either tell her “rules are rules, just keep your hood down so you don’t get in trouble,” or tell her the rule was total garbage and I’d write her a permanent excuse to wear whatever she wanted. Neither felt right. If you teach kids that every rule from a person in charge has to be followed no matter how little sense it makes, they never learn they can push back when something is unfair. If you teach them every rule that inconveniences them is stupid and can be ignored, they never learn that most rules come from someone trying to solve a problem, even if they solved it badly.
I pushed the garlic bread basket toward the middle of the table and tried a different line. “You’re right that it feels unfair,” I said. “Do you remember why the school says they have this rule in the first place?” She mumbled something about safety, so I kept going. “That’s right. They want to be able to see everyone’s face in the hallway so they know who’s supposed to be in the building, and no one gets hurt. That’s a good thing to want. But do you think a total ban on hoods works for every single situation, like when the door’s propped open and it’s 50 degrees outside?” She shook her head. “What do you think we could do about that, instead of just getting demerits or complaining at home?”
She brought the question up at her class’s weekly morning meeting the next day. Half the kids said they’d been cold in that hallway too, and Ms. Henderson helped them write a short, polite note to the principal asking for a narrow exception: 3rd graders could wear hoods in that specific stretch of hallway while the heater was broken, as long as they pulled them down when they entered common areas like the office or cafeteria. The principal walked the hallway with them after class, felt the draft coming through the open door, and said yes. She even dug a spare space heater out of the storage closet for the nurse’s line.
Javi did something similar with the silent lunch rule. He and three friends sat down with the cafeteria manager, acknowledged staff needed to hear kids who were choking or having an allergic reaction, then asked to test a new system: quiet inside voices the whole period, with 10 minutes of open social time at the start instead of five. They offered to remind classmates to keep voices down if noise got too loud. They’ve run the test for six weeks now, and lunch staff say it’s actually calmer than before; no one yells across tables to get a word in before the timer goes off, and the steady hum of quiet talk is easier to hear over than the old bursts of rushed noise.
Not every dumb rule is worth fighting, of course. Javi still turns around when he catches himself walking backwards in the hallway, and neither of us has the energy to organize a push to overturn the pinecone ban. That’s another thing these small rules teach: you get to pick which battles matter to you, instead of wasting energy being mad at every policy that rubs you the wrong way. For younger kids especially, these low-stakes frustrations are practice for bigger, messier unfair moments later in life, without any real risk attached. A demerit for a hood doesn’t hurt a kid’s grades or their long-term record, but figuring out how to name a problem and ask for a specific fix sticks with them.
Last week, the heater in Lila’s hallway finally got fixed, and the principal told the class they have to go back to following the district-wide hood ban. Lila’s already roped three kids from other grades into helping her put together a presentation for the school board, asking them to replace the total ban with a rule that just requires faces to be visible, no ban on hoods. I don’t know if the board will go for it. Half the time, I still just want to tell her to keep her head down and follow the rules so she doesn’t rack up demerits. But last night she was sitting at the kitchen table coloring posters for their meeting, so I just set a snack down next to her and didn’t say anything. It’s a dumb rule. But it doesn’t have to be a waste.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Do Schools Have Dumb Rules