What Happens If FCC E-Rate Cuts Hit School Internet Budgets? A Teacher’s Perspective
Last Tuesday, I sat across from Javi’s mom at my scratchy laminate conference table, my half-decaf coffee gone cold, as she explained why his late homework has piled up over the past month. Their home internet cut out three weeks ago, when she couldn’t pay the bill after her car broke down, and the school hotspot Javi checked out has been cutting out when they use it at their apartment, which sits in a dead zone a mile from the nearest cell tower. Most nights, he does his reading and math work sitting in the passenger seat of her car in the McDonald’s parking lot down the road, where the signal is strong enough to load Google Classroom. I wrote a note to excuse his late work, and told her I’d swap his hotspot for a different model with a stronger antenna after school. I didn’t tell her that our principal just announced at last week’s staff meeting that potential cuts to the FCC’s E-Rate program could mean we lose 120 of our 300 available hotspots next year.
E-Rate is one of those things no one outside of school administration thinks about until it’s at risk. I’d never even heard of it until three years ago, when our district did a parent workshop on budget cuts, and I walked away learning it funds almost half of my school’s total internet costs, from the bandwidth that lets every kid pull up their reading intervention app at the same time to the data plans for the hotspots we lend to families who can’t afford home internet. It’s funded by fees on telecommunications companies, not general taxpayer money, which is a common misconception I end up explaining over and over to parents.
At last week’s staff meeting, our principal printed out the proposed cuts on plain white copy paper, and passed them around while we ate cold donuts left over from the parent breakfast. The current proposal would cut E-Rate funding by around 15% nationwide. For our district, that’s an $180,000 cut to a budget that’s already stretched paper-thin. We don’t have a surplus to cover that gap. Our district already has a $2 million structural deficit from last year, after state funding got frozen. The three options on the table right now are all bad: raise the annual student technology fee from $25 to $50, cut the number of hotspots we lend out by almost half, or downgrade our bandwidth to a slower plan that can’t handle all 800 kids being online at the same time during the school day.
Most people assume internet is a bonus, not a core part of school now. But I can’t remember the last week I didn’t rely on it for something. We do our quarterly reading assessments online. Our speech therapist does tele-practice one day a week for kids who can’t stay after school for appointments. The after-school art club uses free online tutorials from the Art Institute of Chicago. Even our lunch count is taken online now, to cut down on paper waste. Last month, our internet went down for two hours midday during testing, and we had to pause, reschedule half the tests, and push back our progress reporting for parents by three days. If we downgrade bandwidth, that’s going to be a regular occurrence, not a rare emergency.
For kids like Javi, it’s even more personal. Around 60% of our students qualify for free or reduced price lunch, and one in five don’t have a permanent home internet connection at all. Before E-Rate funding expanded a few years ago to cover hotspot lending, those kids were falling behind an average of a month and a half every school year just because they couldn’t do their homework at home. That gap has shrunk by almost two-thirds since we started lending out hotspots, because of the subsidized data plans E-Rate pays for.
A lot of parents have asked me what they can actually do about this, since it’s a federal issue, and most people feel like their voice doesn’t matter. I get that frustration, but there are small, low-effort things anyone can do right now that make a difference. First, it takes 2 minutes to look up your U.S. senators and representative – sites like Vote.org pull up your representatives automatically with just your zip code, no account or extra personal info required. Send a one-sentence email saying you oppose cuts to the FCC E-Rate program because it funds your local school’s internet and student hotspots. That’s it. Congressional offices count every message they get on an issue, and even a hundred short messages from constituents can get a representative to go on the record opposing the cuts. I did this during my 45-minute prep period last week; it took less time than grading a stack of 4th grade spelling tests.
Second, if you’re part of a local PTA or parent group, ask to add a 10-minute update on E-Rate cuts to your next meeting agenda. Most parent groups only talk about fundraisers and field trips, but this is something that will impact every kid in the school next year if it passes. Just letting other parents know what’s at stake is enough to get more people to reach out to their representatives.
Third, if cuts do end up passing, ask your school administration what specific help they need. A lot of people rush to donate old laptops or generic supplies, but what schools will need most in that case is people to help outreach to families about existing low-cost internet plans from providers, or volunteer time to manage hotspot checkout and returns. If your PTA has even a small surplus, you can set aside a couple hundred dollars to cover the one-time activation fees for extra hotspots that the district can no longer fund. That’s a small, concrete thing that makes a huge difference for a handful of families.
After my conference with Javi’s mom, I walked them out to the parking lot. Javi swung his backpack, the dinosaur sticker on his hotspot case peeking out of the side pocket, and asked if he could still go to the after-school coding club this Friday. I told him of course. I didn’t mention the proposed cuts, because I don’t have any answers yet. The FCC won’t finalize the decision until next month, and right now we’re all just waiting to see how it goes. I know that a lot of big national issues feel like they’re out of our control, but this one isn’t. It’s just about letting people in Washington know that the internet for kids like Javi isn’t an extra expense it can cut. It’s the thing that lets him get his homework done, go to coding club, and keep up with his class. That’s all it is.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Happens If FCC E-Rate Cuts Hit School Internet Budgets