Why a Fourth Grader in China Shut Down Over Homework—and What Helped Instead
The worksheet was still blank at 6:48 p.m. An An sat with his raincoat bunched up on his shoulders, red scarf twisted to one side, pencil teeth marks along the eraser. Outside the tutoring room window, a street-food vendor was setting up near the apartment gate, and the smell of fried potatoes drifted through the cracked window.
“Your mom texted me,” I said.
He kept his eyes on the desk. “She says I’m bad.”
I pulled a chair beside him instead of sitting across from him. On paper, this was a fourth-grade English class in a small learning center in eastern China. In practice, most Wednesday evenings involved convincing An An that he was not in trouble.
His mother’s message that afternoon had been short: “Please help this kid. He says he finished homework, but his book is empty. His father is very angry.”
I had seen this before, but not this clearly. An An went to school from 8:00 to 4:30, had math tutoring from 5:00 to 6:20, ate dinner in the car, and came to me at 6:45. By the time he finished his school assignments, it was often after 10:30. On weekends, his family drove him to calligraphy, piano, and an English reading class. His mother kept a small notebook with scores and rankings. His father sometimes checked homework after work and made him copy wrong answers three times.
That night, I did not talk about effort or attitude. I took a blank sheet of paper and covered nine of the ten fill-in-the-blank questions, leaving only number three.
“We’re not doing the page,” I said. “We’re doing this one. Read it to me.”
He mumbled the sentence.
“Which word fits?”
“Between,” he said.
“Okay. Write it.”
He hesitated, then wrote it. The letters were uneven, but they were correct. I uncovered number five. Two minutes later, he had finished that one too. We did four questions in twelve minutes, then stopped and looked out the window at a man selling sweet potatoes from a metal cart.
What looked like laziness or dishonesty was closer to overload. When a child sees a full page after a full day, his attention does not simply become weaker; the task itself starts to feel impossible. He may lie about finishing because finishing feels out of reach, and lying buys him ten minutes of quiet. Adding another workbook, scolding him, or calling him slow only gives him more reason to avoid the work.
The first practical move was to shrink the task. Covering the page worked better than saying, “Just try your best.” I also gave him two real choices: “Do you want to do number three or number seven first?” and “Do you want to say the answer or write it first?” Choice did not remove the expectation; it gave him a small door into it.
I also changed how mistakes were handled. While he wrote, I did not correct spelling or punctuation immediately. I let him finish the sentence, then circled only two things to fix. If he erased a word more than twice, I told him, “First tries are allowed to look messy.” Perfectionism was slowing him down, and every correction felt like proof that he had already failed.
After class, I spoke to his mother for five minutes. I did not show her the blank page first. I showed her the four completed questions.
“He can do them,” I said. “But on tutoring nights, twenty minutes of English is enough. If the schoolwork is too long, stop him and write me a note. I would rather he comes back willing to try than finish one more page and hate English.”
She looked tired. She had cooked breakfast at six, worked through lunch, and still had to go home and supervise homework. “But his father says he must finish,” she said.
“Then let him finish fewer problems correctly,” I said. “Cross out the last three. I will explain to the teacher if needed.”
She agreed to try it for one month.
At home, his mother made three small changes. She gave him a bowl of warm soup and ten minutes of quiet before homework started. She put his phone in a drawer, but she also set a kitchen timer for twenty minutes, followed by a five-minute break where he could walk on the balcony or fold paper airplanes. If an assignment ran past 9:50, she took a photo and sent a message to the teacher instead of forcing him to continue.
These were not magical fixes. Some nights he still stared at the wall. Once, he hid a Chinese dictation paper inside his math textbook and said he had no homework. His mother found it and raised her voice; he cried and said his stomach hurt. But instead of doubling the work that night, she had him wash his face, do five spelling words, and go to bed.
The next week, I asked An An to tell me his answer before writing it. Speaking lowered the pressure. Once he heard himself say a sentence correctly, writing it felt less dangerous. For longer compositions, he drew three boxes—beginning, middle, end—and wrote one sentence under each. He did not have to produce a polished paragraph. He only had to put one idea in each box.
Six weeks later, the change was uneven but visible. He arrived one Tuesday with a folded piece of paper hidden behind his back. It was a comic he had drawn: a cat sitting in rain under a streetlamp. Under the pictures, he had written “cat,” “rain,” “cold,” and “fish?” in English. He had looked up “fish” himself.
Not every day went that way. Last Wednesday, he put his head down and said his head hurt. I checked his water bottle, gave him two minutes to stand by the window, and then crossed out six questions. He picked up his pencil without being told.
His mother still worries about middle-school entrance exams. His father still asks about rankings. The pressure around children in this part of China is real, and one teacher cannot remove it. I did not try to tell the family to ignore grades or abandon their expectations. I only asked them to make the next step small enough that An An could take it without lying or shutting down.
Last Sunday, his mother sent me a message: “He did English before dinner today. I did not remind him. I don’t know if it will continue.”
I don’t know either. But on Wednesday, he will probably arrive with his heavy backpack, his red scarf, and the same pencil with the bitten eraser. The worksheet will be waiting. Most of it will be covered. We will start with one question, and that may be enough for that night.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why a Fourth Grader in China Shut Down Over Homework—and What Helped Instead