Is My Kid’s Unstructured Hobby a Waste of Time? What My Son’s Cardboard Builds Taught Me
Last Tuesday, I was folding socks at the kitchen counter while my 10-year-old Javi hunched over the dining table, a half-melted glue gun in one hand and a cut-up Amazon box in the other. I’d just opened an email from his math teacher, reminding us state testing was six weeks away and that Javi could use 15 extra minutes of long division practice a night to get caught up. I watched him squint and press a googly eye to the lopsided cardboard claw machine he’d been tinkering with for three weeks, and the thought popped up uninvited: is this whole thing a waste of time?
It started 18 months ago, after we stumbled on a pop-up cardboard arcade at the neighborhood park. He spent 45 minutes feeding homemade tokens into a cardboard basketball hoop built by a 12-year-old, and on the walk home he asked if we could save all our delivery boxes instead of putting them straight in recycling. I said sure, figured it would keep him busy for a weekend. A weekend turned into a marble run that snaked down the hallway, then a puppet theater for his stuffed animals, then half a dozen half-finished projects stacked in the corner of his bedroom. The blue recycling bin by our front door is permanently half full of flattened boxes he’s hoarded, and the glue gun he uses has a broken trigger that he jimmies with a butter knife to push glue sticks through. I’ve scraped so many dried glue blobs off the dining table I’ve given up on getting the surface fully clean.
Other people ask the question out loud, sometimes. A mom from his class asked last month when I mentioned he spends most weekend afternoons building, “Oh, is that through a STEM program? No? Just… messing around at home?” My sister said over Christmas, between bites of pie, that we should sign him up for a proper robotics camp instead of letting him waste good glue on what’s basically trash. I even tried that, once. Signed him up for an 8-week after-school engineering class at the rec center, paid the $120 fee, bought him a new notebook for plans. He went two sessions and refused to go back. Every project came with a printed step-by-step guide, every kid’s wind-up car looked identical when class was over, and if you glued a piece on crooked the instructor helped you peel it off and reposition it. “There’s no point,” he told me when I prodded him about going back. “You already know what it’s supposed to be when you start.”
I brought the same worry to his parent-teacher conference a couple months later, actually. I sat across from his teacher, Ms. Henderson, with his math test scores spread out between us, and said I felt guilty letting him spend three or four hours a week on cardboard when he could be practicing math facts or working on his reading comprehension. I expected her to agree, to tell me to set stricter limits on free time. Instead she pulled his writing notebook out of her desk and flipped to his last essay. It was a persuasive piece asking the principal to add a cardboard creation station to the recess playground. He had three numbered arguments, quotes from three classmates he’d interviewed, and two full crossed-out sections where he’d rewritten the introduction because, he’d scrawled in the margin, “this sounds too much like begging.”
“Most fourth graders turn in one draft and call it done,” Ms. Henderson said. “Most of them can’t work through something that fails three times and come back to it the next day. Javi does that every week, for fun.” She flipped to his recent math work, pointed to a long division problem he’d gotten wrong twice before getting right. He’d tried two different methods instead of crumpling the paper and asking for help, she said, same as he does when his cardboard claw strings get tangled.
He got the claw machine working two Saturdays ago, sort of. The claw only grabs the tiny scented erasers he collects about one in every three tries, and you have to jostle the left side of the box just right to keep the string from catching. He dragged it out to my sister’s barbecue that weekend, charged his 7-year-old cousin a quarter a turn, and made $1.75 before anyone told him he was supposed to let little kids win for free. When Lila did start crying because she couldn’t get the unicorn eraser she wanted, he didn’t just hand it to her. He pried the back panel off the box, showed her where the string was catching on a folded cardboard edge, trimmed the edge with his safety scissors, and gave her three extra turns. I stood by the grill eating a hamburger and watched that, and for a little while the “waste of time” voice went quiet.
Over the months I’ve picked up small, simple habits that keep this fun for him without turning cardboard into another forced enrichment activity. I used to interrupt him every 20 minutes when he was working, to remind him to take the trash out or finish his spelling homework, and I noticed he’d lose his train of thought and abandon the project for days at a time. Now if the glue gun’s plugged in, I just stick a sticky note with the reminder on the edge of the table, and he switches tasks as soon as he hits a natural stopping point. I also stopped asking “what is that supposed to be?” when I walk by, because that question makes it sound like the whole point is to end up with a recognizable, perfect thing. Now I ask one small, specific question: “How’d you get that corner to bend like that?” or “What part are you fixing right now?” Most of the time he just grunts and says “stuff,” which is fine. I don’t need a full explanation. I also stopped pre-sorting boxes for him, even though it would make the recycling bin neater. If I hand him exactly the size box he asks for, he never has to improvise. Digging through the bin himself, cutting down a box that’s too big or taping two small ones together, is half the problem-solving.
I get why we all default to counting time as wasted if it doesn’t show up on a progress report or a resume. We’re told over and over that kids need every minute scheduled, every activity tied to a skill that will help them get into good classes, good colleges, good jobs. An hour spent gluing googly eyes to trash doesn’t check any of those boxes. It doesn’t come with a grade or a certificate or a polished photo for a parent group chat. But I think about what actually stuck with me from when I was 10. I don’t remember the multiplication drills or the spelling tests or the weekly current events worksheets I had to turn in. I remember the whole summer I spent digging holes in my grandma’s backyard convinced I’d find dinosaur bones, and how I learned the hard way that if you dig too deep right after it rains, the sides cave in. I remember making friendship bracelets out of embroidery floss that all fell apart after a week, and how I learned to adjust the knot pattern after the first three broke. None of that was assigned. None of it was graded. None of it would count as “productive” by the rules we make up for kids now.
I still have the thought, sometimes. Last week he brought home a B- on a long division quiz, and I found him after dinner cutting up a diaper box to make a gumball machine, and that little voice popped right back up: 15 minutes of practice a day adds up. What if this is taking time away from something he actually needs? What if we get to middle school and he’s behind, and I regret all those hours I let him spend on cardboard?
I don’t have a neat answer for that. We still do the 15 minutes of math practice most nights, after he’s put the glue gun away. Some nights he complains, some nights it goes fine. The claw machine is still sitting by the front door, half the googly eyes have fallen off, and it still only works one out of three tries. Last night he told me he’s going to scrap it and start over, make the claw out of plastic bottle caps instead of cardboard. I didn’t nag him about math practice before dinner. I just nodded and said okay, and reminded him not to leave the glue gun plugged in. Some days that feels like enough. Some days I still wonder.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is My Kid’s Unstructured Hobby a Waste of Time