My Son Asked “Do These Make Me Look Gay?” Here’s What I Said
The car had just come to a stop in our driveway. I was unclipping my seatbelt when Charlie’s voice came from the back seat, quiet but pointed.
“Dad. Do these make me look gay?”
I looked in the rearview mirror. He was holding up a pair of bright orange Crocs that a friend had given him at the end of the school year. They had little mushroom charms on the straps. He was looking at them with a mix of curiosity and concern, not like he was trying to make a statement, just trying to figure out where they fit.
I stalled. I could feel the weight of the question sitting in the car between us. The easy answer would have been to say, “No, buddy, shoes don’t make you look anything.” But I knew that wasn’t what he was asking. He was asking me to translate the world for him, to tell him how other kids (and adults) perceive these bright plastic clogs and what that perception might mean for how he walks into a room.
Charlie is nine. He’s at that age where social currency is everything, but the rules are unspoken. He wanted to know if wearing those shoes would make him a target or, worse, make people think he was someone he wasn’t yet sure he was.
I asked him what he meant. He shrugged and said, “Jake said they’re kinda fruity.” Kids repeat what they hear, but they don’t always understand the weight of the words. So my first instinct was to explain that “fruity” is a word that people sometimes use to make fun of things that are different, and that it wasn’t really about the shoes at all.
We sat in the car for a few more minutes. I remember thinking about all the things I wanted to say. I wanted to tell him that clothes are just clothes. I wanted to tell him that anyone can wear orange Crocs and it doesn’t change who they are. But I also knew that telling him that would be ignoring the very real reality of how he’d be perceived at school on Monday. The truth is, kids read signals. And sometimes, those signals become a story that gets told about them before they even get a chance to speak.
Here’s the thing that I’ve learned as a parent and as someone who used to be a kid in a school hallway: questions like this are rarely about the item. They’re about the social map. He wasn’t asking me to validate the shoes. He was asking me to help him understand the terrain.
So, I did what I think works best in these moments with a nine-year-old: I asked him to describe the social landscape. Not the shoes. The people.
“What happens when a kid wears something really different?” I asked.
He thought for a second. “Sometimes they get laughed at. But sometimes people just don’t care.”
That opened the door. We talked about the difference between a kid who wears something because it’s a joke and a kid who wears something because they love it. I told him that people can usually tell the difference. The kids who wear bright things because they make them feel good tend to shrug off comments. The ones who wear them looking for a reaction are the ones who get teased. I’m not sure if that’s fully true, but it gave us a frame to talk about the difference between owning something and being owned by it.
He still wanted a straight answer about the Crocs. So I gave him one.
“They’re bright. People will notice them. Some kids might think they’re cool because they’re different. Some kids might make a joke. That can happen with anything you wear that stands out.”
He looked out the window. “So does that mean I shouldn’t wear them?”
“You can wear them. But I want you to know that how you handle the comments matters more than the shoes. If you act embarrassed, it’s going to feel bad. If you just say, ‘Yeah, they’re my mushroom shoes,’ and move on, you’ll be fine.”
That was the practical part of the conversation. But the word he had used, gay, kept hanging around my head. I knew I couldn’t let that slide. Because we all know that when a child says “does this make me look gay,” they often mean “does this make me look weak, or silly, or like I don’t fit in.” And that’s a separate issue from actual sexuality.
I took a breath and said, “You know, people use the word gay in different ways. Sometimes they mean someone is actually gay. Sometimes they just mean something is different from what they expect. You’re allowed to like bright colors. That has nothing to do with who you love or who you’ll become. But I also know that kids say that word to be mean sometimes, and that’s not okay.”
He nodded. I think he understood the difference, at least a little. The conversation shifted to the fact that he thought the mushrooms were funny and that he liked how the shoes made his feet feel like boats. That was it for the moment.
But what stuck with me was how easy it would have been to just shut it down. To say, “Stop caring about what people think. Just wear them.” That’s good parenting in theory, but it doesn’t work when the kid is already aware of the social consequences. If I had done that, he would have walked into school with the shoes and a lot of anxiety, but no game plan.
What I’ve learned in the years since is that these questions need a specific kind of answer. The kid isn’t asking for a lecture on gender norms. They’re asking for a map. They’re asking, “If I step onto this street, will I get hit by a car?” And the answer isn’t “cars don’t exist here.” The answer is, “Cars exist. But you can walk on the sidewalk if you know how.”
The real practical shift came later. We went through his wardrobe together and talked about which items felt like “him” and which ones felt like costumes. I didn’t say “wear whatever you want.” That’s too abstract for a kid who just wants to play soccer at recess without being mocked. We sorted things into two piles: ones he wore because he liked them, and ones he wore because they kept him invisible. I didn’t judge either pile. I told him that both reasons are normal.
I also started being more careful about my own words. Kids learn how to talk about clothes from the adults in the room. If I made jokes about someone looking “flamboyant” or “flashy,” I was teaching him that those things are bad. So I stopped. I started saying things like, “That’s a bold choice, how does it make you feel?” And I tried to mean it.
The Crocs never became a regular part of his rotation. I think he wore them twice that summer, both times at home. That was fine. The moment had passed. But a few weeks later, he asked another question while we were eating breakfast: “Dad, is it okay if I’m just not the coolest kid in class?”
That question, honestly, felt bigger than the one about the Crocs. Because it was about releasing the pressure of trying to fit a mold. He wasn’t asking for permission to wear wild things. He was asking for permission to not chase status.
I said, “It’s more than okay. It’s actually a relief. Cool takes a lot of energy. You can spend that energy on other things.”
He took a bite of his cereal and didn’t say anything else.
I don’t think that’s the end of these conversations. There will be more moments like the Crocs. There will be questions about haircuts, about shirts that might be too tight, about words that get thrown around on the playground that I can’t control. What I can control is the conversation after them. And the more of those I have, the more I realize my job isn’t to tell him what things mean. My job is to help him notice the moment before he steps out of the car, so he can decide for himself how he wants to move through the world.
The next pair of shoes won’t be orange. But I hope he knows he can ask me about them anyway.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My Son Asked “Do These Make Me Look Gay