Citronella Mosquito Stickers for Toddlers: Do They Work, and What Are Safe DEET Alternatives
Last Saturday, I was mid-barbecue cleanup when I looked down and found my 2-year-old Lila kneeling in the long grass at the edge of our yard, one chubby hand clamped around a half-eaten strawberry, the other scratching furiously at a bright red bump on her ankle. We’d already gone through half a tube of calamine that week for mosquito bites, and I’d somehow left the bottle of bug spray sitting by the front door. Digging through the bottom of my diaper bag, past crumpled Goldfish crackers and a sticky sippy cup lid, I found the pack of citronella mosquito stickers a friend had gifted me at Christmas. I pulled three off the sheet and smacked them on the shoulders and waistband of Lila’s denim overalls, then crossed my fingers.
Mia, my neighbor who was packing up her 4-year-old’s things, leaned over and laughed. “Don’t get your hopes up. I bought a whole pack of those last year for my son’s birthday party. By the end of the afternoon, he had more bites than the balloons we blew up.”
She was right, of course. Like a lot of parents of toddlers, I’d been avoiding spraying DEET on Lila whenever I can. I know the American Academy of Pediatrics says it’s safe for kids over 2 months old in concentrations up to 30%, but Lila shoves her hands in her mouth 100 times an hour, rubs her face nonstop, and the idea of spraying a chemical repellent all over her just doesn’t sit right with me. So I’d been hunting for alternatives, and citronella stickers are everywhere in mom groups, advertised as natural, easy, no-mess solutions for wiggly toddlers.
By the time we cleaned up the barbecue and headed inside, Lila had three new bites in addition to the one she started with. She woke up the next morning with a faint red rash exactly where the bottom sticker had been glued to her skin. That was enough to make me sit down that night and sort through what actually works, beyond the marketing hype.
First, what I learned about citronella stickers themselves. The active ingredient is citronella oil, which is a mild mosquito repellent, but the oil only diffuses a couple of inches from the sticker. That means it keeps mosquitoes away from the 2 square inches of fabric right under the sticker, but the rest of your toddler’s body is fair game. Some independent studies have found they don’t work any better than no repellent at all for full-body protection. The adhesive can also irritate sensitive toddler skin, which is exactly what happened to Lila. I wouldn’t write them off completely—they’re fine for a quick 15-minute walk around the block when it’s not peak mosquito season, and they’re way easier than messing with spray. But if you’re spending more than a half hour outside, they’re not going to cut it.
Then, what did I find that actually works, if you don’t want to use DEET? The first and easiest thing I started doing is prioritizing clothing over any repellent at all. I picked up a couple pairs of thin UPF long pants and long-sleeve tees from Target for $10 each. They’re lightweight enough for 85-degree summer days, the tight weave keeps mosquitoes from biting through, and they double as sun protection too. When we’re going somewhere extra buggy, like a walk in the woods or a trip to the community garden, I tuck the bottom of her pants into her socks. It looks a little dorky, but it keeps mosquitoes from biting her ankles, which is their favorite spot. I’ve cut our number of bites in half just with this change alone.
For extra protection, when I do need something beyond clothing, I use 10% concentration picaridin spray, and I only spray it on the outside of her clothes, not directly on her skin. Picaridin is also recommended by the AAP for kids as young as 2 months old, it’s odorless, doesn’t feel greasy, and a lot of parents who don’t like DEET find it gentler. I’ve used it on our clothes for a couple of camping trips now, and it’s worked just as well as DEET for me, without the same strong chemical smell I don’t love. I should note that oil of lemon eucalyptus, another popular natural repellent, isn’t recommended for toddlers under 3, so that’s off the table for most of us looking for toddler-specific options.
There are also small changes you can make to your own yard that cut down on mosquitoes before you even step outside. I had a forgotten 5-gallon bucket sitting under our downspout that was full of stagnant rainwater, which is exactly where mosquitoes lay their eggs. I empty it out every two days now, and I dump out the water from our flower pot saucers and the kid’s wagon after it rains. That alone cut the number of mosquitoes hanging around our backyard by a lot, no repellent needed. We also try to stick to playing outside midday, when mosquitoes are less active, instead of dawn or dusk when they’re out in full force.
I still keep that half-used pack of citronella stickers in my diaper bag. If we decide last minute to run down the block to get ice cream, I’ll slap one on Lila’s shirt just for extra peace of mind. But I don’t rely on them anymore for longer outings. We tried the mosquito-repellent wristbands last week too, so I’ll report back after a few more park trips—bite prevention with toddlers is just one of those small things you’re always tweaking, right? No perfect solution, just what works for your kid and your comfort level.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Citronella Mosquito Stickers for Toddlers: Do They Work, and What Are Safe DEET Alternatives