What’s the Point of School? Why Teens Are Questioning the Education Promise and How Parents Can Respond
The heat in room 214 always clanks too loud in March, and the air smells like old microwave popcorn and lemon cleaning spray. I was halfway through reviewing argument paragraphs when Javi leaned back in his chair, hood up, and asked the question that usually hides behind eye-rolls.
“Miss, you really think this essay is going to matter?”
I gave the teacher answer first: clear writing matters, college expects it, employers want people who can organize ideas. He nodded slowly, the way teenagers do when they’re deciding whether to let an adult off the hook.
“My cousin has a business degree,” he said. “He sells phones at the mall. He still lives with my tía because rent’s crazy. And AI can write, like, five of these in a minute.”
A few students looked up from their Chromebooks. Laila pulled out one earbud. “My mom says education is the key to a better future. But what if the key doesn’t open anything?”
No one laughed. That’s when I knew this wasn’t one student trying to get out of work.
I used to answer with confidence. Go to school, get good grades, choose college, find a career, and life gets steadier. That story felt true for many families for a long time. It still does for some students, especially those heading into nursing, engineering, teaching, or certain licensed trades. But for a lot of teenagers, the transaction looks shaky. They see relatives carrying student debt. They see jobs that don’t pay enough to live on. They see software that can summarize, code, and draft faster than they can. And they hear adults repeating a slogan that doesn’t match what they observe.
That night at the kitchen table, my own 16-year-old daughter, Sofia, had a laptop open to college tuition pages. She wants to work with animals, maybe as a vet tech or in animal rescue. She clicked through a four-year school, then a community college, then pushed the computer away.
“Is it even worth it?” she asked.
I almost said the usual things: follow your passion, don’t give up, education is something no one can take away. But those answers felt too neat. Tuition numbers were on the screen. Her friend’s brother had moved back home after graduation. A local clinic had told her vet tech experience mattered as much as a general degree.
“Let’s not decide forever,” I said. “Let’s look at the next two years.”
We made a messy list on a piece of notebook paper: associate degree in veterinary technology, animal science classes that transfer, shelter volunteering, a possible part-time job at a boarding facility. We wrote down costs and commute times. It didn’t remove the uncertainty, but it made the future smaller and more manageable.
That shift matters. When teenagers ask what school is for, they are usually not being lazy. They are doing exactly what adolescence asks them to do: compare adult claims with real evidence. Their abstract thinking is growing, and they’re noticing fairness, inconsistency, and risk. If the only answer we give is “trust the system,” many will disengage quietly. Others will keep doing the work but feel anxious, as if every grade determines whether their life will work out.
In my classroom, I’ve stopped selling school as a golden ticket. Instead, I try to name what it can and cannot do.
Education can give people practice with difficult texts, numbers, writing, and problem-solving. It can expose them to fields they didn’t know existed. It can keep certain doors open, especially for students who want licensed or professional work. What it cannot do is guarantee affordable housing, stable employment, or fair wages. Those are larger economic issues, not personal failures caused by a teenager’s lack of effort.
I also started putting one honest purpose sentence on the board before assignments. “This essay is practice in disagreeing with someone without insulting them.” “These percentages help you understand whether a car loan is a good deal.” “This lab is mostly about following steps and recording mistakes.” If I can’t explain why we’re doing something, I either change the lesson or admit it’s practice for a future class.
Students can ask, “When would someone use this?” once per period. I answer in about thirty seconds and don’t take it personally. Sometimes the answer is career-related. Sometimes it’s simply, “This helps you understand what your government is doing.” Occasionally I say, “You’re right, this particular worksheet is not very useful. Let’s finish it efficiently and spend more time on the discussion.”
At home, the small change has been replacing “How was school?” with more specific questions. “What did you change your mind about today?” “What did you have to redo?” “Did anyone disagree with you?” Those questions don’t always get long answers. Sofia often says “nothing” and keeps eating. But sometimes she tells me about a biology quiz, a fight with a friend, or a video she saw about apprenticeships.
I also use plainer language when the future comes up. “School is not a guarantee,” I tell her. “It’s one way to keep options open and get better at handling hard things.” Some homework is just hoop-jumping, and we talk about how much energy it deserves. A quiz worth 2 percent shouldn’t take three hours. A final project that builds real skills might deserve more.
Parents can help by making different routes visible. Invite a cousin who went to community college to dinner. Mention the electrician, dental hygienist, union apprentice, or preschool teacher whose lives include real training but not necessarily a four-year degree. At school, I’ve tried to bring in recent graduates who took varied paths. Students don’t ask inspirational questions. They ask, “How do you pay rent?” “Did you fail anything?” “Who helped you choose classes?”
We also have to be careful about carrying adult panic into ordinary conversations. Teenagers hear us when we talk about layoffs, mortgages, and the cost of groceries. They need honesty, but not the message that every B+ ruins a life. When a topic is too large, I say, “That’s an adult problem. I’m handling it. Your job right now is to learn and figure out what interests you.”
Last week, Javi stayed after class five minutes early to work on his essay. He had chosen to argue that the city should fund more apprenticeship programs. He used his cousin’s story but also checked employment data and added a quote from a local program.
“AI could write this,” he said, “but it wouldn’t know my cousin.”
“Exactly,” I said.
He still doesn’t love school. He still asks questions, and I don’t always have good answers. Sofia is still comparing programs and worrying about debt. Some days she’s excited; other days she says the whole thing feels like a gamble.
I think that’s where many families are now—not abandoning education, but lowering the slogans and looking at the details. School can still help young people build skills, choices, and confidence, but the old promise has become less reliable. The most useful thing adults can do may be to stop pretending otherwise, then help teenagers take one clear, practical step at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What’s the Point of School