Is 9 Too Young to Explain What “Virgin” Means? Practical Tips For Parents
The grass stains on my 9-year-old’s soccer cleats were still rubbing off on the backseat when he leaned forward from his booster seat and asked, “Mom, what does virgin mean?” I almost choked on the lukewarm iced coffee I’d grabbed before practice, and fumbled to turn down the kids’ podcast we’d been listening to. He’d heard two fifth graders saying it on the playground after the scrimmage, he said, and they were using it to tease a kid named Jake. He didn’t get the joke, and it was bugging him.
I’d mapped out a whole timeline for these kinds of conversations in my head. Basic body boundaries and correct names for private parts at 4, puberty talk at 10, consent and sex education at 12. This question was three years early, at least. My first instinct was to brush it off: “It’s nothing you need to worry about right now, honey. We can talk about it later.” But I remembered last spring, when I brushed off his question about why our next-door neighbor couldn’t have a baby, and he turned around and asked the cashier at the grocery store while I was unloading chips and cereal onto the belt. I’d stood there red-faced while the 16-year-old cashier stared at me, waiting for me to step in. I wasn’t doing that again.
I pulled into the gas station up the street, bought him a cold lemonade and me a new coffee, and sat in the parking lot for two minutes to collect my thoughts before I answered. I didn’t overcomplicate it. I said, “It’s a word people sometimes use to describe someone who hasn’t had sex yet.” He blinked, and asked the next obvious question: “Why were they making fun of Jake for that?” That part was easy, too. I said, “It’s rude to make fun of anyone for that. That’s really personal information, and it’s nobody’s business what anyone else does or doesn’t do. Those boys were being mean for no good reason.” He nodded, twisted the cap off his lemonade, and said, “Okay. Can we get chicken nuggets for dinner?”
That was it. Three minutes of conversation, and he moved on to thinking about dinner. After he fell asleep that night, I texted my sister, who teaches fourth grade, and asked her if I’d messed up, if 9 was too young to give him a straight answer. She wrote back that she gets this question at least once a semester from kids. They hear the word on TikTok, in Netflix shows their older siblings watch, on the playground all the time. Most parents never talk about it early, so most kids walk around with some messed up definition they got from an 11-year-old, and that usually leads to more teasing and more confusion.
That got me thinking about how many of us are scared to answer these questions early because we think it will push kids to grow up too fast. I’ve talked to other parents at soccer drop-off who say they’d never explain a word like that to a 9-year-old. But what I’ve realized is, not explaining it doesn’t keep them from hearing it. It just keeps them from getting a clear, neutral answer from someone they trust. If I’d brushed him off, he would have asked one of his friends the next day, and who knows what wrong answer he would have gotten. It wouldn’t have stopped him from thinking about it, it just would have made him think it’s a word so bad he can’t ask his mom about it.
There are a few small things that worked for me that I think any parent can do if this happens to them. First, don’t act like the question is dirty or embarrassing. It’s okay if you’re caught off guard—you can say “That’s a good question, give me one minute to think about how to answer it” just like I did by pulling into the gas station. But keep your voice calm and normal. If you act like it’s a big scary secret, kids will just be way more curious than they would be otherwise. Second, keep it simple. You don’t have to give a 9-year-old a whole lecture on how the idea of virginity ties to outdated ideas about purity, or how it doesn’t actually mean what a lot of people think it means. They just asked what a word means, so give them a basic definition. If they ask more questions, answer those too, but you don’t have to dump everything on them at once. Third, address the context they heard it in. My son heard it being used to bully someone, so we talked about why that bullying was wrong. If your kid hears it in a different context, just meet them where they are.
A week after that car ride, my son came home from school and told me those same two fifth graders were teasing another kid for being a virgin. He walked over and told them “It’s none of your business anyway,” and then walked away. That surprised me more than anything. I didn’t expect that to stick so fast.
It’s been a couple months now, and he hasn’t asked any more questions about it. I still have that rough timeline in my head for when we’ll talk more about puberty, and consent, and all the bigger stuff that comes later. I know there will be plenty more questions that catch me off guard, plenty more times I spill my coffee and have to buy myself a minute to think. I don’t have all the answers, and I don’t know if I’m doing this perfectly. But so far, answering the small questions as they come feels a lot better than letting him learn everything from the playground.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is 9 Too Young to Explain What “Virgin” Means