Great, He’s at It Again. Why Kids Keep Doing the Same Frustrating Things (and What Actually Helps)
He’s sitting on the hallway floor, one sock on, one sock off, glaring at the blue sneaker in his hand like it has personally insulted him. It’s 7:13 AM. We’re already late. And I hear myself say the words I swore I would never say again: “We are not doing this today.” He throws the sneaker. Not at me, just at the wall, which somehow makes it worse. I stand there, holding his lunchbox, feeling the familiar headache bloom behind my eyes. Great. He’s at it again.
The thought that follows is not one I’m proud of, but I’m guessing every parent has it at some point: When will this fing end?
The truth is, it doesn’t feel like a phase anymore. It feels like a loop. The same tantrum over the same shoes. The same refusal over the same bath. The same five-minute standoff over turning off the tablet, which we have never won in under fifteen. There’s a rhythm to it, a horrible predictability. I can practically set my watch by his meltdowns, and in the middle of the morning chaos, that predictability feels less like a clue and more like a life sentence.
Last night, it was the bath again. Same scene, different day. He stood in the hallway with wet hair, arms crossed, claiming, with genuine outrage, that he had “already washed” his hands, his face, and his entire body, which was visibly dirty. I tried logic. I tried bribery. I tried the thing the parenting blogs say about offering choices: “Do you want to walk to the bath or hop like a frog?” He looked at me like I was insane and said, “No. I want to stay dirty.”
I closed the bathroom door and leaned against it. That’s when it dawned on me—not a brilliant insight, just a tired one. He wasn’t crying because he hated baths. He was crying because he wanted to decide something. Anything. He’s at that age where he has almost zero control over his own day. Adults decide what he eats, where he goes, when he sleeps, what he wears. The only power he has is refusal. The word “no” is the only lever he can pull. And he pulls it constantly, because it works. Even when it doesn’t change the outcome, it gets my attention. It gives him a second of being the one who decides.
The “again” of it all—the repetition that makes me want to scream—is actually the point. Kids don’t repeat behaviors because they’ve forgotten that I asked. They repeat because the behavior is serving a purpose. It’s telling me something my son doesn’t have the words for. And most of the time, the message isn’t “I hate baths.” It’s “I need more ownership over my own body” or “I don’t like being rushed” or, honestly, just “I’m tired and I don’t want to transition to the next thing.” Transitions are hard. They’re hard for adults—we just have better coping mechanisms. A four-year-old only has the lever. So he pulls it.
Here’s the thing that has actually helped, and it didn’t come from a parenting seminar. It came from sheer desperation. One morning, after the sneaker incident, I stopped talking. I didn’t argue, I didn’t explain, I didn’t ask him if he was ready. I just sat down next to him on the hallway floor, held out the shoe, and said one sentence: “First shoe, then we go outside and see the trash truck.” He looked at me, suspicious, like I was trying to trick him. But he picked up the shoe. And he put it on. Not because I reasoned with him, but because I gave him a clear, immediate “what’s next,” and I shut up long enough for him to process it.
That “first/then” phrase is now a weird little lifeline in our house. I don’t use it as a magic trick—some mornings it fails, and he still throws the shoe—but it works a lot more often than my fifteen-minute lectures did. Because when I say “first sock, then breakfast,” I’m not asking a question. I’m not giving him a chance to say no. I’m just laying out the order of the universe. There’s no negotiation. And unlike my long-winded explanations, he can actually remember the phrase.
The other thing that changed, slowly, was the environment. Instead of relying on him to remember to bring his jacket or his water bottle, we made a “launchpad” by the front door—a small shelf with hooks at his height. Everything he needs for school hangs there. He can see it, reach it, and grab it himself. It sounds so painfully simple, but it removed the daily power struggle of me saying “go get your jacket” and him saying “you get it.” He still forgets. I still end up chasing him with a sweater down the driveway. But the fight doesn’t happen as often.
I’ve also learned to stop asking questions I can’t afford to have answered. “Are you ready to go?”—that’s a trap. The correct answer is always no. Now I say things like “We’re leaving in two minutes” or “Time to get in the car.” Not a question. A fact. The first few times I did this, he cried. He wanted to be asked. But the crying was shorter than the arguing had been, and eventually, he stopped waiting for the question that never came.
I wish I could tell you we’re fixed. We’re not. Yesterday morning, he refused to wear a jacket even though it was drizzling, and I ended up carrying it under my arm while he ran to the car in a t-shirt. It’s a trade-off. There are days I pick my battles, and there are days I realize I’ve been fighting a war over the wrong thing. Sometimes the thing he’s resisting is a bath, but the thing he’s testing isn’t the water—it’s whether I’ll still be calm when he pushes.
I don’t know when this ends. I suspect it doesn’t, exactly. The tantrums about shoes will turn into arguments about homework, then curfews, then who knows what. The “again” just morphs into a new “again.” What’s shifted for me is realizing that the question “when will this end” was never really about him. It was about me being stuck in a loop that wasn’t working. The thing that had to change wasn’t his behavior—it was my approach to the fact that he was going to keep testing, keep pulling his lever, keep needing control he didn’t have.
This morning, he walked to the car holding both shoes, barefoot, and then put them on by himself in the backseat. I didn’t say anything. I didn’t want to jinx it. Partly it was triumph; partly it was just a Tuesday. He’ll be at it again tomorrow—some other thing. And I’ll be there, holding his lunchbox, trying to remember that “again” isn’t a personal attack. It’s just the next chapter.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Great, He’s at It Again