Why the College Gender Gap Should Worry Every Parent (and What We Can Do About It)
Last spring, I found myself sitting in a folding chair in the high school guidance office, watching my son kick his split tennis shoe against the desk leg. The counselor had just pulled up a chart showing which students from our school had applied to college that year. It was mostly girls. Then she showed me the list of students who had actually been admitted. Again, mostly girls.
My son didn’t say anything. He just looked at the chart like it was a list of names from someone else’s life.
The counselor didn’t need to explain the implications. For every boy she talked to about college applications, she said, she talked to four girls. She said it with a kind of tired shrug, like it was an old weather pattern. We all kind of laughed, but none of us thought it was funny.
The gender gap in college enrollment isn’t new. But it’s not something we can keep shrugging about. Women now make up around 60 percent of undergraduate students, and the number keeps moving in the same direction. In some working-class neighborhoods, the balance is even more lopsided. A lot of boys are simply deciding, somewhere between middle school and graduation, that college isn’t for them.
And for a long time, I thought that was just a men’s issue. Something for the comment sections and think pieces. But then I started paying attention to the economic side of it, and it became harder to treat it like a cultural talking point.
When a large share of young men don’t pursue any kind of education after high school, their earnings drop. They’re more likely to fall out of the workforce entirely. Local employers that need trained workers—hospitals, manufacturers, software companies, even schools—can’t fill jobs. Families feel the pressure. Communities feel it too. This isn’t about which gender is smarter or more deserving. It’s about what happens when half the population checks out of the education pipeline.
The strange part is that most parents I know see this happening in real time, but we don’t know what to do about it. Our sons come home and close their bedroom doors. They say school is boring. They say they’ll figure it out later. They say they don’t want to sit in a classroom for another four years.
I’ve said some version of those sentences myself. But the last few months have taught me a few small, practical things that actually make a difference.
The first thing I had to change was how I talked about reading. My son has always been a reluctant reader. His teachers pushed novels, and he pushed back. At home, though, he would read game wikis, sports stats, and weird tech reviews for hours. I used to tell him to put the screen away and pick up an actual book. Eventually, I stopped policing the material and started paying attention to the behavior. Reading is reading. When I stopped judging what he read, he began talking about it. We’d have conversations about why some game mechanic was broken or why a certain athlete’s career faded. Those conversations didn’t feel like homework. But they were building the same skills he’d need in any college classroom.
Another thing that helped was getting him to think about his life at 25 instead of college itself. One night, I asked him what he wanted his ordinary Tuesday to look like when he was 25. He said he wanted to work with his hands, maybe outside. He wanted a dog. He wanted enough money to rent an apartment and not worry every time his car made a noise.
I didn’t respond with a lecture about how college makes those things easier. Instead, I said, okay, let’s work backward from that. We looked up a few jobs that matched what he described. Some required a four-year degree. Some required a two-year degree or a certificate. A few required an apprenticeship that came with classroom time. That conversation changed the stakes. College stopped being a vague, scary obligation and became one possible step toward a life he could picture.
I also realized I had been letting my son define himself by what he was against. He said school was a waste of time. I used to argue with him about it. That got us nowhere. So I started asking a different question: What would make it less of a waste? He mentioned an automotive class that only existed at the career center across town. He didn’t think he could take it because of the schedule. I called the guidance office, and it turned out he could. That single change made junior year feel more like something he chose rather than something that was happening to him.
None of this is complicated. But it takes a kind of quiet persistence that’s easy to abandon when you’re tired. I had to stop panicking when my son said things like “I don’t care about school.” I had to listen long enough to hear what he was actually saying. He wasn’t saying he wanted to do nothing. He was saying he didn’t want to do what his school was offering him.
That’s a fair complaint, in some ways. The path to college is often described as a reward for patience. But boys don’t always respond to delayed gratification. They respond to meaning. They want to know why they’re sitting in a class. They want to see how it connects to something real. We can’t just keep telling them to work harder and wait. That doesn’t work anymore.
Parents can do small things around this. We can expose our sons to adults who use college or trade school in ordinary, visible ways—not just doctors and lawyers, but nurses, electricians, project managers, graphic designers. We can ask them what they think their days will look like at 25 and help them research what that kind of life costs. We can let them read what interests them and trust that the skill transfers. And when they say college isn’t for them, we can resist the urge to either agree or argue. Instead, we can ask: okay, what’s your plan for the next five years? Let’s write it out together. That doesn’t mean forcing a four-year degree. It means making sure education after high school doesn’t become something they drift out of without ever actually choosing it.
I’m not sure where my son will end up. He’s still the same kid who lets his room turn into a disaster zone and forgets to charge his laptop. But something shifted around that chart in the guidance office. We’re no longer treating college like the only good ending. We’re treating it like one of several doors. And we’re making sure he knows the doors don’t stay open by themselves.
The gender gap in college enrollment isn’t going to close overnight. But if more parents start having these boring, persistent conversations at the kitchen table, maybe we can give our sons a better chance of walking through the door when they’re ready—or at least know the door exists before they walk away.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why the College Gender Gap Should Worry Every Parent (and What We Can Do About It)