What Is The Actual Difference Between University And College: Answers For Parents Of High Schoolers
The pepperoni crumbs on my kitchen table stuck to the glossy paper of two viewbooks last Saturday, when my 17-year-old niece Lila and my sister sat down to work on college applications. My sister twisted one brochure between her fingers—one that said “Maplewood Community College” on the front, the other “Central State University” — and looked up at me. “Okay, be honest,” she said. “What’s the actual difference between these two? One minute everyone’s talking about ‘going to college’ after high school no matter where they go, the next they act like university is something totally different. I’m confused.”
I’ve been a high school guidance counselor for 12 years, so I get this question at least a dozen times every application season. It’s not a silly question. The terms are thrown around so interchangeably that it’s easy to mix them up, and too many families end up making decisions based on the name on the brochure instead of what actually matters for their kid.
I leaned back in my chair and nodded at Lila, who was scrolling through the Common App on her laptop. “First off, it’s different depending on what country you’re looking at,” I said. “If you’re applying to schools in the UK, for example, college is usually the two years before university, for kids getting ready to get their degree. But here in the US, where almost all of us are looking, there are two main distinctions people care about.”
The first core difference is size and what degrees they offer. Most universities offer both four-year bachelor’s degrees, plus graduate degrees—master’s, PhDs, med school, law school. They’re usually bigger, sometimes with tens of thousands of undergrads plus thousands of grad students. Colleges, on the other hand, usually focus only on undergraduate degrees. That can be two-year associate degrees or certificates, like what Maplewood offers, or it can be four-year bachelor’s degrees, just no big graduate programs. I pointed to Lila’s laptop where she had Boston College pulled up. “See that? It’s called a college, it’s a private four-year school, and it’s way more selective than a lot of big public universities. A lot of small, private liberal arts schools call themselves college because their whole focus is teaching undergrads, not research for grad students.”
Lila looked up and said, “My friend Javi goes to Williams College, and he says all his professors know his name, unlike his cousin who goes to a big state university and can’t even get into office hours because there’s 400 people in intro bio.”
That leads to the most common myth I run into: most parents assume university is automatically better or more prestigious than college. I heard that from a parent of a student last year, who refused to let her son apply to our local community college because she said “it’s not a real university.” That kid wanted to be an electrician, and the community college’s two-year electrical technology program had a 95% job placement rate right after graduation, starting at $65,000 a year. He’d have graduated with $10,000 in debt total, instead of $100,000 for a four-year university degree he didn’t need for that job.
Another student I worked with, Jake, wanted to be a civil engineer. His family’s income was too high for a lot of need-based aid, but not high enough to cover $30,000 a year tuition at the state university. So he did two years at community college, knocked out all his general ed requirements for a quarter of the cost, got a 3.8 GPA, and transferred to the state university’s engineering program through their guaranteed transfer agreement. He graduated two years later with half the debt of his classmates, and got the same degree everyone else got.
I told my sister that instead of worrying about whether the school is called college or university, there are three concrete things to check first, no matter what your kid wants to do. First, what degree do they need for their end goal? If they want to be a registered nurse, a two-year college ADN program gets you licensed and working two years earlier than a four-year BSN from a university, and you can always go back for your bachelor’s later while you’re working. If they need a four-year degree to go to grad school, then you look for that, regardless of what the school is called. Second, check transfer agreements if you’re starting at a two-year college. Almost all community colleges have written agreements with in-state public universities that guarantee admission to your program if you hit a certain GPA in your prerequisite classes. You can find that on the college’s website in five minutes, no guesswork. Third, compare the actual total cost, not just the name. A $10,000 a year college program that gets you the degree you need is always a better deal than a $40,000 a year university program with the same outcome, just a fancier name.
My sister flipped back to the Maplewood viewbook and nodded. She’d been worried that if Lila listed it as a safety, she was settling for a lower quality education. Lila clicked add it to her Common App list, and said she liked that their early childhood education program has a required internship at the elementary school five minutes from their house.
We finished up, cleared the crumbs off the table, and walked to the corner store for ice cream. I still get this question every fall, from parents who’ve heard so many different things they can’t keep it straight. There’s no big secret, no hidden hierarchy that people aren’t telling you about. Some kids thrive in the big, busy environment of a university, with hundreds of clubs and research opportunities. Some do better in small colleges, where they get more one-on-one time with professors. Some start at a community college and end up with a graduate degree from a top university, and some go straight to a four-year college and love every minute. The name on the building doesn’t determine how good your kid’s experience will be. That still holds, even after 12 years of answering this question. It’s just a name, after all.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Is The Actual Difference Between University And College: Answers For Parents Of High Schoolers