Why I Didn’t Realize How Much of a Person a 17 Month Old Is
We were halfway through breakfast when the yogurt pouch incident happened. My daughter had spent the last ten minutes smearing the contents into her hair, and when I peeled the empty pack out of her hands to toss it, she started screaming like I had taken a limb, not a piece of trash. I did what any reasonable adult does. I offered her mashed banana. She knocked it off the tray. I offered Cheerios. She turned her head. I offered the orange sippy cup instead of the blue one. She went silent, grabbed it, and took a long, satisfied sip.
That was the moment I realized I’d been treating her like a baby. She didn’t just want a drink. She wanted the orange cup. Not because it was better—it was the same water—but because she had a preference, and in the chaos of breakfast, I hadn’t consulted her.
Since then, I’ve started watching her more closely. She’s 17 months old, and honestly, I didn’t think a toddler this small could have that much going on inside. But she does. She knows which book we read at naptime. She knows the sequence of events that comes after dinner. If I try to skip the part where she waves at the mailman from the window, she’ll come over, take my hand, and pull me toward the living room. She isn’t just reacting to the day. She’s expecting it.
The hardest part is realizing how often I’ve been the problem. We went to the park last week, and I spent the entire trip trying to keep shoes on her feet. She screamed every time I crouched down to Velcro them back on. Finally, I let her walk barefoot across the grass. She took three slow steps, stopped, pressed her weight down, and giggled. Then she sat down, touched the blades, and looked up at me like I’d unlocked a hidden game. I hadn’t. I’d just backed off and let her feel the texture.
I’m starting to learn that a lot of what looks like stubbornness is actually intention. My daughter isn’t trying to be difficult when she yanks the spoon out of my hand and aims it at the bowl. She’s trying to feed herself. When we’re in the bathroom and she screams because I reached for the faucet first, it’s not a tantrum. It’s a correction. She wanted to turn the handle herself. She has a picture in her head of how this is supposed to go, and I keep interrupting it.
The practical answer, for us, has been choices. Small ones. At breakfast, I ask, “Do you want the blue bowl or the green bowl?” Before bath, I set out two towels and let her pick. It takes me ten extra seconds, and sometimes she just stares at me like I’ve offered her a physics problem, but when she does respond—when she points at the green towel and then stands there with her arms up—the whole routine moves smoother. It’s not magic. It’s control. She wants a vote.
I also learned to stop rushing to fix things. Last week, she was trying to get her stuffed bunny out from under the couch. She had her whole arm wedged underneath, and she was getting frustrated, huffing and pushing. My instinct was to grab the bunny and hand it to her. I didn’t. I sat on the floor nearby and waited. She pulled out the bunny, hugged it, and went on playing. She didn’t need me to solve it. She needed me to let her work through it.
This has changed how I see the so-called terrible twos. They’re not coming next year. They’re here. And they’re not about defiance. They’re about self-definition. At 17 months, she’s learning what she likes, what she remembers, and what she expects from the world. She’s noticing the difference between her will and mine. She’s testing where her power starts and ends.
Our evenings are the clearest window into this. After dinner, we sit on the floor and I hand her a stack of board books. She’ll flip through one, set it aside, and pull out another. Sometimes she brings me the same book four times in a row. It used to feel monotonous. Now I recognize it. She’s confirming what she knows. She’s not bored. She’s building a map. When she points to the dog on the page before I turn it, she’s not showing off. She’s remembering.
There are days I forget all this. I rush through the morning to get us out the door, and I don’t offer choices, and I buckle her into the car seat while she twists, and I wonder why she’s crying. When that happens, I try to slow down. Not every moment has to be a lesson. But when I catch myself getting frustrated, I remember the yogurt pouch. She wanted to hold the empty thing. She wanted to be the one to hand it to me. She had a plan.
I think that’s what I’m getting wrong less often now. I walk in assuming she’s along for the ride. But she’s not. She’s driving her own tiny car, and most of the time, she’s just trying to figure out the road. My job isn’t to grab the wheel. It’s to sit in the passenger seat, point things out, and let her take the turns at her own speed. Some days she’s ready. Some days she’s not. We’re both still figuring it out.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I Didn’t Realize How Much of a Person a 17 Month Old Is