How To Spot Passionate Young Writers and Researchers In Your Home Or Classroom
The bell for free writing had just rung last October when I leaned down to collect notebooks from the back table of my third grade class. Most kids had half a page of doodles or a quick story about a pet, and a few had crumpled blank pages tucked into their bindings. When I got to Milo’s desk, he slammed his notebook shut so hard his eraser fell on the floor. His cheeks went pink, and he tucked the book against his chest. “It’s just stupid,” he mumbled. I told him I didn’t care if it was stupid, I just wanted to see what he’d worked on. After a minute, he pushed it across the desk.
I expected a drawing of a superhero or a half-finished story about a camping trip. Instead, I found seven handwritten pages, complete with a bar graph drawn in colored pencil, titled “Splatters: Why Bark Chips Are Better Than Mulch For Our Playground.” Milo had spent three weeks counting how many kids came to the nurse with splinters after recess. He’d asked each recess aide how many splinters they picked out a day, and he’d measured how much mud stuck to shoes after rain on both surfaces. He’d even walked around the neighborhood after school to check the bark chips at the park down the street, to compare.
I’ve been teaching 12 years, and for most of that time, I thought I knew what a passionate writer or researcher looked like. They were the kids who raised their hands first every discussion, who turned in extra pages on every assignment, who signed up for writing club and competed in the regional science fair. I’d been asked by our school’s gifted and talented program just the week before to nominate kids with strong writing and research skills, and I’d almost sent the same list I send every year: the four kids who always do extra credit, who share their work at assembly.
After I read Milo’s notebook, I started thinking. How many kids are we missing? Last Christmas, my sister was complaining about my 14-year-old niece Lila, who never turned in her English homework on time, and spent all her free time on her phone instead of “doing something real.” When I asked what she was doing on her phone, my sister said she was just “wasting time writing about cartoons.” I asked Lila about it when I saw her, and she pulled up a 12-page Google doc that broke down how the main character’s personality changed across three seasons of her favorite show, cross-referenced with interviews the creator did five years apart, with side notes on how the animation team adjusted the character’s facial expressions to match the changes. That’s writing. That’s research. It just didn’t count for a grade, so no one but Lila saw it.
I don’t do big overhauls of my classroom, and I don’t expect parents to either. The first small change I made was what I ask kids every Friday. Instead of opening share time with “does anyone want to show their free writing?” I start with “who’s been working on something cool this week that’s not for homework?” It’s a 10-second swap, but every week at least one kid mentions something no one else knew about: the kid who’s counting bird nests in the backyard, the girl who’s writing a guide to all the different types of snails she finds after rain, the boy who’s comparing how fast different juice brands ferment. Most of it’s small, none of it is perfectly written or formatted, but it’s all driven by the same curiosity that makes any writer or researcher show up for their work.
I also keep a blank binder on the shelf by my classroom door, labeled just “Stuff I Wrote/Researched.” Any kid can add anything they want, anytime, no grades, no approval needed. It’s not a display for parents or visitors, just a place for kids to leave their work if they want other kids to read it. Parents can do the same thing at home for almost no effort: leave a blank notebook on the kitchen table, or a folder in a drawer, where kids can put whatever they’ve been working on, no pressure to share if they don’t want to.
What I’ve learned over the past year is that most passionate writers and researchers don’t look the way we expect. They’re not always the loud kids, they’re not always working on topics we think are important. If your kid is writing 30 pages about Minecraft redstone circuits, that’s writing. If they’re researching every different species of wild cat and taking notes on their average weights, that’s research. You don’t have to turn it into a big project or a college application bullet point. All you have to do is notice it. One small question is enough: instead of saying “that’s cool” and moving on, ask “what’s the most interesting thing you found out so far?” You don’t have to know anything about their topic, you just have to care that they care enough to do the work.
I added Milo to my nomination list that year, and the G&T program invited him to their monthly research club. He still doesn’t talk much at meetings, but he brought his bark chip study to the first meeting, and now the group is working with him to do a similar study at the middle school playground. The PTA even used his findings when they ordered new playground surface material this past spring. Last week, he added a new paper to my classroom binder: a comparison of five different pencil eraser brands, ranked by how many times you can erase a pencil mark before the eraser wears down. He included a photo of each eraser he tested, and a table of his results.
I still don’t know if Milo will ever write a novel or win a national science award. He still rarely raises his hand in whole class discussions, and he still forgets to turn in his spelling homework half the time. But he’s a writer and a researcher, the kind that asks questions and answers them on his own time, just because he wants to know. We’re still looking, every week, for more kids like him. There are always more that we’ve missed, hiding in the back of notebooks and in open browser tabs no one else sees.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How To Spot Passionate Young Writers and Researchers In Your Home Or Classroom