Practical High School Security Tips From a Teacher Who’s Seen It All
Last October, I stood in the hallway outside my 10th grade English class sipping lukewarm coffee, watching a 20-kid line back up from the main entrance after a random security check. Jake, my student who stays after class every Wednesday to talk about graphic novels, was hunched against the cinder block wall, face pink, because he’d left his student ID on his kitchen counter that morning. The policy back then was any kid without an ID had to walk a quarter-mile across campus to the attendance office to get a printed temp pass, which meant he’d miss the first 20 minutes of his AP Bio quiz. By the time the security guard could leave his post to walk Jake down, the line had stretched so far no one could see who was coming in or out of the building anyway.
I’ve been teaching at this suburban high school for 12 years, and I have a 16-year-old daughter who’s a junior here, so I get asked all the time by new parents and new teachers what actually works for high school security. Most of the time, the stuff that makes the news and gets school boards applause doesn’t actually make anyone safer. It’s just the small, boring changes that make the biggest difference.
After Jake’s incident, a bunch of us teachers talked to Mr. Torres, our head of security, who’s been here longer than I have and complains just as much as we do about dumb policies. We suggested keeping a pack of cheap blank sticker name tags at every entrance, instead of sending kids all the way across campus. If you forget your ID, you write your name and grade on a sticker, put it on your shirt, and go to class. First offense is a warning, second is a call home after school, no big deal. That change cut entrance line wait times by 75% the first month, and it eliminated the huge crowds that used to block the front doors – crowds that are a far bigger security risk than a kid without an ID. It’s a tiny change that costs less than $20 a year for new stickers, but it’s made a huge difference in how smoothly mornings go.
A few years back, the district mandated all classroom doors be locked at all times, which sounds good on paper. But what it meant in practice was that any kid who stepped out to go to the bathroom or get a drink of water was stuck standing in the hallway for 10 minutes while we finished a lesson, fumbling for our keys. Loitering kids in empty hallways are the thing we actually need to worry about, not an unlocked door when 25 kids are in the room with me. I looked for a fix, and ended up buying a $12 magnetic door holder for my classroom that mounts to the wall. It holds the door open just enough to get in and out when I’m teaching, but it pulls right off the magnet and slams locked if anyone tries to force it open. I showed it to admin, they ended up buying them for every teacher in the building. No more kids stuck in the hall, no more breaking rules propping doors open with textbooks.
Anonymous tip lines are standard now, but for years ours was only listed on page 7 of the student handbook. No one knew the number, so no one used it. Two years ago, our PTA pitched in to print small stickers with the tip line number and a QR code that takes you straight to the reporting form. We stuck them on the back of every student ID, inside every bathroom stall door, and on the lower right corner of every classroom desk. The first year we had those stickers, we got three times as many tips as the year before, and one of them was a credible threat we were able to address before anything happened. A 9th grader told me later she’d been too scared to talk to a teacher face to face, but she pulled out her phone during study hall and scanned the code on her desk. That accessibility makes all the difference, and it cost less than $500 to print and stick all those stickers.
Mr. Torres told me once that the best security tool he has is knowing every kid’s name. When he started, security staff spent all day sitting at the front desk or watching camera feeds. Now, we have four security guards, and at least one of them is walking the hallways between every period, and every one of them eats lunch in the cafeteria, not the office. They don’t just walk around looking for rule-breakers – they ask freshmen how their first cross country meet went, they help kids fix broken bike locks, they sit with kids who don’t have anyone to eat with. Last year, a sophomore told Mr. Torres that another student had been posting about bringing a gun to school, because Mr. Torres had sat with him for 45 minutes after his parents split up a few months before. The kid trusted him, so he said something. Shifting staff schedules to make that connection possible didn’t cost anything extra, just a rethinking of what security is supposed to do.
We still get it wrong a lot. We do too many unannounced lockdown drills that interrupt class and leave kids anxious, and the school board still keeps talking about adding 50 more cameras instead of hiring a fifth security guard to cover the back parking lot after school. The clear backpack policy we tried three years ago cost the district $20,000 and didn’t catch a single thing before we got rid of it. It’s never going to be perfect.
Last week, I was leaving school and saw Jake – he still forgets his ID once a month, now just grabs a sticker and heads to class without stress – stop to say hi to Mr. Torres on his way out to the parking lot. A group of freshmen clustered around one of the bathroom QR codes the other day, and I thought it’s never the big, flashy changes that work. It’s the small stuff that makes it easier for kids to go to school, easier for staff to see what’s going on, and easier for everyone to speak up when something feels wrong. We’re still tweaking, still learning, but those small adjustments have made our school feel safer than any strict policy I’ve ever seen rolled out.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Practical High School Security Tips From a Teacher Who’s Seen It All