Why Your Teen Might Ask ‘Is Life Even Worth Living?’ And What To Do Next
The final bell had just blared, rain streaked the portable classroom windows, and I was stacking dog-eared grammar workbooks next to my half-cold coffee when Mia lingered by the door. She’s a quiet 10th grader, turns in all her work on time, always has her gray hood pulled up over her ponytail, and her canvas bag has a peeling orange cat sticker on the strap. We’d just finished discussing Hamlet’s “To be or not to be” that morning, and she’d turned in her essay with that question scrawled in the margin, underlined twice: Do people really find life worth living? Then she asked it out loud: “I wasn’t just asking for the essay. Do you actually think most people mean it when they say life is great?”
After 12 years of teaching high school, I know my old instinct would’ve been to walk her straight down to the counselor’s office, or launch into a speech about all she has going for her, how it gets better after high school. But I’ve learned that doesn’t work. So I pulled out the extra chair by my desk, patted the seat, and said “That’s such a heavy question to carry. What made you think about it this week?”
She sat down, twisted her bag strap until her knuckles went pale, and talked. Her mom picked up a third weekend shift to pay for their car repair bill, so they haven’t eaten dinner together in three weeks. Her best friend moved to Oregon over the summer, and texts back less and less every week. She studies for three nights for chemistry tests and still gets a B-. Every time she hints that she feels this way on TikTok or to her aunt, she gets the same thing: just count your blessings, it gets worse when you’re older, just think positive. So she stopped talking about it.
I didn’t tell her she was wrong to feel that way. I said, “You know, last Wednesday after parent-teacher conferences, I spent 40 minutes walking around the parking lot in the rain looking for my car keys. I checked every classroom, checked my bag three times, even called my husband to ask if I’d left them on the counter at home. Turned out they were in the front pocket of my rain jacket the whole time. I sat down on the curb right there and thought, what is even the point of any of this if I can’t keep track of my own keys?” She snort-laughed, that kind of surprised laugh she doesn’t do much, and said “Really?” I said “Yeah. Some days I don’t think it’s worth it either. Not the big dramatic way, just the mundane, annoying way. Most days are just a lot of little stuff that doesn’t go right.”
We sat quiet for a minute after that, and I asked her, if she had to name three tiny things that don’t totally suck right now, what would they be? No big things allowed, no “my future” or “my family” if that doesn’t feel real right now. She thought for a minute, said her 2-year-old tabby wakes her up every morning purring on her chest, even when she sets an alarm. The 7-11 by her bus stop sells blue raspberry slushies for a dollar, and they still put extra ice in like she asks. The new season of that survival show she watches comes out next Friday. That was it, three tiny things. No big grand meaning to life, just three small okay things.
The bell for after-school study hall rang, she grabbed her bag and headed out, and that was that. I read her essay later that night, and she added a line at the bottom: “No adult ever says it’s okay to think it’s not worth it some days. They just act like you’re crazy if you ask.”
As a teacher and a mom to a 13-year-old, I see this question pop up more and more these days, and most adults get it wrong. We treat any existential question from a teen as an automatic crisis, or we jump to fix it before we even listen. The truth is, asking this question is a normal part of growing up. When kids hit early adolescence, they start being able to think abstractly for the first time. All the unspoken rules they just accepted as kids—go to school, get good grades, get a job, be happy—stop making sense just because someone says they should. They’re testing out what they actually believe, and that means asking the big scary questions first. That doesn’t mean they’re suicidal, of course it’s always important to ask directly if they’re thinking about hurting themselves. Most of the time, though, it just means they’re developing the ability to think for themselves.
There are a few small, concrete things that work better than the default speeches, from what I’ve seen. First, don’t rush to reassure. If your kid or student asks this, don’t lead with “Of course it is! You have so much to live for.” That just shuts the conversation down immediately. Instead, use that line I used: “That’s such a hard question to carry. What made you think about that today?” That’s it, just open the space. Second, don’t argue with their feelings. Don’t list all their accomplishments or all the people that love them to prove they should feel grateful. They don’t need proof that they’re wrong, they just need to be able to say how they feel. Third, normalize the feeling by sharing a small, mundane struggle of your own, not a big dramatic story. You don’t have to overshare, just a 1-sentence story like my key incident lets them know they’re not broken for feeling this way. Fourth, if you talk about what works, let them name the tiny things. Big answers like “changing the world” or “building a family” don’t feel real to a 14-year-old who’s just trying to get through chemistry class. Tiny, dumb, small things are enough.
I saw Mia in the hallway last week. She was walking with a new girl from her art class, both of them holding blue raspberry slushies, her cat sticker still peeling on her bag. She waved at me, and I waved back, and that was it. I still don’t know if she’s found a solid answer to that question. I haven’t, most days. Some weeks it feels like every small good thing outweighs the annoying stuff, some weeks it doesn’t. The best thing we can do for the kids asking isn’t to give them a neat answer. It’s just to let them ask the question without making them feel bad for it.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Your Teen Might Ask ‘Is Life Even Worth Living