Why Schools Should Prioritize Emotional Education: A Teacher’s Real Classroom Experience
I was grading last-minute spelling quizzes at my desk last Wednesday when the yelling started. Mia, 9, with a side braid that’s always coming loose, burst through the classroom door first, face streaked with angry tears. Javi, 10, who’s barely 4 foot 10 but plays like he’s a linebacker, followed, fist clenched so tight his knuckles were white. The soccer ball they’d been fighting over bounced off my desk, knocked over a cup of colored pencils, and sent 20 of them rolling across the linoleum.
For the first 10 years I taught 4th grade, this is where the story would have gone: I’d have raised my voice, asked who started it, written both names on the behavior board, sent one to the office, called both parents after school, and moved on to get back to my reading lesson. We’d have sorted out who owned the shot on the goal, handed out consequences, and that would be the end of it.
That day was different. We’d started doing 10-minute morning mood check-ins three weeks prior, after I realized I couldn’t keep up with all the small, heavy things kids were bringing to class that no one was talking about. So instead of asking who started it, I bent down to pick up a handful of pencils, told both of them to sit on the couch by our reading nook, and pulled the granola bar I keep in my desk drawer for kids who forget lunch. I handed it to Javi first, then said, “Before you tell me what the other person did, tell me how you feel right now.”
Mia got it out first: her mom lost her waitressing job the night before, and she’d stayed up listening to her parents fight about rent, so she’d been shaky all morning. She just wanted to run around to stop thinking about it, and when Javi called her shot out of bounds, everything just blew up. Javi mumbled that his dad’s been working double shifts at the warehouse all month, and he’d forgotten to pack a snack three days in a row. He’d been hungry since 9 a.m., and everything felt annoying, and he’d pushed her without thinking.
By the end of it, both of them were apologizing, not just for yelling, but for not seeing that the other person was having a bad day. The whole conversation took 12 minutes. That’s 12 minutes I didn’t get to spend on the reading lesson I’d planned. But that’s 12 minutes that didn’t end with two kids sent home upset, a half hour of admin work writing behavior reports, and two parents stressed out after work.
I’ve been teaching long enough to see the shift. Ten years ago, most behavior issues I saw were kids acting out because they were bored, or they wanted attention. Now, most of the time, kids act out because they don’t have words for what they’re feeling. A year and a half ago, we had a student who refused to do any math work for three straight weeks. He got sent to the office three times, got three detentions, before our part-time counselor finally got it out of him: he was convinced his grandma, who lived with him, was going to have a heart attack while he was at school, and he couldn’t focus on anything because he was too scared. No one had thought to ask him why he wasn’t working. Everyone just assumed he was being defiant.
The pushback I hear from admins and school boards is always the same: we don’t have time for this. We have to hit test benchmarks, we have to cover the curriculum, we don’t have extra funding for extra programs. What a lot of people don’t see is that when kids don’t learn how to name and manage their feelings, you end up spending way more time putting out fires than you would spending 10 minutes a day checking in.
The things we’re doing don’t cost much, and they don’t take much time. We have a magnetic board by the door with numbers 1 through 5. 1 means you’re so upset you can barely sit still, 5 means you’re calm and ready to learn. Kids move their name magnet to the right number when they walk in, and that’s it. No one has to talk about it if they don’t want to. It just lets me know who needs an extra check-in before class starts. I have a calm down bin by the door with fidget toys, a coloring book, and a stuffed rabbit a parent donated last year. Kids can go there for two minutes to breathe without asking permission if they feel themselves getting too worked up. That’s all it is. No fancy program, no extra training.
For parents whose kids’ schools haven’t started this work, it’s easy to bring it home. Instead of asking “how was school?” every night, which always gets you the answer “fine,” ask them what number they’d give their day from 1 to 5, using the same scale. It gives them a starting point to talk about what’s bugging them, instead of just brushing it off. If you’re talking to your kid’s teacher about adding this to the classroom, you can even offer to help put the board or bin together for free, to take work off their plate.
I still have bad days. Last week, I rushed through check-ins because we had a standardized test to get through, and by 10 a.m. two kids got into a shoving match over a broken crayon that would’ve been avoided if I’d stopped to see they were both already frustrated before the test started. Our district still only has one counselor for every five elementary schools, so we do most of this work on our own time, with supplies we buy ourselves. There’s still a long way to go before this is part of every school day, not just something extra teachers add if they have the energy.
But last month, I looked up from my desk and saw Javi walk over to Mia, who was sitting alone at lunch picking at her sandwich after her mom’s job interview fell through. He pulled an extra cookie out of his lunch bag and handed it to her. No one told him to do that. He just knew she was having a hard time, because he’d had a hard time too, and we’d practiced talking about it. That’s the whole point, isn’t it? We don’t need to fix every bad feeling a kid has. We just need to teach them they don’t have to carry it alone.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Schools Should Prioritize Emotional Education: A Teacher’s Real Classroom Experience