Car Seat Recommendations for a 63 Pound 6 Year Old: What I Learned After Shopping Wrong Twice
Last month, I stood in my driveway staring at my 6-year-old son Leo’s old car seat, sunblock oozing out of its cracked cup holder, while he jumped up and down waving a neon water gun, yelling that we were going to be late to the lake. I’d just taken Leo for his 6-year checkup, and the nurse wrote his weight down clear as day: 63 pounds. His old convertible topped out at 65, so technically he had two pounds left to grow, but his shoulders were brushing the sides, and for the last three school runs he’d complained his legs went numb on the way. I’d put off buying a new seat because car seat shopping is the worst, but that day I couldn’t put it off anymore.
First I went the cheap, easy route. I grabbed a backless booster off the end cap at Target, because I’d heard once your kid hits 40 pounds they’re fine in a booster, and 63 is way over that. Got it home, heaved it into the back row, strapped Leo in. The lap belt sat right across his soft little tummy, not the hard hip bones it’s supposed to, and when he leaned his head back against the car, it was just resting on the plastic window ledge. I took him around the block, and 10 minutes in he fell asleep, his head lolled forward onto his chest, and I kept swerving to check on him. I knew right then it wasn’t going to work.
I took it back, and next I got a slim high-back booster everyone raved about online. That one fit better, but the headrest only adjusted down so far. Leo’s torso is still pretty short for his weight, he got that from me, so the top of the headrest hit him right at the base of his skull, not above his shoulders like it’s supposed to. Another return, two weekends in a row I’d spent dragging car seats in and out of my minivan, and I was annoyed enough to text my cousin who does child passenger safety checks on the side for free. I told her my problem: 6 year old, 63 pounds, what the hell do I buy that’s actually safe?
She told me something I’d totally forgotten, even though I’d read all the car seat guides when Leo was a baby. Most parents rush to move kids out of 5-point harnesses way too early. The guidelines say to keep kids in a harnessed car seat as long as possible before moving them to a booster, and plenty of 60 to 65 pound 6 year olds still fit just fine in one. The thing is, a 5-point harness holds them in place way better than a vehicle seat belt ever can at that size, because the seat belt is made for full-grown adults. For a kid that’s 63 pounds, you don’t have to force a booster if the harness still fits. That clicked for me, because I’d been thinking “6 year old = booster” just because of his age, not his actual body.
She walked me through what would work, based on what I needed: I carpool three kids to soccer twice a week, so it can’t be too bulky, and it has to be under $200. I ended up going with the Graco Milestone 3-in-1, and it’s been perfect. It holds up to 65 pounds in the 5-point harness, which fits Leo right now with a little room to grow. The harness adjusts from the front, so I don’t have to take the whole seat apart to tighten or loosen it when he’s wearing a bulky winter coat. It fits narrow enough to sit between two other seats in my minivan’s middle row, which I didn’t think was possible with a harnessed seat. It’s held up well to goldfish crumbs and spilled apple juice, too.
If your kid refuses a harness, which plenty of 6 year olds do because they want to be just like their older friends who use boosters, she recommended the Chicco KidFit ClearTex Plus high-back booster. I tested that one too before I settled on the harness, and it’s great. The belt guides lock the seat belt into the right spot automatically, so I never have to squint and adjust it 10 times to make sure the lap belt is low enough across the hips. It goes up to 100 pounds, so it’ll last until he’s ready for no booster at all, and the cover comes right off to throw in the wash when he spills Gatorade on it. For anyone who just needs a backup seat for grandma’s car or occasional carpooling, a backless booster is fine if that’s all you have room for, and the Graco TurboBooster Backless is lightweight, cheap, and gets the job done for occasional use. I just wouldn’t use it as a daily seat for a 63 pound 6 year old, that’s my take.
We installed the Milestone the night before our lake trip, and I double checked the straps with the pincher test, you should only be able to fit one finger under the strap, that’s what my cousin told me, and we headed out. Thirty minutes in, Leo was asleep, his head resting against the padded side of the seat, no lolling, no complaints. I didn’t spend the whole drive glancing in the rearview mirror the way I did with the first two seats. When we got there, he climbed right out and ran for the water, no numb legs, no complaining.
I still have that first backless booster I bought in the back of my hall closet, waiting for the day we need to carry an extra kid somewhere. I know in another year, Leo will hit 65 pounds, and we’ll move him to a high-back booster, and he’ll probably brag to all his friends that he has a big kid seat. For right now, this works. Car seat shopping doesn’t have to be some big complicated thing where you buy the most expensive seat on the market. You just have to ignore the unwritten rule that 6 year olds have to use boosters, and pick what fits your kid’s actual weight and body, not what you think you’re supposed to buy. That’s the thing I wish someone had told me before I made two wrong trips to the store.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Car Seat Recommendations for a 63 Pound 6 Year Old: What I Learned After Shopping Wrong Twice