Why Schools Should Prioritize Emotional Education: A Fourth Grade Teacher’s Observation
The heater in my 4th grade classroom was humming too loud last Tuesday, half the kids were already daydreaming about spring break, and we were halfway through our fraction unit test when I saw Leo crumple his paper into a ball and hurl it under his desk. He dropped his forehead into his arms and didn’t move for three minutes.
Leo is the kid who always turns his homework in early, helps the kindergartners tie their shoes after lunch, and once stayed after school to reorganize my bookshelf just because he said it “bugged him” that the poetry books were mixed in with the graphic novels. I’ve never seen him blow up at anything.
I wandered over, leaned against his desk so I wouldn’t draw the whole class’s attention, and picked up the crumpled test when he didn’t move. He’d gotten a 92. The only mistake was the last word problem, where he mixed up miles and feet. I knelt down and whispered, “Want to tell me what that’s about?”
His voice was muffled in his sleeve: “I’m stupid. I always mess up.”
I sat down on the floor next to his desk, which made a couple kids glance over, but I didn’t care. I remembered two weeks earlier, he’d pulled me aside after recess to say his mom lost her job at the grocery store, and now they were staying with his grandma until they found a new place. He said his dad kept saying “no more mistakes, we can’t afford any more mistakes” right now.
I didn’t tell him to calm down, I didn’t remind him it was just a test, I didn’t send him to the counselor’s office to cool off like the student handbook would suggest I do. I just said, “It feels really scary to mess up right now, doesn’t it? Like one wrong thing could make everything harder for your family.”
He nodded, and cried quiet, shoulder-shaking cries for a minute, then wiped his face on his sleeve and said he was ready to go back. We fixed the problem together after class, and that was that. But it got me thinking: how many times a week do we miss moments like this, because we’re too busy pushing through the lesson plan to get to the next test deadline?
Last month I sat in a parent-teacher conference with a mom whose son has straight A’s across the board. She told me he refuses to try out for the school play, won’t raise his hand in class even when he knows the answer, and says he’d rather get a bad grade than be wrong in front of everyone. Two weeks before that, I broke up a fight on the playground where two 9-year-olds were pulling each other’s hair because neither of them could say “I feel hurt that you copied my art project and got more compliments than me.” They just knew they felt bad, and hitting was the only way they knew how to get that feeling out.
Right now, most schools tuck emotional education into a 10-minute advisory period once a week, or a one-off assembly about bullying, and call it done. We count test scores and attendance rates and college acceptance numbers, and we treat big feelings like a disruption to the real work of school. But the real work of school is teaching kids how to be people, not just how to fill in a bubble sheet.
I started doing a tiny thing in my classroom this year that takes less than two minutes every morning: I taped a poster by the door with three colors: blue for calm, red for wobbly or upset, yellow for excited or energized. When kids walk in, they tap the color that matches how they feel that day. It doesn’t sound like much, but it changes everything. I know immediately if I need to check in with a kid before class starts, instead of finding out 20 minutes into math that they’re too upset to focus.
For parents who want to do this at home, it works at dinner too. Instead of asking “how was school” that always gets “fine,” ask everyone at the table what color they felt most that day, and one small thing that made them feel that way. It takes 30 extra seconds, and it gets kids talking about their feelings without them feeling like they’re being interrogated.
When a kid is upset, instead of saying “just calm down” or “it’s not that big of a deal,” try naming the feeling for them. “You sound really angry that your friend didn’t save you a spot at lunch.” That helps them learn to put words to what they’re feeling, which is the first step to handling it. If you’re a teacher, next time you pass back a test, write one quick sentence about their effort instead of just a number. “I saw you stuck with this problem for 10 minutes, that’s the hard work that matters” takes 5 seconds to write, and it sticks with a kid way longer than the number at the top of the page.
I won’t say this fixes everything. Last week, a 4th grader tapped red three days in a row, and I was so busy getting ready for state practice tests that I didn’t have time to pull him aside for five minutes. Ten minutes into the test, he threw his reading booklet across the room and refused to work. I knew it was coming, I just didn’t make space for it. That’s the problem right now: we ask teachers to fit emotional education in on top of everything else we have to do, instead of building it into the day. Schools have to stop treating it like an extra add-on, and start making time for it, even if that means cutting 10 minutes of test prep a day.
We’ve only been doing the daily check-ins at our school for three months. We still have fights on the playground, we still have kids who shut down during tests, we still have days where everything falls apart. But I’ve noticed half as many kids get sent to the office this semester as last year. Leo told me last week he’s going to try out for the 5th grade soccer team next fall — he told me back in January he was too scared to try, because he might miss a goal and let the team down. That’s the thing that’s sticking with me. Kids don’t need to be perfect to be successful. They just need to know how to name what they’re feeling, and how to keep going even when it’s hard. That’s the stuff they’ll use long after they forget what a fraction is.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Schools Should Prioritize Emotional Education: A Fourth Grade Teacher’s Observation