Why My Teen Called Their Math Teacher A Bitch (And What I Learned About School Conflict)
The backpack hit the kitchen counter so hard the half-empty mug of coffee I’d been sipping slipped an inch to the left. I was matching stray socks from my 13-year-old’s laundry basket when he looked up at me, red-faced, and said it: “My math teacher is a bitch.” I’d never heard him drop that word on anyone, let alone a school staff member, and I almost dropped the pair of neon basketball socks I was holding.
He slammed the crumpled test down on the counter, and there it was: a D- scrawled in red pen at the top, every problem marked wrong even though I could see the numbers scribbled on the back of the page. “I did all of it,” he said, voice cracking a little. “She didn’t even flip it over. When I went up after class to tell her, she yelled at me in front of everyone for not following directions, said I was making excuses because I didn’t do the work. I just asked Jake for a pencil, for God’s sake. She said I was passing notes.”
My first two impulses were both wrong. First, I wanted to grab my phone and fire off an angry email to the principal and Mrs. Lopez, copying the PTA president for good measure. Second, I almost defaulted to the thing my parents always did when I complained about a teacher: “Well, you must have done something to get her riled up. Teachers don’t just act that way for no reason.” But I paused, because I remembered a conversation I had with a friend who teaches middle school a few months back. She said when a kid uses that kind of language about an adult at school, it’s almost never just disrespect. It’s the only way they know how to say “I’m so powerless and frustrated here I can’t breathe anymore.”
I pulled out the chair next to him, grabbed an orange Crush from the fridge (his favorite, the kind I only buy when he’s had a bad day), and said, “Go all the way back to the start of this week. Tell me every single thing that’s bugged you about this class, no matter how small it seems.” I didn’t interrupt, I didn’t correct his swearing, I just nodded. By the end of it, I learned the D on the test wasn’t the first problem. For three weeks straight, Mrs. Lopez had called him out for talking when he was just asking the kid next to him for a tissue. She knocked 10% off his last quiz because he used the wrong size graph paper, even though every answer was correct. He’d been raising his hand to ask for clarification on homework every other day, and she’d walked right past him three times in a row. He’d worked his ass off over the summer to get into this advanced math class, too—he did six weeks of extra math camp just to qualify—so every small slight felt like proof he didn’t belong there anyway.
I still didn’t jump in. Instead of planning my attack, I asked him what he wanted out of this. Did he want me to email the teacher? Did he want to switch classes? Or did he just want to get it off his chest? He thought for a minute and said he wanted his points back, and he wanted her to stop calling him out in front of people. I said okay, let’s work on that together. I didn’t write the email for him. I sat next to him while he wrote it, and helped him tweak the wording to be calm instead of yelling. The finished email said, “I wanted to ask if we could meet for five minutes before school this week to talk about my last test. I did all the work on the back, and I’ve been confused about a few things that have happened in class lately, and I want to figure out how to do better in your class.” We copied me, sent it, and waited.
She wrote back the same day, said she’d meet us. When we got there, I didn’t do all the talking. I let him say everything he’d told me at home, word for word. What happened next wasn’t the big dramatic apology I half expected. Mrs. Lopez sighed and said she’d had a terrible fall. Her 10-year-old was having ongoing asthma issues that kept her up at night, she’d been covering an extra class for a teacher on medical leave, and she was more short-tempered than she meant to be. She admitted she didn’t flip over the test, and gave him back half the points he lost. She agreed that if he drew a small arrow on the front pointing to extra work on the back, she’d be sure to check it. She said she’d pay more attention before calling him out for talking. It wasn’t perfect, but it was something.
That’s the thing no one tells you when your kid says something that harsh about a teacher. Most of the time, it’s not a situation where one person is 100% right and the other is 100% wrong. My kid wasn’t being rude just for the sake of being rude. He was using the strongest word he knew to tell me he couldn’t handle the stress on his own anymore. Mrs. Lopez wasn’t some evil villain. She was a person stretched too thin, who didn’t realize how her behavior was landing on a kid who was already nervous about being in over his head.
The small, specific steps we took here work for almost any school conflict, I’ve found. First, don’t lead with punishing the swearing. If you stop everything to yell at your kid for using a bad word before you hear why they’re that upset, they’ll stop telling you how they really feel. I said to my son after he calmed down that the word is harsh and disrespectful to use about people most of the time, but I got why he needed to say it, and that didn’t count as a punishable offense this time. Second, let your kid lead the fixing as much as they can. I didn’t have to fight his battle for him. I just had to help him practice fighting it himself. Third, don’t go in looking for someone to get in trouble or a big dramatic win. Most of the time, you just need a small adjustment that makes the rest of the semester bearable, and that’s enough.
It’s still not perfect. Last week, he came home grumbling that she knocked five points off his homework because his binder tabs weren’t labeled the exact way she wanted. He rolled his eyes and said “she’s still a lot,” but he didn’t yell that word again. He just grabbed a pack of new labels and fixed it, and that was that. We don’t have a perfect happy ending where he and Mrs. Lopez became best friends. But he learned how to say what he needs, and I learned that sometimes the ugliest things my kid says are the ones I need to listen to the most.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why My Teen Called Their Math Teacher A Bitch (And What I Learned About School Conflict)