Why Most Teen Financial Literacy Doesn’t Stick (I’m Looking For Testers For My New Course)
Last July, I stood at my sister’s kitchen counter wiping cherry popsicle juice off my wrist while my 16-year-old niece Lila leaned over the island, squinting at her bank app. She’d just gotten her first paycheck from the local coffee shop, three weeks of 6 a.m. opening shifts and mopping up spilled oat milk. “I counted 28 hours,” she said, poking the screen with a chipped neon nail. “That should be almost $350. Where did $92 go?” I asked if she’d looked at the deductions section. She scrolled up, blinked, and asked what FICA was. When I said it’s a tax for Social Security, she shrugged and said, “Why am I paying for that when I’m 16 and won’t retire for 50 years?”
I’ve taught 10th grade business basics at a public high school for 12 years, so this isn’t a new conversation. Every fall, I start the semester with the same quick check-in: I ask how many students can explain what a credit score is, how credit card interest works, and the difference between a federal student loan and a private one. Less than one in 10 can answer two out of three. The financial literacy content most schools offer right now is stale. It’s worksheets about balancing paper checkbooks that no one under 25 has ever used, or 10-year-old videos about predatory lending that feel abstract to a kid who’s just trying to save up for a new gaming console. I’ve watched dozens of smart, capable teens graduate high school every year with no clue how to read a pay stub, much less pick a loan for college or a car.
Last year, one of my former students stopped by my classroom to ask for advice. She’d graduated two years prior, started a cosmetology program at community college, and took out a private student loan because she didn’t know federal loans had lower fixed interest rates. Her balance was already $3,000 higher than she borrowed, even before she finished her certification, because of accruing interest. That conversation stuck with me. I started pulling together lesson plans that actually match what teens deal with right now, and over the last eight months, that turned into a full 6-module course for 13-18 year olds.
It’s built around 30-minute sessions, each with a 10-minute activity that ties to their actual life. After the pay stub module, they pull up their own bank account to check their deductions, or use a sample check to calculate what their first real paycheck will actually be. Instead of talking about compound interest in vague terms, I show them what happens if they put $50 a month from their part-time job into a high-yield savings account for a used car, versus spending it all on fast food and fast fashion. I added a section on tipping etiquette and splitting bills on Venmo, after my 14-year-old son pointed out that’s the financial question he deals with every weekend that no one ever talks about.
I didn’t build this to get rich or make a name for myself. I built it because I haven’t found anything out there that meets teens where they are. And that’s why I’m looking for honest testers right now. I’m just one 40-year-old teacher making this after school and on weekends, and I know I’m going to miss stuff. I already got feedback from a fellow teacher who tested the first module with her class that the credit score section felt irrelevant to her 15-year-olds who don’t plan to get a credit card any time soon. I need that kind of unfiltered honesty: what’s boring, what’s useless, what did I leave out that you or your kid actually want to know?
What I’ve learned from all these years of talking to teens and parents about money is that most of the problem isn’t that kids don’t want to learn, it’s that we teach the wrong stuff at the wrong time. Even if you don’t test my course, there are small, concrete things you can do this week to teach your teen more than any textbook can. Next time you’re sitting at dinner and your teen is scrolling their phone, pull up your own latest pay stub and show them the deduction lines. It takes two minutes. Point out how much comes out for taxes, how much your health insurance costs, and explain that the salary number on a job offer isn’t the money you actually take home. When your teen asks for money for a new $150 jacket, have them calculate how many hours of their part-time job they need to work to pay for it after taxes. I did this with Lila after that July paycheck conversation, and she decided she didn’t need the new AirPods she’d been begging for after all – that was 12 opening shifts, which she decided wasn’t worth it.
A lot of parents tell me they don’t want to talk about money with their kids because they don’t feel like they’re good with money themselves. That’s actually a good thing. You don’t have to be a financial expert to teach this stuff. If you messed up and got stuck with credit card debt when you were young, tell them that story. It’s way more memorable than a generic rule about not overspending. My mom told me when I was 17 about the $2,000 credit card balance she carried at my age that took her three years to pay off, and that story stuck with me way more than any high school class I ever took.
Right now, I’m looking for two groups of testers: parents of teens 13-18 who want to let their kid go through the course for free, and high school or middle school teachers who want to use it in their classroom for free. All I ask in return is that you fill out a 10-question survey at the end, and if you’re up for it, a 15-minute call to tell me what worked and what didn’t. No catch, no requirement to leave a positive review, I just want real feedback.
I don’t know if this course will end up being widely useful. I might throw out half the content after I get tester feedback and start over on some sections. That’s the point, though. We’ve had enough generic, disconnected financial literacy content for teens. I just want something that actually helps them navigate the small, daily money stuff they deal with right now, before they have to make big, life-altering decisions about loans and apartments that are hard to undo. If that’s something you or your teen would be willing to help me build, I’d love to hear from you.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Most Teen Financial Literacy Doesn’t Stick (I’m Looking For Testers For My New Course)