Why Kids Refuse to Wear Anything That Covers Their Head: Practical Tips for Parents and Teachers
I stood at my first-grade classroom door last month, wiping frost off the doorframe, when Mia and her mom pulled up. It was 37 degrees outside, and Mia’s ears were already bright pink. Her mom held out a red fleece hat stitched with a unicorn pom-pom, the kind every 7-year-old seems to want these days, and Mia pressed her back against the cinder block wall, shaking her head so hard her pigtails bounced. “We fought 15 minutes in the car,” her mom said, apologetic, her own ears peeking out from under her knit beanie. “She won’t put it on. I don’t know what to do anymore. She says it’s ‘too much on her head.’”
I didn’t say anything right away, because I’ve been that parent. My son is 5, and last winter I went through three different hats, two hooded coats, and a dozen headaches trying to get him to keep anything on his head. Once, at the grocery store when it was 20 degrees out, I pulled the hood of his coat up as we walked in, and he melted down so fast he dropped his apple sauce pouch and screamed until his face turned purple. I yanked the hood off, embarrassed, and thought what every adult thinks in that moment: He’s just being stubborn. He wants to win the power struggle. He’ll get over it if we just make him wear it.
It took me three months of daily fights to realize it wasn’t defiance. It wasn’t even a preference. For him, and for a lot of kids like Mia and him, anything that rests on top of their head pulls on their hair, puts constant pressure on their scalp, or itches at their forehead in a way that’s impossible to ignore. It doesn’t just feel a little uncomfortable—it feels like wearing a tight rubber band around your temples for hours. I tested this once, after our occupational therapist mentioned it’s a common sensory sensitivity. I pulled a tight beanie on before I cleaned the kitchen, and 45 minutes later I had a dull ache so bad I had to lie down. I could take it off whenever I wanted. Why would I force a 5-year-old to live with that all day at school?
Once I stopped framing it as bad behavior, small changes started working. The first thing I changed was what I ask, instead of barking “put your hat on” when we’re running out the door. I started asking specific questions: “Does the edge scratch your forehead? Does the pom-pom pull your curls? Is it too heavy on your ears?” For Mia, that question was all she needed to open up. She nodded and touched the seam of the unicorn hat: “It itches right here, and the pom makes my head feel heavy when I run.”
The second thing I changed was ditching the expectation that a kid has to wear a hat to be warm or safe. I started keeping a pair of cheap, thin clip-on earmuffs in my classroom closet for kids who won’t wear hats. They only cover the ears, no fabric sitting on top of the head, no pressure. I keep a pack of travel SPF 50 sticks in my desk too, for sunny days when kids won’t wear hats for sun protection. For Mia, the clip-on earmuffs worked. She wore them all recess, no yanking, no fuss.
At home, we tried a dozen different options before we found what worked for my son. We tried thick beanies, thin beanies, straw hats, baseball caps—all got yanked off within two minutes. What ended up working? A $8 pair of dinosaur clip-on earmuffs for cold days, and a small portable umbrella he can hold over his head at the park on hot sunny days. We reapply SPF to his scalp every two hours when we’re outside, and if it’s really windy and we forget the earmuffs, his ears turn pink for an hour after we get inside. That’s inconvenient, but it’s better than a 20-minute fight before we leave the house that leaves both of us upset.
A lot of parents and teachers I talk to say “just make them wear it, they’ll get used to it.” That hasn’t been my experience, either as a teacher or a mom. Forcing a kid to keep something on their head when it hurts just makes them associate head coverings with stress, and it makes the fight worse the next time. Instead, test different options when you’re not rushed. Don’t try on a new hat 10 minutes before school drop off—do it on a Saturday afternoon, when you’re hanging around the house, and let your kid walk around with each option for 5 or 10 minutes to see how it feels. If none work, skip the hat. There are workarounds that don’t require a daily fight.
For school staff, it helps to have a backup plan. Don’t make it a rule that all kids have to wear a hat for outdoor recess, and don’t send a kid to the office for refusing to put one on. Keep a spare pair of earmuffs and an extra SPF stick in your closet, like I do, and that covers most situations. If it’s dangerously cold, talk through the options with the kid, don’t just demand compliance. Most of the time, they’ll agree to try earmuffs if that’s the alternative to staying inside.
My son still won’t wear anything that covers the top of his head, even two years later. I still get the occasional side-eye from other parents at the park in the middle of winter, when his head is bare and his ears are pink. I used to stop and explain, that he just can’t stand the feel of it, but now I don’t bother. It works for us. Some days we forget the earmuffs, some days the umbrella gets left in the car and I have to lather extra sunscreen on his scalp before we go into the playground. It’s not perfect, but it’s a whole lot better than starting every day with a fight.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Kids Refuse to Wear Anything That Covers Their Head: Practical Tips for Parents and Teachers