My 2 Year Old Doesn’t Seem to Like Me: Why It Happens and What Actually Helps
I turned the key in the lock at 5:47 p.m. last Tuesday, scuffed leather flats sticking a little to the porch mat where my 2-year-old Milo had spilled bubble solution the weekend before. I’d stopped at the corner bodega on my way home from the office, grabbed the organic strawberry banana pouch he always begs for at the grocery store, and even tucked a sheet of dinosaur stickers in my bag for good measure. I pushed the door open, dropped my lunch tote by the shoe rack, and leaned around the corner to where he sat cross-legged on the living room rug, stacking plastic Duplo cows on top of a plastic horse with my partner, Jake.
“Hey bug!” I said, grinning, already lowering myself to kneel on the floor. “Look what I got—”
He didn’t even let me finish. He twisted away, pressed his face into Jake’s faded college sweatpants, and mumbled so muffled I almost didn’t catch it: “No mama. Dada do it.”
That quiet, sharp little twist in the chest is familiar these days. Six months ago, I was the only person he wanted. He’d scream if I left the room to use the bathroom, fall asleep curled on my chest after nursing, light up so hard his whole body wiggled when I walked in the door after work. Now, at 2 and a half, I’m the default second choice. If he trips on the sidewalk, he pushes my hand away and screams for Dada to kiss the scrape. Bath time, only Dada is allowed to pour water over his hair. If I try to tuck him in after his story, he screams until Jake takes over, quiet within 30 seconds.
For months I turned it over in my head after everyone else was asleep. Did I work too many late nights? Did I snap at him too much when he dumped cereal on the floor that one rough week? Was I already messing this up, before he was even old enough for preschool? I dropped him off at Ms. Rita’s home daycare a few weeks later, still quiet because he’d refused to let me put his sneakers on that morning, screaming and kicking until Jake carried him to the car. Ms. Rita was slicing Honeycrisp apples at the kitchen counter, wiping juice off paint-splattered jeans, and nodded like she read the whole thing on my face.
“Honey, every single parent goes through this between 18 months and 3 years,” she said, pushing apple slices into a plastic snack bowl. “Half the kids in this room have gone through a phase where they won’t let one parent within three feet. It’s never that they don’t like you.”
What she explained next made more sense than every 2 a.m. parenting scroll I’d done. A 2-year-old’s only real job right now is figuring out they’re a separate person with their own wants, and that those wants matter. They don’t do nuance. They can’t hold “I want Dada to open my goldfish crackers right now” and “I love mama more than anything” in their head at the same time. All they know is what they want in that exact 10 seconds, and they don’t have the impulse control or vocabulary to soften it. It’s the same impulse that makes them insist on the blue cup every day for two weeks, then scream if you give them the blue cup because now they only want red. It’s preference, not judgment.
Most of the time, the favorite parent just lines up with current routine. Jake works four 10-hour shifts a week, home three full weekdays with Milo, while I’m in the office five. Right now, Dada is default for most daily tasks just because he’s the one who does them most often. It’s not a reward for better parenting, not a punishment for working late. It’s just pattern recognition.
I left daycare with three small, specific changes to test, none of which involved forcing hugs or “winning” him back with more toys. First, stop demanding attention the second I walked in the door. I used to rush right over, get in his space, ask for a kiss, rattle off 10 questions about his day, wave the special snack around like a peace offering. Ms. Rita said toddlers need 10 to 15 minutes of no-pressure transition time after being apart, same as adults don’t want to jump straight into a heavy conversation right after walking in from work.
Now when I get home, I just call “Hi Milo, I’m home” from the door, put my stuff away, pour water, and change out of work clothes before I try to interact. If he’s playing on the floor, I sit a foot or two away, pull out a few extra blocks, and do my own quiet thing. I don’t ask him to look, don’t ask what he’s building, don’t take over to make a “better” tower. The first time I tried it, he stacked his animals for three quiet minutes, then pushed a plastic sheep across the rug until it bumped my knee. He didn’t look up, didn’t say anything, but that was it. I was allowed.
Second, I stopped arguing with “Dada do it.” I used to sigh and say “Mama can open that too, buddy, why don’t you let me help?” which turned it into a power struggle, and he’d dig in harder until he screamed. Now I just say, “Okay, you want Dada to help with that right now. I’ll be over here cutting strawberries if you need me.” No guilt trip, no voicing hurt feelings, no fight. Two-year-olds don’t know their words can sting. They’re just testing that their choice gets a predictable response, and if I turn it into a fight, “no mama” just becomes a more interesting game.
The last change was one tiny, exclusive routine that only I do, no exceptions. It’s not a whole bedtime, not a big weekend outing, just two minutes every night after his bath: I rub lavender lotion on his feet, and sing the silly made-up sock monkey song I made up when he was a newborn and couldn’t sleep. Jake never steps in, never offers, never even mentions it. Now, even on the most stubborn “no mama” days, after his bath he plops down on the bath mat and holds both feet out to me before I can grab the bottle.
It’s been six weeks, and nothing is magically fixed. Some days I still get that quiet twist. Last night at dinner, he pushed my hand away when I tried to wipe spaghetti sauce off his cheek and yelled for Dada so loud the dog ran under the table. I just handed Jake the wipe and got another glass of iced tea, and didn’t think about it again two minutes later. Ten minutes after that, he climbed right into my lap, sticky as anything, hauled his half-eaten applesauce with him, and sat there for 12 whole minutes while I watched my show, no squirming, no demands for Dada.
This morning when I left for work, he dragged his favorite ragged stuffed rabbit across the floor by one ear and held it up to me. “Mama bring,” he said. He wanted me to take it with me, so I’d have it while I was gone. I tucked it into my work bag, and it’s sitting next to my keyboard right now.
I still don’t know when this phase will end. Ms. Rita says some kids flip overnight, some drag it out six months or more, and often it rotates straight to grandma-only or teacher-only the second you get used to it. I don’t get the running, grinning front-door greetings I used to daydream about on my commute. Some days I still feel like I’m on the outside of the little club he and Jake have going. But I don’t lie awake at night replaying every “no mama” anymore, wondering what I did wrong. It’s just 2-year-old stuff. Right now, that’s enough.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » My 2 Year Old Doesn’t Seem to Like Me: Why It Happens and What Actually Helps