Why I’m Fed Up With The One-Size-Fits-All Education System (And Small Changes I Make At Home)
Last Tuesday, I sat across from Leo’s 4th grade teacher in a cinder-block classroom, Goldfish crumbs stuck to the knee of my jeans, staring at his latest math test. He’d gotten every single multi-step word problem correct—the ones about splitting pizza for a birthday party, the one about calculating how much water a group would need for a 3-day camping trip. Three points off, though, for the three basic multiplication problems where he didn’t write out his work. The answer was right on every single one, but no work, no points.
His teacher leaned forward, and I could tell she felt awkward about it too. “District policy says I have to grade this way,” she said. “When the state test comes around, if he doesn’t show his work, he’ll lose points there too. It’s better he gets used to it now.”
I nodded and smiled and said I’d talk to him about it, but by the time we walked out to the car, my jaw was tight. This isn’t new. In second grade, he got a C on a reading comprehension test because he finished 10 minutes early and drew a T-Rex in the margin instead of re-reading every answer. In third grade, he had to redo a science project because he didn’t follow the exact 5-paragraph display board format the teacher asked for, even though his experiment on how light intensity affected bean sprout growth was more thorough than most.
Leo kicked a loose piece of asphalt in the parking lot and asked, “Am I bad at math now? Because the test says I got a B minus.”
That’s when it hit me how fed up I really am. It’s not that I think grades don’t matter at all, or that kids shouldn’t have to follow any rules. It’s that the system is so focused on making every kid fit the same box that it’s willing to punish the things that make my kid smart. Leo does math in his head because he can. He doesn’t need to write down 7×12 = 84 step by step when he knows the answer before he picks up the pencil. Why are we punishing him for that?
I can’t quit my job and homeschool him, and I don’t have time to go to every school board meeting and argue about testing policy. I know a lot of teachers are just as stuck as we are, following rules they didn’t make. So I started making small changes at home, things that don’t take a ton of time or money, that help push back against what the system is teaching him about what counts as smart.
The first thing I changed was how we talk about school when he gets home. For years, I’d open the front door and ask “What grade did you get on your test?” Now the first question I ask is “What was the coolest thing you worked on this week?” When he brings home a test with points off for stupid reasons, we don’t start with the grade. I first point to the work he should be proud of. Last week, when that math test came home, I said “Look at this camping problem. You figured out that you need an extra tent for the leader’s gear, that’s something most kids missed. That’s such good thinking.” We talk about the points off after that, but it’s never the main event anymore.
The second thing I do is carve out 20 minutes every Friday for what we call “no rules work.” It doesn’t count for anything, no grades, no corrections, no requirements. Leo loves drawing comic books about a team of cave explorers, so most of the time he works on that. Last month, he wanted to figure out how big a cave system would need to be to hold 120 explorers, plus storage for food and water. He sat at the kitchen table and wrote down every single step of his math, because he wanted to remember how he got the number for his comic. He didn’t complain about writing down work once, because it mattered to him. That’s when I realized the problem wasn’t that he wouldn’t show his work. It was that the system was asking him to do it for no reason he cared about.
Third, when he has to do a useless assignment that just checks a box, I help him get it done fast so we can move on to the stuff that matters. For example, now that he has to show work on every math problem for class, I told him he can do all the problems in his head first, get all the answers right, then just jot down the steps after. It takes two extra minutes, instead of 10 extra minutes of him complaining about it. Then we can go walk the dog or work on his comic or shoot hoops outside, instead of being stuck at the kitchen table doing busywork. I don’t make him fight every single battle. That wastes his energy and mine. We just jump through the small hoops quickly, then get back to the stuff that matters.
It’s not perfect. Last month, Leo said he didn’t want to join the school math bee because “even if I get all the answers right, I’ll forget to write down the work and lose.” We talked about it, and he still decided not to go, and that’s okay. I don’t force him to push through every dumb rule just to prove a point. He still gets Bs when he should get As, sometimes, because of arbitrary rules.
But lately, he hasn’t asked me if he’s bad at math anymore. Last week, he brought his cave comic into class, and his teacher hung it up on the bulletin board by the door. He came home so proud, pointing out the calculations he’d written in the corner of the last page. We still have bad nights, where he’s frustrated that he has to do work that doesn’t make sense. I still sit in the car after parent-teacher conferences with my jaw tight, wondering what we’re doing to kids that think in different ways.
I don’t have a big solution to fix the whole system. I just know what works for my kid, right now. We keep the stupid stuff small, and we make room for the stuff that actually matters. That’s enough, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I’m Fed Up With The One-Size-Fits-All Education System (And Small Changes I Make At Home)