Why I Stopped Giving Parenting Advice After This Week With My 8-Year-Old
The coffee pot gurgled off at 7:42 this morning, I was wiping strawberry jam off the toaster lever when I noticed my 8-year-old standing by the back door, staring at his rain boots like they’d personally insulted him. “C’mon,” I said, checking my phone. “Bus is 3 minutes out. Put ‘em on.” He crossed his arms. “I can’t. It’s wrong.” The wrong thing? A tiny scuff on the toe of the left boot, from when he tripped over a curb last weekend. I’d stared at that scuff for 10 seconds last night and forgot it existed. To him? It was a dealbreaker.
Ten days earlier, I stood on that same elementary school playground chatting with a mom I’d met a few times. She’d just coaxed her 7-year-old through a meltdown over a missed slide turn, and she turned to me and said, “You always seem so calm with this stuff. What do you do? I lose my mind every time.” And me, being me, I spit out the neat little answer I’d typed a hundred times in local parent groups: “I always validate first, don’t dismiss their feelings, give them space to calm down before problem-solving.” She nodded, typed it into her notes app like I’d handed her a secret formula. I left the playground feeling pretty good about myself, like I actually knew what I was doing.
Then this morning happened. I tried all that stuff I told her. I said, “I get it, scuffs are really annoying. That sucks.” I offered two choices: wear the scuffed boots, or wear the old sneakers with the hole in the toe that get your socks wet when it rains. He just sat down on the entryway floor and started hyperventilating, shoulders shaking, like the whole world had fallen apart over a ¼-inch mark on rubber.
I was already 2 minutes behind, the bus was pulling up to the stop down the street, and I didn’t do any of the calm stuff I’d bragged about. I sighed really loud. I thought bad things about overpriced kids’ rain boots. I picked him up, carried him to the car, strapped him in, and drove him to school with one bare foot sticking out of his jeans. That’s how it went. No perfect resolution, no teachable moment, just a late kid and a pair of unused boots rolling around in my trunk.
That’s not even the only messy moment this week. Wednesday I volunteered in my son’s classroom for the fall party. A tiny first grader from the other class came over, holding a tightly sealed bag of Goldfish, tears rolling down her cheeks. The night before, I’d commented on a teacher education Instagram reel that said “Never do for a kid what they can do for themselves – letting them struggle builds confidence.” So I leaned down and said, “Can you try twisting the top a little harder for me?” She tried, cried harder, and then the boy next to her reached for the bag and knocked over her full cup of apple juice all over her paper ghost craft. I ended up opening the Goldfish, mopping up the juice, and gluing her wet ghost back together while she sat on my lap eating crackers. No confidence building, just a lumpy ghost and a lot of crumbs on my jeans.
This is just a vent, not advice. But if there’s one thing I’ve learned lately that’s actually stuck, it’s that most of the time we don’t need advice anyway. We just need to stop pretending we have all the answers, and stop expecting other people to have them for us.
I changed one small thing a few months ago that anyone can try, no extra work required. When someone asks me for parenting advice now, I don’t give it. I just say, “What’s the part that’s bugging you most right now?” Half the time, that’s all they wanted – someone to let them talk through the mess, not someone to hand them a 3-step plan that works for a hypothetical kid, not theirs. When I’m in the middle of one of these messy moments, I stop trying to remember the “correct” response I saw on TikTok. I just say one of two things, out loud, either to my kid or to myself: “I don’t have the right answer right now, but I’m not going anywhere,” or “We can fix this later, let’s just get through the next 10 minutes.” I always keep an extra pair of socks, an extra pair of underwear, and a pack of fruit snacks in my center console. That’s the only “hack” that’s never failed me. It’s way lower effort than memorizing 5 steps for meltdowns.
After school today, my kid came running out to the car, jumped in, and held up a jagged piece of quartz he’d dug out of the playground dirt. He didn’t mention the boots, the scuff, or the fact that he wore one sock and one bare foot through math class. We stopped for ice cream on the way home, and he put the scuffed boots on when we got out to walk into the shop, no complaints at all. I texted that mom from the playground on the way home. I said, “I’ve been thinking about what you asked me the other week. That advice I gave you? It works sometimes, but most days I’m just running 10 minutes late and hiding from my kid in the bathroom to drink cold coffee. I don’t have any secrets. If you want to come over this weekend and complain about meltdowns while the kids play, I’ve got extra wine.” She wrote back two minutes later: “I’ve been faking it too. I’ll bring the brownies.”
I don’t have any big takeaway to leave you with, no neat moral to wrap this up. Some days go smooth, some days you end up with a barefoot 8-year-old and a jam-stained toaster and that’s just it. No one has it all figured out, no matter what they type in the parent group comments. I’m still here, still messing up, still keeping extra socks in the car. That’s enough, for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why I Stopped Giving Parenting Advice After This Week With My 8-Year-Old