Why Great School Programs Disappear When A Teacher Leaves (And What Actually Stays)
Last September, I stood at the back of my daughter’s third-grade classroom during back-to-school night, squinting past the stacks of math workbooks for the hand-painted wooden stand that used to sit by the door. For 12 years, that stand held packets of native plant seeds harvested by students, part of the outdoor science program Ms. Rosa, the longtime third-grade teacher, built from scratch when I was still teaching middle school across town. I’d looked forward to my daughter getting to do that project. When the new teacher turned around and saw me staring, she shrugged. “Ms. Rosa retired last spring,” she said. “No one picked up the stipend, and the garden out back got turned back into grass for the playground expansion. I don’t know anything else about it.”
I knew exactly what she meant. Ten years ago, I started a lunch buddy program at that same middle school for new kids who didn’t know anyone. I matched seventh and eighth graders with new transfers, made weekly reminder slips for homeroom teachers, kept a box of extra ice cream coupons for first week meetups. When I left to have my daughter, I left a three-ring binder with all the steps, the contact list for the PTA that funded the coupons, everything saved on the shared drive. A year later, the program was gone. The binder’s still in a cabinet somewhere, I bet, but no one ever opened it.
The thing no one talks about when we talk about school culture is that most of the good stuff isn’t actually part of the school. It’s part of the person who built it. Ms. Rosa didn’t just write a lesson plan for the plant project. She knew the owner of the local nursery went to the school as a kid, so she called him every April and he’d donate 50 small plants for free. She stayed 20 minutes late every Friday to pull weeds out of the garden, because the custodian already had too much to do. She emailed every parent at the start of the unit to ask for empty yogurt cups, because the budget didn’t cover seed starting pots. None of that was in the teacher handbook. None of that was written down in the program outline the administration kept on file. When she retired, all that invisible work left with her.
A month after back-to-school night, my daughter came home from school clutching a crumpled yogurt cup with a tiny milkweed seedling poking out of the dirt. Her name was scrawled on the side in blue sharpie. “Ms. Lopez let us plant these,” she said. “Jake brought a whole bag of seeds from his grandma’s farm. We talked about how monarchs need milkweed.” A few weeks after that, I ran into a former student of mine from that middle school by the cereal aisle at the grocery store. She’s 22 now, has a two-year-old of her own. We chatted for a minute, and she suddenly said, “I still think about that lunch buddy program you did. I was the new kid my seventh grade year, and everyone already had their friend groups. My buddy sat with me every day for the whole first semester. I do the same thing now for new kids at my son’s daycare. It’s the smallest thing, but it made such a difference for me.”
That’s when it hit me, what actually sticks around, and what we can actually do when we love a school program, instead of just panicking when the leader leaves. First, if you’re leading a program, write down the unspoken stuff, not just the lesson plan. Leave a note that says “Joe at Main Street Nursery donates plants, text him at this number, mention you’re from the third grade program, his grandkids went here.” That’s the stuff new leaders actually need, not a 10-page formal outline that collects dust on a shelf.
Second, share the work while you’re still there. Don’t be the only person who knows how to order the seeds or run the buddy matching. Ask a parent helper to come to every work day, let a student lead the weekly check-ins, so when you leave, there are already three other people who know how it works, not just you. You don’t have to wait until you’re moving on to start spreading that knowledge around.
Third, don’t waste time mourning the exact original program if the leader leaves. The big 12-bed garden Ms. Rosa built is gone, but a dozen tiny yogurt cup seedlings still teach the same lesson. You don’t need a full formal program with a budget and a stipend to have an impact. It can be small, it can fit whatever the new teacher or parent has time for. No one has to rebuild the exact thing that was there before to keep the point of it alive.
This spring, the PTA voted to put three small raised beds in the corner of the playground, to bring back a version of the plant project. A handful of us parent volunteers signed up to take turns weeding, and the new teacher is going to fit the seed planting into her science curriculum when she has time. No one’s sure it’ll last 12 years like Ms. Rosa’s did. Maybe when our kids move on to middle school, the next group of parents will let it go, and it’ll turn back into grass again. But right now, there are dozens of milkweed seedlings growing in backyards across town, and a 22-year-old mom welcoming new kids to daycare every year, because someone took the time to do something small for kids once. That’s what school culture keeps, anyway. Not the binders, not the programs, not the wooden stands by the door. The little things people carry with them, long after the original project is gone.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Great School Programs Disappear When A Teacher Leaves (And What Actually Stays)