Why Girls Hold Back From Answering Questions: A Teacher’s Simple Observations and Tips
It was Tuesday 7th grade math, right after lunch, and half the class was still blinking awake into their fraction word problem worksheets. I’d walked through the first problem together, then asked who could talk me through the first step of the second. A dozen hands shot up, mostly boys, a few calling out half-answers before I even called on anyone. I scanned the room, and spotted Lila twisting her pink eraser against the edge of her notebook. Two minutes earlier, I’d leaned over her desk to check her work, and her first step was exactly right. Her hand stayed down. I called her name anyway, and she mumbled “I don’t know, never mind” and stared at her desk.
After class, she lingered to turn in a make-up worksheet, and I asked her why she’d held back. She shrugged, kicked the leg of my desk, and said “I just wasn’t 100% sure yet. What if I got it wrong?” That line sounded familiar. I’ve been teaching middle school for 8 years, and I’ve heard some version of that from dozens of girls over the years. The next day, I wrote a line on the whiteboard at the start of every class: Just have a simple question for all girls (boys can also answer if interested): When you think you know the answer, why don’t you raise your hand? I passed out blank index cards, told kids they could write anonymously if they wanted, and collected them after 10 minutes of writing.
The responses weren’t surprising once I stopped writing them off as shyness. One 12-year-old girl wrote “If I’m wrong, everyone will remember I messed up that question for the whole week.” Another said “I have to check my work three times to make sure I didn’t misread the question. By the time I’m done, a boy already yelled out the answer.” A 13-year-old boy answered, which I loved, and wrote “I feel this way when we do reading out loud. I don’t want to mispronounce a big word so I just keep my hand down. Everyone acts like it’s so stupid if you mess up.” One girl summed it up simpler: “Boys don’t care if they’re wrong. I do.”
I used to think this was just about low confidence, something girls needed to build on their own. But reading all those cards made me realize it’s not that they don’t know the material, or that they can’t do the work. It’s that we’ve framed answering questions as a test of being right or wrong, instead of a step in learning. And girls in particular get the message early that being wrong is embarrassing, something to avoid at all costs. It doesn’t mean boys never feel this way, just that more girls learn to wait for perfect before they speak up.
I started making small changes to my classroom after that, and they’ve made more difference than any “confidence building” assembly I’ve ever sat through. The first change is tiny: I swapped my question. Instead of saying “Who has the right answer?” I say “Who wants to try out a first step?” That one phrase shift changes everything. It’s no longer about being perfect, it’s about contributing to the work. I’ve had at least three more hands go up per class just from that.
The second change is also tiny: I wait 10 full seconds after I ask a question before I call on anyone. I used to call on the first hand up after 2 seconds to keep class moving, but that only rewards the people who think fast and don’t mind being wrong. Now I lean against the board, cross my arms, and count slow to 10 in my head. That gives the kids who need an extra minute to check their work, sort out their thought, and work up the courage to raise their hand time to do it. For parents, this works at home too: if your kid pauses while talking through a homework problem, don’t jump in to give them the answer or fill the silence. Just wait 10 seconds. More often than not, they’ll finish the thought themselves.
Another thing I changed, and that I’ve started doing with my own 10-year-old daughter at home, is how I talk about wrong answers. I don’t say “it’s okay, you tried” when someone gets it wrong – that just makes it sound like getting it wrong is a pity party. Instead, I write the wrong answer on the board and say “Great, that rules out this path. Who can build on that?” For parents, if your kid comes home and says they messed up answering a question in class, don’t say “next time just be more confident.” That’s useless. Instead, ask “what did you learn from getting that wrong?” It frames mistakes as information, not failures. Last month, my daughter was practicing for a science presentation and kept stopping because she forgot her line, saying she didn’t want to go at all. Instead of telling her she’d be great, I asked her to show me the part she did remember, and said that half a presentation is still way better than none. She went, made up the line she forgot, and didn’t even panic after.
It’s not like every girl in my class now raises their hand every day. Last week, we did a geometry problem, and I saw Lila’s hand creep halfway up, hover for 8 seconds, then drop back to her desk. I didn’t call on her. After class, I walked by her desk and said “That was a really smart way you worked out the area, I saw that.” She looked up, smiled, and said “thanks, I was just too nervous today.” That’s okay. We don’t have to fix every bit of hesitation overnight. The point of asking the simple question wasn’t to get every hand up. It was to remind me that small changes to how we ask for answers make more of a difference than pushing kids to just be more confident. And any kid, boy or girl, who’s ever waited for perfect before they speak up gets something good out of that change.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Girls Hold Back From Answering Questions: A Teacher’s Simple Observations and Tips