Is 9 Too Young To Explain What “Virgin” Means? Parenting Tips For Unexpected Questions
Last month I was pulling out of the elementary school soccer field parking lot, my 9-year-old Lila crumpling an empty Goldfish cracker bag in the backseat, when she blurted, “Mom, what’s a virgin?” I nearly tapped the brake too hard, my chest jumping a little. I’d prepped for questions about why the sky is blue, why we have to go to bed early, even why her grandma doesn’t let dogs on the couch. This wasn’t on my radar for another three or four years at least.
I asked her where she’d heard it, and she shrugged, kicking her mud-cleated soccer shoes against the seat. “Two sixth grade helpers were talking by the slide after school. They whispered it a bunch. I didn’t get what they meant.” She fidgeted with the tassel on her backpack, no embarrassment, just plain curiosity. That’s when the question popped into my head, the same one any parent would have: Is this too soon? Am I about to put something into her head that doesn’t need to be there yet?
I pulled into the empty parking lot of the grocery store down the street, turned around in my seat, and took a breath. I’d read once that the first thing to do when a kid asks a question you’re not ready for is ask them what they’ve already heard, so that’s what I did. “What do you think it means?” I said. She thought for a second, then said, “I think it’s something about being a kid still? They said it like it was a big change when you stop being one.”
I nodded, and gave her the simplest definition I could think of, no extra frills, no awkward blushing. “It’s a word people use to describe someone who hasn’t had sex yet.” That was it. I paused, waiting for the flood of follow-up questions that never came. Lila blinked, then said, “That’s it? Why were they whispering so hard about it then?”
I told her that a lot of people treat any word about sex like it’s something bad or secret, so people get used to whispering about them, but there’s nothing wrong with asking me what any word means. She nodded, then pointed out the window at a golden retriever tied to a parking meter, and by the time we got home with the ice cream we stopped for, she’d moved on to talking about who got picked for which soccer team next week.
I sat on the question for the next week, texting my sister who teaches 4th grade to ask if I’d messed up. She said she gets questions like this at least once a semester from 9 and 10 year olds. Kids hear things, she said, whether we want them to or not. Older siblings, playground chatter, TikTok snippets when someone leaves their phone unlocked. It’s not the 90s anymore, when you could go until middle school without hearing most sexual words.
What I’ve realized since that day in the parking lot is that most of us mix up two things: explaining what a word means, and explaining the whole complicated context of sex to a 9 year old. You don’t need to give a 9 year old a full lesson on sexual activity, consent, or the cultural baggage that comes with the word virgin to answer the question they asked. They just heard a new word they don’t understand, and they’re asking you what it means. Shutting them down with “you’re too young to know that” doesn’t protect them. It just makes the word more mysterious, and teaches them that they can’t come to you with awkward questions later when they actually do need more information.
The practical stuff I’ve taken away from this is pretty simple, and you can use it for any unexpected sexual question a kid that age asks. First, if you’re caught off guard, you don’t have to answer right away. You can say “that’s a really good question, let me finish unloading the dishwasher and we’ll sit down and talk about it in 10 minutes.” That gives you time to get over your shock and think through what you want to say, instead of reacting awkwardly or shutting them down. Second, answer only what they asked. If they just want the definition of a word, give them a plain, neutral definition. Don’t dump extra information they didn’t ask for. Third, if they don’t ask follow-up questions, let it go. You don’t have to turn a one-off question about a word into a full birds and bees talk unless they lead the way.
A week after our first talk, Lila came home from school and said one of her classmates was yelling “virgin” as an insult on the playground. She walked up to him and said “that’s just a word for someone who hasn’t had sex yet, what’s wrong with you?” and walked away. She told me that like it was no big deal, and it was. It wasn’t a big deal because I didn’t treat it like a big deal.
I don’t think this means I’m doing everything right. I still fumble through questions, I still put off hard talks when I’m tired or not ready. I get why people think 9 is too young. I wish my kid didn’t have to hear words like this on the playground before she’s even in middle school. But the alternative, letting her learn what it means from a bunch of 11 year olds on the playground or a random TikTok, seems way worse. Right now, it works that she knows any question, any word, is okay to ask me. Next year she’ll ask something harder, and I’ll probably fumble through that too. That’s just how it goes.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Is 9 Too Young To Explain What “Virgin” Means