Why Does My Child Talk About the Same Thing Over and Over? Tips for Handling Repetitive Obsessive Conversations in Kids
The third time my 7-year-old son asked me whether the new blue Minecraft axolotl would still spawn in the same cave after we reset our server, I was stirring pasta for dinner, and my answer came out sharper than I meant it to be. “Buddy, we talked about this 20 minutes ago. Can we talk about something else for a minute?” He went quiet, slumped against the kitchen counter, and pushed the rubber toy axolotl in his hand around the base of the toaster. I sighed, turned off the stove, and remembered the first year I taught third grade, when I had a student who talked about airport security checks for 12 straight weeks—every single free period, art class, and bus line. Back then I had no clue what to do, and I’d gently redirect him over and over, wondering if there was something wrong I was missing. Years later, standing in my own kitchen, I realized I was making the same mistake I’d made with him.
A few days after the pasta incident, I ran into a neighbor at the playground who has a 6-year-old daughter. She laughed, tired, and said her girl talks about garbage trucks nonstop. She’ll ask every grocery store clerk they pass what route they drive, how often they pick up trash, what happens to the trash after it leaves the truck. She said she’d started panicking, googling “obsessive conversations in children” at 10 p.m. every night, convinced it was a sign of something serious. I told her what I’ve learned from my time in the classroom and my own time as a parent: most of the time, this isn’t something to panic about. It’s just how kids process things that feel big to them, whether that big thing is excitement over a new favorite animal or a quiet worry they can’t put into words any other way.
That night after I snapped at him, I sat down on the couch next to him and asked what he was really thinking about with the axolotl. He flipped open his crumpled drawing notebook to a page full of blue lizards with goofy grins, and said, “What if the axolotl had a home in that cave, and we reset the server and he gets lost?” I’d completely missed the worry under the repetitive question. I wasn’t being asked to repeat a fact I’d already shared—he was asking for reassurance I hadn’t given yet, because he hadn’t known how to say what he was really worried about the first two times.
Over the past month, I’ve worked out a few small things that work way better than snapping or redirecting. The first is to stop assuming he’s just forgetting or being annoying, and start with a quick check-in. Instead of saying “we already talked about this,” I try to say “You’re still thinking about that axolotl, huh? What’s on your mind this time?” Nine times out of ten, there’s a new angle or a new worry he hasn’t shared yet. If I’m in the middle of something and can’t stop to talk right then, I give him a specific time and a clear limit, instead of just brushing him off. I’ll say, “I need to get this dinner on the table in 10 minutes, but when we sit down to eat, we can talk all about axolotls for 10 whole minutes. Is that okay?” He almost always agrees, because he doesn’t feel rejected—he just knows the conversation is coming later. I also got him a $1 spiral notebook I call his “axolotl book,” and when he brings up a question that doesn’t need an answer right away, I ask him to draw it or write it down in the book so we don’t forget it when we have time to talk. That gets the question out of his head and onto paper, and it takes the pressure off me to answer right this second.
That third grade student I had, the one who talked about airport security all the time? His dad had just started a new job that required him to fly cross-country every week. The kid was terrified his dad would get stopped at security and wouldn’t be allowed to come home. He couldn’t say that outright to anyone, so he talked about security checks over and over, working through the worry bit by bit. After a couple months, once his dad settled into a routine and he got to go the airport to see him leave once, the conversation tapered off on its own.
That said, there are times when it makes sense to check in with a doctor. If your child won’t do anything else—won’t play with friends, won’t participate in class, gets extremely upset if you won’t talk about their topic with them, and it goes on for months with no sign of slowing down—that’s worth bringing up to your pediatrician. But most of the time, it’s just a phase that runs its course. Kids’ brains are taking in so much new information every day, sometimes the only way to sort through it is to talk about it over and over.
Last week, we went to a family barbecue, and my son cornered my uncle, who’s never touched a video game in his life, to explain axolotl spawn rates and what they eat in the wild. I was halfway across the yard grabbing a burger, and I started walking over to interrupt, before I stopped. My uncle leaned against the fence, nodded, and asked, “Do they really breathe through their skin?” My son lit up and launched into a 10 minute explanation, and no one got hurt.
A month later, he still talks about axolotls most days. Some days I still get tired of it, and I have to remind myself to step back. I found his axolotl notebook on the counter this morning, and he’d scrawled a new question at the bottom of the last page: Can I get a real axolotl for my birthday? I know I’m going to hear all about it at dinner tonight, and I know I’ll probably zone out halfway through. I also know that in a few months, it’ll be something else. Maybe volcanoes, maybe space rockets, maybe something even more repetitive. For now, I’m just trying to remember to pause before I snap, and ask what he’s really thinking about this time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Does My Child Talk About the Same Thing Over and Over