How I Use Post Approval and Comment Flair to Teach Thoughtful Responses
The notification landed at 8:14 PM on a Tuesday. “Comment awaiting approval.” I was in the living room, half-watching a show, and I almost tapped approve without reading it. But I didn’t. I opened the notification and saw Maya’s reply to Liam’s post about the science fair experiment. Her comment read: “lol maybe if you actually read the instructions.”
It wasn’t mean. It was snark. Fifth-grade snark, the kind that passes for humor in group chats. A month ago, I would have let it through without thinking. But last week I changed the settings on our class blog so that every single post and comment has to pass through me before anyone can see it. I also added a new flair system—a little dropdown where students have to label what they’re writing. “Question,” “Observation,” “Connection,” or “Helpful.”
So I didn’t approve it. Instead, I flagged it and sent Maya a private note: “Want to rephrase this so it’s a helpful observation?” She replied a few minutes later. “But it’s true,” she typed. I said, “True isn’t the same as useful.” She sent back a revised comment: “Liam, I think your project might work better if you look at step 3. Do you want help?” I approved that one.
That was the first time I realized the approval process isn’t just about blocking bad things. It’s a chance to pause someone in the middle of an impulse.
I teach fifth grade at a public school, and our class blog is a small corner of the internet where students post about what we’re reading and discuss each other’s ideas. We set it up in September. By October, it was a mess. Kids were posting half thoughts, replying with “I agree” or “that’s cool,” and occasionally writing something that made me wince. I tried the usual low-key approach—remind them about netiquette, model good comments, give them sentence starters. It helped, sort of. But the real change came last month when I had to go through the moderation settings to block spam. That’s when I discovered the option to require approval for all posts and comments. I also saw the flair feature, which I’d never used before. I decided to turn both on at the same time.
The first three days were exhausting. I had to approve every word that went up. I’d get forty or fifty notifications a day, and a good chunk were from the same three kids who lived for a reaction. But I found that I wasn’t just approving or rejecting. I was editing in a way that mattered. I’d send a comment back with a note: “You said you disagree—can you add one reason?” or “This is a good question, but you didn’t tag it as a question.” The flair made them think about what kind of message they were actually sending. It’s one thing to write a short sentence. It’s another to decide whether it’s an observation or a connection.
One boy, Ben, posted a comment that just said “I agree with that.” He tagged it as “Observation.” I approved it because there wasn’t anything wrong with it, but I noticed he was tagging everything the same way. So on Friday, I spent ten minutes of class showing the kids an anonymous list of real comments from our blog—nothing personal, just the words—and asked them to guess which ones made the conversation go forward. Ben’s “I agree” was on there. So was Maya’s revised comment. The kids picked out the ones with specifics. I didn’t tell Ben his was the weak one. He knew. The next time he commented, he tagged it “Helpful” and wrote, “I agree, and I also noticed the ending of the chapter was kind of unclear. Maybe the author meant to leave us confused.” I approved it with a little inward cheer.
I’m not saying the approval system turned my students into reflective writers overnight. It’s messier than that. Some kids get anxious when they have to wait. I had a girl who wrote a perfectly fine comment, but then her flair didn’t save, so she had to redo the whole thing and she gave up. Another boy accused me of “policing” his words because I sent back a comment that said “this is boring” with a note asking him to add a reason. He didn’t talk to me for two days. And honestly, sometimes I approve things I’m not sure about because I’m tired or because I don’t want to be the reason a kid stops writing altogether.
But there’s something about the flair that feels different from a rubric or a rule sheet. It’s more like a pause button. When a kid has to look at those four labels and decide where their comment fits, they’re doing a little bit of thinking before they write. I’ve watched them do it—some hover over the dropdown for a few seconds, some click the first option just to get it over with. But even the quick clickers are making a choice. That tiny choice adds up.
If you’re thinking about trying this on your own class blog or a family group chat, a couple of things helped me. First, don’t approve alone. I mean, you are the only approver, but I started setting aside five minutes at the beginning of each day to show the class a few examples—an appreciated comment, a rejected one, and one that came back for revision. That made the process less mysterious for them. Second, start with only three or four flair options. I first made eight, and it was way too many. Kids spent more time picking a category than writing. I narrowed it down to “Question,” “Observation,” “Connection,” and “Helpful,” which covers most of what a good comment does. Third, and this is the one I still struggle with: leave room for mess. If you reject or revise everything, the conversation loses its spark. There has to be a place for jokes and tangents, or the blog will feel like a worksheet.
Last week, a parent emailed me to say that her son had started using the same flair system at home. He’s a fourth grader, and they have a family photo group. She said he tagged her dinner picture as “Observation” instead of just commenting. She laughed about it, but she also said he paused before posting something about his sister. She told me, “He acted like he was deciding what to label it, and the second time he actually changed what he wrote.” I thought about that. The label isn’t the goal. It’s just a stepping stool to noticing what you’re about to say.
I still have my doubts. I wonder if approval teaches kids to write for the teacher instead of for their peers, and whether the flair becomes a gimmick that loses its effect once they figure out which tag gets the most likes. Maybe. I’ll find out in May when they’re all writing their final reflections. For now, I’m holding onto the moment when Maya’s revised comment finally appeared on our blog. She didn’t say anything about it. But Liam replied the next day, saying “thanks for the tip—I redid it and it worked.” Maya rolled her eyes when she saw that, but she tagged her next comment “Helpful” without me reminding her.
That’s not a neat ending. It’s a Tuesday night, and I still have eleven comments sitting in my approval queue. One of them is from a kid who wrote “who cares” on a post about photosynthesis. I’m going to send it back with a note asking if he has a specific question. He’ll probably roll his eyes too. But I’m okay with that.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » How I Use Post Approval and Comment Flair to Teach Thoughtful Responses