Why Do All Teachers Want Different MLA In-Text Citations? A Teacher-Parent’s Practical Guide
It’s 8:17 on a Tuesday night, and my 10th grader Lila slams her Chromebook shut so hard the half-eaten bowl of Cheetos slides an inch across our scuffed kitchen table. I look up from the pile of mismatched socks I’m folding, and she glares. “Ms. Henderson marked every single one of my in-text citations wrong. I did them exactly how Mr. Torres wanted for my history research paper last month. What is even the point of MLA if everyone just makes up their own rules?”
I lean over the table, pushing a stray Cheeto out of the dog’s reach, and pull her paper up on the screen. Sure enough, red comment bubbles pop up every few lines: Wrong citation format, add comma here, missing source identifier. I pull up Lila’s A- history paper from last semester, and sure enough, Mr. Torres marked her wrong on that exact same format back in September when she added that comma.
The difference is tiny, but enough to cost Lila 8 percentage points on her English essay: Mr. Torres wants (Smith 12) with no comma between the author’s last name and page number. Ms. Henderson wants (Smith, 12) with a comma. For a website with no listed author, Mr. Torres just wants the article title in parentheses. Ms. Henderson wants the full website name. It’s enough to make any kid (and any parent helping them at 8pm on a school night) want to throw the whole paper in the trash.
I used to teach high school English before I switched to part-time curriculum writing, so I know this frustration isn’t because teachers are power-hungry control freaks who love to take points off for no reason. I’ve been that teacher who insisted on a specific formatting quirk that didn’t match the latest MLA update. There are three very ordinary reasons this happens, none of which have anything to do with your kid doing something wrong on purpose.
First, MLA updates its rules every 3-5 years, and most teachers don’t re-take a workshop on citation every time a new edition comes out. A teacher who got their teaching degree 20 years ago learned that comma between author and page was the correct MLA format, and that’s what they’ve always taught. There’s no real benefit to them unlearning what they’ve done for decades, especially when the tiny difference doesn’t change the whole purpose of the citation anyway. Second, different classes have different priorities. A history teacher cares a lot more about when a source was published, so they might require you to add the publication year in the in-text citation to make it easier to spot if you’re using primary vs secondary sources at a glance. An English teacher grading 30 essays on To Kill a Mockingbird just cares that you can point to the exact page you quoted, so date doesn’t matter to them. Third, some quirks are just about making grading faster. If all students put the website name in the in-text citation, a teacher doesn’t have to flip back to the works cited every time they want to check a source. That’s just practical for them, not a random punishment.
After Lila calmed down enough to stop glaring at her Chromebook, we did three quick things that fixed the problem, and they’ve worked every time this has popped up since. First, we confirmed the assignment sheet only said “MLA format” with no other details, so Lila sent a one-sentence email to Ms. Henderson: “Hi Ms. Henderson, I noticed my in-text citations were formatted the way I learned for history, can you quickly remind me what format you prefer for this paper?” Most teachers will answer this in a few hours, and Ms. Henderson wrote back 20 minutes later with a quick example that matched what she wanted.
Second, we added a line to Lila’s pre-submit assignment checklist that’s taped to her desk: “Check teacher’s citation rules.” It’s just one extra step that takes 30 seconds, and it keeps her from automatically copying what worked for the last class. Third, we made a simple note in her phone labeled “Teacher Citation Quirks” where she adds one line per teacher after getting a paper back: Ms. Henderson ELA: comma between author and page, no date needed for in-text. Mr. Torres Social Studies: no comma, add year after author. It takes 30 seconds to update, and it eliminates the guesswork next time.
I know it’s frustrating to see your kid lose points over something that feels arbitrary. I’ve been there as a parent, and I’ve been the teacher on the other side getting the frustrated email from a parent asking why 5 points were taken off for a comma. The thing is, this isn’t really about MLA. It’s a tiny, low-stakes example of how different people and different spaces have different expectations, even when they’re asking for the same thing. Your kid will go on to have one job where their manager wants a weekly check-in email, and another that just wants a 2-sentence text when the task is done. Learning to check the rules for the specific space you’re in is a more useful skill than memorizing the exact latest MLA comma rule anyway.
Last week, Lila turned in another research paper, and she got full points on her citations. We still have nights where she complains that citations are stupid and no one can agree on anything, and she’s not wrong. It’s still an annoying hassle, but it’s one that’s easy enough to work around with a few quick habits. For now, that’s good enough for us.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Do All Teachers Want Different MLA In-Text Citations