Why Do Schools Put So Much Pressure on Teenagers? A Parent and Substitute Teacher Explains
Last Tuesday, I found my 15-year-old daughter Lila curled on the kitchen linoleum at 9:47 p.m., her half-finished AP Bio lab report splayed across the tile next to a crumpled peanut butter granola bar wrapper. She wasn’t sobbing, or yelling about how unfair school is. She was just staring at the scuffed baseboard, saying she couldn’t make herself type one more sentence about cellular respiration. When I suggested she turn it in a day late, she shook her head without looking up. Her teacher knocks 10 percentage points off for every day late, she mumbled. A B+ would drop to a C, and that would kill her GPA, and she’d lose her spot in the dual enrollment nursing program she applied for next year.
I’m not just a mom complaining about too much homework. I substitute teach at Lila’s public suburban high school two days a week, so I see the other side of the attendance desk too. Most days, I leave school just as worn out as the kids are, and not from chasing freshmen down the hallway.
Last month, I stayed late to grade exit tickets after covering an 11th grade college prep English class, and the regular teacher, Ms. Henderson, slouched into the desk next to me, scrolling her grade book with one hand while sipping cold coffee from a chipped district mug. The district had just released its annual performance benchmarks, she said, and 78 percent of graduating seniors needed to have a four-year college acceptance on file by May, up from 72 percent the year before. Twenty percent of her annual performance review was tied directly to hitting that number. A week earlier, she’d gotten a long angry email from a parent after she gave their son a B+ on his college essay, arguing the grade would tank his GPA for state university applications. The principal had asked her to re-grade it, even though she’d shared the clear rubric with parents at back to school night, and the paper really was only B+ work.
A few weeks later, I ran into the vice principal at a staff breakfast before school. He didn’t defend the benchmarks when I brought them up. If the school’s overall AP pass rate drops two years running, he said, the district cuts two full-time elective positions to redirect money to test prep. Last time that happened, they eliminated auto shop and beginning pottery. Kids still ask about both every semester. The school’s ranking on state report cards and national education sites ties directly to local property values, too. Homeowners show up to school board meetings to complain if the ranking slips even one spot.
I saw that parent demand myself at Lila’s 10th grade back to school night in September. Seventeen of 18 parent questions across three presentations were about weighted GPAs, AP credit transfers, or recommendation letters for elite colleges. One mom asked about nightly homework and flexibility for kids with after-school jobs; other parents shifted in their folding chairs like she’d wasted everyone’s time. No one else asked about workload or support for struggling kids.
Last month in study hall, a red-eyed freshman told me his guidance counselor said he needed two AP classes sophomore year to “stay on track.” He wants to be an electrician, already applied to the regional trade program, and had no idea APs weren’t required. No one had ever asked what he wanted.
It’s easy to write this off as schools being overly strict, or admins caring more about numbers than kids. But almost every teacher and administrator I work with got into this job because they like working with teenagers. Very few wake up excited to assign hours of homework or panic a 14-year-old about college. Most of the pressure doesn’t start in the front office. It trickles down from state accountability rules, national college rankings, increasingly selective admissions, and parent demand for top rankings that prop up local property values. No single person designed a system that leaves teens crumpled on kitchen floors. It’s just what happens when every layer is measured on the same narrow set of numbers.
That night with Lila, I didn’t give her a big speech about how grades don’t define her, or tell her to just take the night off. We pulled the dual enrollment program requirements up on my laptop right there on the floor, instead of relying on the number she’d heard from a friend between classes. It turned out the program only requires a 3.0 cumulative GPA, not an A in every AP class. She’d mixed up the requirement with the rule for National Honor Society. Half the panic most teens carry around comes from these secondhand rules no one ever actually wrote down, and no one ever checks.
After that, we started a 10-minute homework audit every Sunday after dinner. We pull up each class’s online grade book and write all upcoming due dates and point values on a cheap whiteboard next to the fridge, under the grocery list. A few weeks ago, Lila planned to stay up until midnight finishing three 5-point vocabulary worksheets, worth just 2 percent of her semester grade, because she thought skipping would tank her mark. She saw the 100-point biology unit test (30 percent of her grade) was two days away, skipped the worksheets, studied an hour, and got eight hours of sleep. She lost three total points on her final grade. It was the easiest trade she ever made.
We also booked a 20-minute meeting with her guidance counselor a month later, something I’d put off for a year. I went in with one clear question: What are the exact requirements for the path Lila wants, not the default four-year college track the school recommends for everyone? It turned out she only needed three AP classes total for her target nursing program, not the six her friends were signing up for. She dropped AP Psychology, swapped it for a certified nursing assistant course at the county tech center, and gets home 90 minutes earlier most days. Most guidance counselors carry 300-student caseloads; they can’t tailor plans unless you ask.
For teachers, small changes make a huge difference without any district overhaul. Ms. Henderson hung a clipboard by her door last semester with a sign: “Late work accepted for full credit up to three school days after the due date, no questions asked. Write your name if you need more time.” Admin gave her a talking-to at first, saying it taught bad habits. After one semester, her AP pass rate went up 4 percent, and far fewer kids turned in rushed, half-done work just to avoid a zero. A handful of other teachers have copied the policy for major assignments this semester.
Things aren’t perfect now, by any stretch. Lila still has weeks where three tests and a project all land on the same day, and she still stays up later than she should. Last week she texted me from lunch panicking over a math pop quiz, and she checks her grade app more often than I’d like. Ms. Henderson still has to hit that 78 percent acceptance benchmark, and she still gets angry parent emails; some weeks she says she’s not sure she’ll stay another year. The rankings aren’t going anywhere, and college admissions aren’t getting less competitive.
But Lila skipped a study session two weeks ago to go to a show with friends, and only checked her grade app twice all night. That felt like enough for now. We can’t tear out the whole system from our kitchen tables or classroom desks. But most of the pressure that breaks teens on a Tuesday night isn’t big, unavoidable stuff. It’s a misremembered rule, busy work no one cares about, a default track that has nothing to do with what they want. Most weeks, we can at least help them sort through which parts actually matter.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Do Schools Put So Much Pressure on Teenagers