Why Can’t My 6-Year-Old Recall Schoolwork Or Tell Me About Their Day? What We’ve Tried That Helps
I’m leaning against the chipped red brick wall of the elementary school, sun burning the back of my neck, holding Leo’s favorite lemon Popsicle I grabbed from the gas station on the way. The second he pushes through the front door with his backpack slipping off one shoulder, I ask the same question I’ve asked every school day since August: “What did you do today?” He blinks, licks a drip of Popsicle off his wrist, and shrugs. “Nothing.”
I used to brush this off, until last month when his first grade teacher sent a note home saying he’s struggling with immediate recall during class. He’ll follow along during the reading lesson, answer questions when she prompts him one on one, but when it’s time to pull out the answer on his worksheet five minutes later, he freezes and says he can’t remember. Last night, I sat with him at the kitchen table to do homework, and he couldn’t remember how to write the number 7—something his teacher said they’d practiced for 20 minutes that morning. I sat there, stirring my cold coffee, and pulled out my phone to type the question into a local parenting group that night: Have any of you got a 6-year-old like this?
Turns out, so many of you do. More than a hundred comments popped up by morning, all from parents saying their own first graders couldn’t tell them anything about their day, froze up during homework, and left them wondering if they should be worried. I spent the next two weeks talking to Leo’s teacher, my cousin who works as a school psychologist, and testing small changes to our routine, and I learned something I never expected: this isn’t usually a sign of a learning problem. Most of the time, it’s just how 6-year-old brains work.
When Leo was little, I thought memory was like a drawer—if you learned something, it went in the drawer, and you just pull it out when you need it. But it turns out, for 6-year-olds, the drawer is still being built. Their working memory, the part of the brain that holds onto information you need right now, only develops enough to hold 2 to 3 new bits of information at a time at this age. Think about how much new stuff a 6-year-old is processing at school every single day: where to hang your coat, who’s in your reading group, what the rules are for the water fountain, that you can’t bring dinosaur toys to circle time, when lunch is, what page to turn to for math. By 3pm, when you pick them up, that working memory drawer is completely full. There’s no room left to pull out the memory of what you did that morning to tell you about it. The information’s there, it’s just stuck behind all the other stuff they’re holding onto.
That changed everything for me. I used to get frustrated, think Leo was just not paying attention or being stubborn when he couldn’t tell me about his day. Now we’ve adjusted our routine, and the small changes have made a bigger difference than I thought they would.
The first thing we did was build in a 15-minute no-questions buffer after school. Leo gets in the car, gets his Popsicle or granola bar, and I don’t ask him a single thing about school. He can look out the window, play with the rubber bouncy ball I keep in the cup holder, or sing off-key to the radio, no pressure. By the time we get home and he’s changed out of his uniform into his stained play clothes, most of the extra temporary stuff from his working memory has shifted to long-term storage, so there’s room to pull out a memory. Then, instead of asking the big open question “what did you do today?” that’s way too big for his brain to sort through in one go, I ask one tiny, specific question. I know the class schedule from the school website, so if it’s art day, I’ll ask “What color paint did you use for your picture today?” If it’s PE day, I’ll ask “Did you play tag during recess?” Last week I asked “Did anyone do anything silly at snack time?” and he talked for 10 straight minutes about how his friend Jake put a goldfish cracker in his nose. That’s the most he’s ever told me about school in one go.
For homework, we do the same thing. No homework for the first 20 minutes after we get home—he runs around the backyard, chases our cat, kicks a ball against the fence, gets all that wiggly energy out and lets his brain unload the day’s pressure. When we sit down to do work, if he freezes and says he can’t remember how to do something, I don’t tell him to think harder or get frustrated. I give him one tiny prompt, instead of asking him to pull the whole memory out of nowhere. When he couldn’t remember how to write 6 last week, I didn’t show him or tell him what to do. I just said “What did Mrs. Henderson say the 6 has to do?” And he immediately grinned, said “It curls around and grabs its tail!” and wrote it perfectly on the line. The memory was there the whole time, it just needed a little nudge to find it.
Of course, we still check in with his teacher every few weeks to make sure there’s nothing bigger going on. If he couldn’t recall things even with prompts, or was falling far behind the other kids, we’d get him evaluated. But right now, his teacher says he knows all the material, he just takes a little longer to access it than some of the other kids. That’s totally normal for his age.
Some days it still goes wrong. Last week, the school had a big fire drill that interrupted the whole morning, and when I picked him up he couldn’t even remember that it happened. He still stares at his homework some nights and can’t recall the sight words he practiced that day. I still catch myself scrolling late at night sometimes, wondering if we’re missing something. But it’s a lot less stressful than it used to be. It’s nice to know we’re not the only ones waiting around for answers that don’t come right away. Most days, Leo will be eating dinner an hour after we get home, and he’ll just blurt out that they got to watch a video about butterflies, or that the principal gave him a lollipop for being line leader. It just takes his brain a little extra time to find the right file. That’s all.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why Can’t My 6-Year-Old Recall Schoolwork Or Tell Me About Their Day