When Your Child Asks If Life Is Worth Living: What Parents and Teachers Can Do
The heater in room 214 clicks twice before it kicks on, and by 3:40 most of my eighth graders have already bolted for the buses. Devon is still there, sliding a dry-erase marker back into the tray, taking much longer than the job requires.
“You ever think about whether it’s worth it?” he asks. “Like, all of this.”
I’ve been teaching long enough to know there are two versions of that question, and they can sound identical. One is the kid who read something in a novel or watched a video at 1 a.m. and is trying the idea on for size, the way you’d try on a coat. The other is a kid telling you something without saying it directly. So I don’t answer right away. I pull a chair out from the front row and sit down, sideways, so we’re both facing the whiteboard instead of each other.
“What made you think about it today?” I ask.
He shrugs. Then he talks. He was up until almost two, he says, not doing anything, just lying there with his brain going. His older brother left for college in August. His parents both work nights and he’s alone in the house from about six until ten. He says he doesn’t mean anything by it. He’s just wondering.
We talk for maybe twenty minutes. Somewhere in there he mentions he hasn’t really eaten lunch in a week — not dieting, just not hungry. He says it like it’s a small thing.
It isn’t a small thing. It’s the detail I’d been waiting for without knowing I was waiting.
Here’s what I’ve learned, teaching fourteen-year-olds for eleven years and raising two of my own. The question itself — is life worth living — is not the alarm. Kids are philosophers by nature, and somewhere around middle school they figure out that people die, that time moves in one direction, that their parents will one day not be there. That realization lands hard and it usually comes out as a big question at an ordinary moment, like while unloading the dishwasher.
What matters is what comes attached. Sleep that’s gone sideways. Appetite disappearing. Quitting the things they used to love with a shrug instead of a fight. Giving away a prized hoodie. A strange calm after a bad stretch — that one gets missed a lot, because it looks like improvement. If you’re seeing several of those together, don’t wait for the perfect conversation. Call the school counselor, call your pediatrician, or call or text 988 in the U.S. to reach the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline. You don’t need to be sure. Being unsure is a good enough reason to make the call.
But most days, it’s a conversation, not a crisis. And the conversation is where I’ve made the most mistakes.
My instinct, the first time a student asked me this, was to reassure. I gave a speech. Life is full of possibilities, I said, and there are people who love you. He nodded and left and never brought it up again, which I mistook for resolution and now think was probably just politeness. Reassurance is a door closing. The kid says the scary thing, you hand them a tidy answer, and they learn not to bring you the messy version next time.
So now I ask questions instead. Not “are you okay,” which gets a reflexive “yeah” from every teenager on earth, but things they actually have to think about. What’s the worst part of your day right now? When did you start feeling like this? Is there anyone at school you talk to? What does it feel like when it gets bad — heavy, restless, numb?
And I sit beside them rather than across from them, which sounds like a small thing and isn’t. Some of the best conversations I’ve had with my own kids happened in the car, both of us looking out the windshield. Nobody has to make eye contact. Nobody has to hold a face.
One more thing, and I say this out loud to students now: if you tell me something that makes me worried about your safety, I’m going to bring in someone who knows more than I do. I say it before they start talking, not after, so it doesn’t feel like a betrayal. Kids usually respect it. They’d rather know the rules.
With Devon, I emailed the counselor that evening and told him the next morning that I had. He was annoyed. He said it wasn’t a big deal, that I was making it into something. He went anyway, mostly because I walked him down there myself at lunch. That part doesn’t make it into tidy versions of this story — the kid being irritated with you for caring. It’s fine. Being annoyed is a feeling, and feelings are better than the flat nothing he’d been describing.
The counselor talked to his parents. They adjusted the nights, so someone’s home by eight. He started eating lunch again, at least some of it, sitting with two kids from his robotics team. He’s still quieter than he was in September. I check in with him on Thursdays, briefly, usually about nothing — a test, a game, whatever. I don’t make it a thing.
At home, my eleven-year-old asked me a version of the same question last month, standing at the counter while I flipped pancakes. Do you like being alive? I said yes, mostly. I said some days are a grind and I still want to be here for the next one. She said okay and asked for more syrup. I don’t know what she did with the answer. I’m not sure she knows either.
What I’ve landed on is this: kids don’t need us to prove that life is worth living. They need us to stay in the room while they figure out what they think. Answer honestly when they ask. Notice the small changes before they get big. And keep showing up on Thursdays, even when the conversation is about nothing at all.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Your Child Asks If Life Is Worth Living: What Parents and Teachers Can Do