Why My 19-Month-Old Ignores the “Educational” Toys (and What We Use Instead)
The shape sorter has been sitting on the rug for three days. It came in a box with bright primary colors and a smiling bear on the lid, and it promises to teach colors, shapes, and hand-eye coordination. My 19-month-old walks past it every single time. He steps over it to reach the silicone muffin tray I left drying on the kitchen mat, and he stands there for five minutes, picking it up, chewing on the edge, and then dropping it to see what sound it makes on the tile.
I remember buying that shape sorter online one night after reading a blog post about “cognitive development through sorting.” I had another tab open checking prices on wooden puzzles with chunky knobs. It felt like homework. At 19 months, my son has an opinion about everything—the color of his cup, which parent carries him down the stairs, the exact angle of his banana slices. So his refusal to engage with the toy I researched felt personal.
But then I watched him with the muffin tray.
He wasn’t ignoring it. He was studying it. He turned it over, ran his finger along the little cups, then attempted to stack two of them together. They didn’t fit, so he swapped one for a smaller one, and then he grinned when it nestled inside. He did that maybe six times. Then he picked up a wooden spoon from the drawer I’d left open and used it to tap the tray, testing the different sounds each cup made. He was sorting, recognizing size relationships, and exploring cause and effect—all the things the shape sorter was supposed to teach. He just decided to learn them with an old piece of kitchen equipment instead.
That afternoon, I took a good look at our toy shelf. There were the stacking cups, which he does use, but mostly for throwing and occasionally for wearing on his wrists. There were the textured balls, which he chases until they roll under the couch and he forgets about them. There was a wooden train with animal figurines that he ignores entirely. And there were the blocks—simple, unadorned wooden blocks that my mom bought at a garage sale. Those he actually plays with. He knocks down towers I build, and after about a week, he started trying to build his own one block on top of another. The moment only lasts a few seconds before it topples, but the concentration on his face is unmistakable.
I’m learning that “educational” at this age doesn’t mean what the packaging suggests. It doesn’t mean a toy teaches a discrete skill like naming a triangle or pressing the right button to make a light flash. At 19 to 20 months, a child is learning how the physical world works. They’re figuring out what fits, what falls, what moves, what makes noise, and what stops moving if you put it in a bucket. That’s why cardboard boxes are often more compelling than anything from a toy catalog. A box can be a drum, a cave, a basket, or a lid that goes over a stuffed animal. The muffin tray turned out to be a better sorting toy than the shape sorter because it’s open-ended—there’s no right answer, so my son can experiment without feeling corrected.
I still want to buy things. There’s a toddler “busy board” with latches, switches, and zippers that keeps popping up in my ads. I keep picturing my son standing in front of it, quiet and focused, working the lock like a tiny locksmith. But every time I get close to clicking, I remember the shape sorter. So I’ve started applying a kind of low-friction test before any purchase: Will he still be able to use this in six months? Is there more than one way to play with it? Can I easily put it away without wanting to hide it? The busy board fails all three.
What actually works right now is pretty straightforward. Wooden blocks and simple stacking toys—but only if I don’t force him to stack them correctly. He likes knocking things down, so I build and he destroys. That sounds silly, but it’s his job right now. He’s testing gravity and predicting what happens when he swipes his arm across the tower. Sometimes I sit on the floor and build one tower while he watches, and then he crawls over and knocks it down with both hands. He laughs. I rebuild. This can happen for fifteen minutes, which is an eternity at this stage.
The other thing that works is the “small objects with parent nearby” category. At this age, he’s nuts about putting things into containers and taking them out again. I bought a simple set of plastic eggs that snap together, and inside each one is a little animal. He can’t snap them together yet, but he loves opening them, finding the cow, dropping the egg half into a bowl, and then asking me to close it so he can open it again. It’s not a complex toy, but it exercises his fine motor skills and, more importantly, it gives us a rhythm together. The interaction matters more than the object.
I’ve also stopped showing him how a toy is “supposed” to work. For a while, the shape sorter bothered me because he wasn’t putting the square block through the square hole. He was trying to push the square through the circle hole and getting frustrated. I caught myself hovering, saying “No, this one goes here” and moving his hand. He pulled away and glared at me. So now I let him figure it out. If he gets frustrated, I do a gentle commentary instead of a correction. “That one is a square. Does it fit in the circle? Hmm, it wobbles. Maybe you can try another spot.” Then I let him make the choice. Sometimes he does, more often he walks away. That’s fine. He’s not developmentally ready to understand sorting, and pushing it does more harm than good.
The language stuff is where I see the biggest payoff, and it doesn’t require a specific resource. At 19 months, he’s starting to point at things and say “dat” for “that.” So I’ve started narrating in a simple, boring way. “That’s the red cup. You’re holding the blue one.” I use real words in real contexts, not flash cards. I’ve also brought out picture books that show real photographs—dogs, balls, shoes, baby faces. We sit on the floor and he points at a picture of a ball, then I say “ball” and we look at the actual ball in the basket across the room. He gets it. He connects the image to the object in his hand. That feels more educational than any app or tablet, and I’m not worried about screens right now because we just don’t need them.
One thing I’ve learned to accept is that his attention span is short. I used to get annoyed when he’d play with something for three minutes and then abandon it. But that’s normal at this age. The trick is not to have too much available. We have a low shelf in the living room and I rotate about four or five things at a time. When he seems bored, I put something away and take out something he hasn’t seen in a few days. The novelty of a familiar toy returning is more powerful than unpacking a brand new one. The other day, I put the shape sorter away. When I brought it back a week later, he actually sat down and tried the circle hole with the circle block. It was a fluke, probably, but it worked because he was ready to see it fresh.
We still have clutter. The kitchen drawer with the wooden spoons is now openly available. He has a designated cupboard with plastic containers and lids, and he pulls everything out to stack and bang and hide under. Sometimes he drags a towel over and tries to cover the containers, which I think is his version of playing peekaboo with objects. I could buy a more polished toy that does the same thing, but why would I? The container cupboard is his favorite spot in the house. My mother-in-law still looks at it with polite confusion, but she also noticed that he said “cup” while holding a yogurt tub, so maybe she gets it.
I still have a cart full of “approved” toys sitting in a digital wish list. That busy board is still there, and so is a set of magnetic fishing pieces that I know he’ll put in his mouth. I’ll probably keep them there for a while. Maybe he’ll surprise me next month and actually want to sit still with a puzzle. Or maybe he’ll keep ignoring every fancy option and stick to the muffin tray. For now, that’s fine. More than fine, honestly. I’m learning to look at what he’s curious about instead of what the advertisement tells me to buy. The shape sorter can stay under the couch. It’s not going anywhere, and neither is he.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » Why My 19-Month-Old Ignores the “Educational” Toys (and What We Use Instead)