When Your 14 Year Old Son Asks ‘Do I Look Like A Lesbian?’ Practical Parenting Tips For Gender Questions
I was folding clean laundry on our kitchen counter last month when my 14-year-old son leaned against the fridge, still toweling damp hair out after his after-school run, and blurted it: “Do I look like a lesbian?”
The toaster was still warm from the pop-tarts he’d grabbed for breakfast that morning, his half-empty blue Gatorade sweated on the tile next to his feet, and my first thought was to fumble out a generic “Of course not, you look like you” that would have ended the conversation right there. But I’d been teaching 8th grade long enough to know that when a kid drops an awkward, loaded question out of nowhere like that, they’re not asking for a quick, reassuring platitude. I set the soccer socks I was holding down and pulled out the wooden chair next to me. “What made you ask that?”
He shifted his weight, kicked a crumb of granola bar across the floor, and told me the story. A group of kids in his math class had been joking after a gender and sexuality alliance assembly earlier that day, and when he’d walked in, one of them nudged the other and said “See? That’s what a lesbian looks like, right?” It wasn’t even mean, he said, just a dumb offhand joke. But it stuck with him. He’s been growing his hair out for eight months, after all, to donate 10 inches to an organization that makes wigs for kids with cancer. He stopped wearing tight graphic tees last year because they itch when he runs cross country, and he lives in my old oversized college hoodies now. He knows lesbians can look any way, he said—our family friend Lila is a lesbian and wears floral sundresses every weekend. He just wanted to know: when other people look at him, is that what they see?
I sat with that for a minute, because I’ve had dozens of versions of this conversation with kids over the years, as a teacher and as a parent. Most adults panic when a kid brings up gender or sexuality labels out of the blue. They either jump straight to assuming the kid is being bullied badly enough to call the principal, or they immediately start probing to see if the kid is questioning their own identity, or they brush it off as dumb teenage teasing and tell the kid to ignore it. None of those work, not really. If I’d brushed it off, he wouldn’t have come to me with another awkward question down the line. If I’d immediately jumped to “Are you gay?” that would have put him on the spot when he wasn’t even asking about his own identity—he was asking about other people’s perceptions.
Instead, I asked him another question: “Does it bother you that they said that?” He shrugged and said it didn’t really, not as much as it confused him. He likes how he looks right now, he just didn’t get why people needed to slap a label on it because it didn’t fit what they think a 14 year old guy should look like.
That’s when I answered the actual question, the way that felt right. I said, “Here’s the thing: the idea that there’s only one way a lesbian looks is just a made-up stereotype. No one gets to make a list of rules for how someone has to look based on who they love. To me, I see a kid who spent eight months not getting his hair cut so he could give it to someone who needs it more. I see someone who wears whatever clothes don’t bug him when he runs. Any label someone else puts on that is about what they think is normal, not about who you are. So no, you don’t ‘look like a lesbian’—you look like you. And if you did look like what people think a lesbian looks like, that wouldn’t be a bad thing anyway.”
He nodded, then grabbed his phone off the counter and went back to his room to play video games. That was that, for the day. But I’ve been thinking about it ever since, because this is the kind of small, messy moment that no one really prepares you for as a parent or a teacher.
The concrete stuff that works here, the stuff I tell other parents when they ask me about similar moments, is pretty simple. First, always start with three questions before you say anything else: What made you ask that? How did that make you feel? What do you think about it? You don’t have to fix anything in the first five minutes. Most of the time, kids just want to get the confusing question out of their head, not have a two-hour lecture. Second, don’t treat the label like an insult. If you jump to say “Of course you don’t look that, that’s terrible” you’re sending the message that being a lesbian is something bad, which it’s not. Even if your kid is straight, that’s not a lesson you want them to learn. Third, don’t push identity questions if they don’t bring it up first. This kid wasn’t asking if he was gay, he was asking how other people see him. It’s okay to meet him where he is.
A month later, things are still messy, in that ordinary teenage way. He still gets the occasional dumb comment in the hallway. Last week he came home laughing and said he’d shrugged off a rude comment by telling the kid “At least my hair is going to a good cause, yours just sits there looking like a scrub brush.” We went to the salon last Saturday to cut his hair, and he walked out with 10 inches off, still a little longer than his old cut, and grinning the whole way home.
I don’t know what the future holds. I don’t know if he’ll grow his hair out again next year, or if he’ll end up identifying as something other than straight, or if he’ll forget this whole conversation by the time he’s 16. But that’s okay. Right now, the thing that matters is that when he had an awkward, weird question to ask, he asked me, and I didn’t mess it up too bad. That’s enough for now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Your 14 Year Old Son Asks ‘Do I Look Like A Lesbian