What To Tell Your Anxious Kid About Bullying Before School: No One Is Going To Bully You (Probably)
The ceiling fan hummed above Milo’s dinosaur-patterned comforter, the same coffee stain I’d been meaning to pretreat for three weeks blotted into the sheet near my knee. It was the night before third grade, and he was running a thumb over the frayed edge of his new sweatpants, not looking at me when he asked, “What if someone bullies me this year?”
I almost said what I’d said the year before, what every parent says: Don’t worry, if anyone bullies you we’ll go straight to the principal. It’ll be fine. But I’d seen how that answer landed last year. After a kid pushed him off the slide in first grade, I’d panicked. I emailed his teacher twice, called the other boy’s mom, and spent a week asking Milo three times a day if that kid was being nice to him. By the end of the month, Milo was asking me every morning before we left the house if that kid would be at recess. He was more scared than he’d been the day after the push.
I work as a paraprofessional at the same elementary school, so I spend six hours a day on the playground, wiping juice off tables and breaking up scuffles over four square lines. I’ve heard every label you can throw at kid meanness, and what I’ve learned is that 9 times out of 10, it’s not bullying. It’s a 9-year-old who just found out his dog is sick and takes it out on the kid who took his turn on the swing. It’s a group of girls practicing being mean because they saw it on a kids’ YouTube channel and don’t actually grasp that it hurts that much. It’s just kids being messy, not some deliberate, ongoing campaign to hurt your kid.
Last month, I watched a 4th grade girl call another girl’s new haircut stupid. The girl who got insulted ran crying to the bathroom, and two moms standing by the gate immediately started muttering about bullying. By the end of lunch, the girl who’d made the comment had snuck into the bathroom with a pack of glitter stickers to apologize. She’d spent the morning fighting with her mom about her parents’ upcoming divorce and just snapped. A week later, they were sitting together on the bus again. That’s how most kid conflict goes.
So when Milo asked again, what if someone bullies me, what came out was, “No one is going to bully you, probably.”
He looked up, confused. “Why probably?”
I sat back against the headboard. “Because most kids are too busy worrying if someone will bully them to bother bullying you. Really. I see it every day. Half the kids on the playground are just like you, wondering if someone will be mean to them. They don’t have time to plan to be mean to you. And the small mean stuff that happens? It’s usually not bullying.”
I didn’t leave it at that, either. I gave him concrete steps instead of vague advice. I told him if someone says one mean thing, he doesn’t have to run to the teacher right away to make a big report. He can just say “that was rude, I’m not playing with you right now” and walk away. Ninety percent of the time, that’s the end of it. The kid will get distracted by a soccer ball or a interesting bug and move on. If the same person is mean to him twice, he can try that same line again. If it happens three times, on purpose, that’s when we go talk to the teacher together. No shame, no big fuss, just fixing it.
I also changed one small habit at home. I used to lead with “was anyone mean to you today?” the second he got in the car after school. That question made him scan his entire day for bad stuff to tell me, and turned small offhand comments into big deals in his head. Now I lead with “what was the dumbest thing you saw today?” or “did anyone bring a good snack for snack time?” If something is wrong, he tells me. I don’t have to dig for it.
First week of third grade, he came home grinning and told me a kid in his class called his dinosaur backpack stupid. I tensed up for half a second, then asked what he did. He said, “I told him I think your Lightning McQueen backpack is ugly too, but I don’t say it because that’s rude.” Then the kid laughed, and they traded Pokémon cards after school. They’re going to each other’s birthday parties next month. That was it. No bullying, no trauma, just two kids being kids.
I know bullying does happen. That’s why it’s “probably,” not “definitely not.” I don’t dismiss the real pain of ongoing, intentional harm, and I know I might one day have to deal with it as a parent, just like I deal with it at work. But the problem with framing every possible conflict as a potential bullying nightmare before it even happens is that it teaches kids to see threat everywhere, and it turns small, normal growing pains into big, scary traumas.
Last night, Milo was packing his backpack for a field trip to the zoo, and he joked, “You still think no one’s gonna bully me probably?” I laughed and said yeah, that’s still my take. He rolled his eyes and went back to shoving extra granola bars in his bag. I still check in. I still go to the school if something’s wrong. But I don’t spend the night before school digging through all the terrible what-ifs with him. Most of the time, the what-ifs never happen. And if they do, we’ll handle them one at a time, same as we handle everything else. We don’t have to bring them into the house before they knock.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What To Tell Your Anxious Kid About Bullying Before School: No One Is Going To Bully You (Probably)