What to Do When Your Pre-Teen Doesn’t Know How to Handle Kids Who Don’t Like Her
The sour candy I keep in the center console for after-school pickup went untouched last Tuesday. My 11-year-old daughter, Clara, hauled her too-heavy math textbook into the backseat, kicked her scuffed Converse up on the edge of my seat, and stared out the window for three stoplights before she mumbled, “They all moved over to make room for Mia, but not me. No one even said anything.”
I knew exactly what she was talking about. For two months, she’d been hovering around this group of three girls in her homeroom. She brought them homemade lemon bars for the bake sale, stayed after school to help them decorate for the fall dance, and memorized all their favorite TikTok creators to have something to talk about. I’d already had a dozen versions of this conversation, and I’d messed up almost every one. Once I blurted “They sound rude, just find other friends” and she didn’t talk to me for the rest of the night. Another time I said “Just be more confident” and she rolled her eyes so hard I thought she’d strain a muscle. I get why, now. What does “be more confident” even mean to an 11-year-old who’s holding a full lunch tray and trying not to cry in front of the whole cafeteria?
That day, I didn’t jump to fix anything. I just nodded and said, “That sounds awful. What stung the most?” She thought for a minute, then said it wasn’t even that she desperately wanted to be their best friend. It was that everyone in the room could see she didn’t have a spot. It felt like she’d done something wrong to deserve being left out. We didn’t solve anything in the car ride home, but that question got her talking more than any of my bad advice ever had.
Later that night, while we folded soccer socks and sorted clean laundry on her bed, I told her about the time I joined a mom’s group when she was a toddler. Three of the women would always leave for coffee right after playgroup and never asked me to come along. I never figured out if it was intentional, or if I just didn’t fit with their group. I still think about that awkward feeling sometimes, but I also met my best friend at a different playdate a month later, so it worked out in the end. I didn’t say it to cheer her up. I just said it to let her know this happens to everyone, even grownups, and it doesn’t mean you’re broken.
We didn’t plan a big confrontation with the girls, and I didn’t email the teacher to step in (this wasn’t bullying, just a group of kids clicking with some people and not others). Instead, we came up with two small, concrete things she could try the next time she felt left out. First, we practiced an escape line she could use if she walked up to the table and it was clear there was no spot for her. Instead of standing there awkwardly waiting for someone to move, she just says “No worries, I see someone I know over there” and walks away. She rolled her eyes at practicing in the kitchen, but admitted it felt less scary than making something up on the spot. Second, we made a list of three backup spots she could go anytime she didn’t have a place to sit. There’s Jordan from art class who always sits by the window drawing and has said she likes having company. There’s the two boys from Clara’s soccer team who’ve had an extra seat ever since their friend got cut last month and always save it for anyone who needs it. And there’s the school library, where she can eat a granola bar and read her graphic novel if she doesn’t feel like talking to anyone at all.
I realized a long time ago that my job isn’t to make every bad feeling go away. Pre-teens this age are moving past the simple rules of childhood: back when you shared your crayons, you got a friend in return. Now they’re learning that sometimes you’re nice to people and they still don’t want you around. It’s not always personal, it doesn’t always mean you did something wrong, it’s just how people are. And that’s a skill they have to practice, not something a parent can fix for them.
Last week Clara came home from school smiling. She walked up to the group’s table on Monday, there was no extra spot, so she used her line and went to sit with Jordan. They spent the whole lunch drawing bad caricatures of their math teacher, and she said it was way more fun than sitting there listening to the group talk about a TikTok dance she doesn’t even care about. Sometimes the girls say hi to her in the hallway, and she says hi back. There’s no big fight, no dramatic making up, it just is what it is.
It’s not all fixed. Last Saturday she saw photos of the group’s mall trip on Instagram, and she sat on the couch picking at a frayed blanket for an hour before she admitted it still hurts. We got ice cream with Jordan after that, and she forgot about it by bedtime, but I know it’ll happen again. There will be more uninvited parties, more empty spots at lunch, more people who just don’t click with her for no good reason. That’s just part of growing up. The thing I’m glad about now is that we’re not just waiting for it to go away. We’re practicing what to do when it happens, one lunch line at a time.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What to Do When Your Pre-Teen Doesn’t Know How to Handle Kids Who Don’t Like Her