What To Do When Your Kid Writes A Letter To The Tooth Fairy: Parenting Tips For Big Kid Feelings
It was 10:17 PM, I was scrubbing spaghetti sauce off the kitchen counter, when I remembered I still needed to check under Lila’s pillow. She’d lost her first wobbly molar at dinner that night, cackling when it dropped into her bowl of mac and cheese, and insisted on leaving a letter for the Tooth Fairy along with the tooth tucked into a glittery cardboard box she’d made at art class. I’d mumbled “that’s nice, honey” while I packed her lunch for the next day, and hadn’t given it another thought. When I slipped into her room, the glow-in-the-dark stars on the ceiling were still faintly glowing, and her stuffed rabbit was slumped half off the bed. I fished out the box, flipped open the folded notebook paper, and read the smudged crayon writing: Dear Tooth Fairy. My goldfish Bubbles died last Wednesday. I don’t want money for my tooth. Can you bring me a new fish that doesn’t die? Love, Lila.
I froze, my fuzzy slippers cold on the hardwood. I had a 9 AM meeting I still hadn’t prepped slides for, and the pet store 10 minutes away closes at 8 PM. My first thought was to just tuck a $5 bill under there and write a quick generic note saying sorry, can’t do fish tonight. Then I leaned a little closer and saw the faint streaks where the crayon had run – she’d cried while writing this, and I never noticed. After Bubbles died, I’d scooped him out of the tank right after she got home from school, said we could go get a new one anytime, and she just shrugged and said okay, then went to her room to color. I thought she wasn’t upset. Turns out she just wasn’t ready to tell me she was upset.
I’ve been a parent for seven years, and I’d always thought of the Tooth Fairy as a silly little tradition, the kind of thing you check off your to-do list between brushing teeth and locking the front door. I’d done the whole thing three times before this, left a dollar or a tiny lollipop, and that was that. But this time, I realized that for kids, these made-up magical people aren’t just for candy and cash. They’re a safe space to share big feelings that feel too scary or too big to say to a grown-up directly. When you’re 7, you’ve already learned that grown-ups are busy a lot of the time. You know that if you say you’re still sad about a fish that died a week ago, grown-ups might sigh or tell you it’s just a fish or remind you you can get a new one. But the Tooth Fairy? She’s magic. She’s got all the time in the world for weird, sad little requests that don’t make sense to grown-ups.
I didn’t have a fish to leave that night, so I sat down at the kitchen counter with a piece of Lila’s unicorn stationary and wrote back as the Tooth Fairy. I said I couldn’t carry a whole fish in my tiny tooth bag (that tracks, right? Tooth Fairies only carry small things that fit in their pouches) but I’d talked to Lila’s mom, and tomorrow after school we’d go to the pet store and pick any fish she wanted, and the Tooth Fairy would cover the cost. I also added that it’s totally okay to miss Bubbles a lot, even a week after he died. I signed it Tooth Fairy, and sprinkled a little extra glitter from Lila’s craft jar on the note to sell it.
The next day after school, we went. She walked up and down the fish aisle for 15 minutes, stopping to tap every tank glass, before picking out a tiny orange guppy that didn’t swim very fast. She named him Orange, of course. On the drive home, she talked the whole time. She told me she’d felt bad because she forgot to feed Bubbles one day when she was at playgroup, and she thought that’s why he died. I had no idea. She never would’ve told me that straight out. She told it to the Tooth Fairy first, and once that weight was out, it was easier to say it to me.
This isn’t just a cute story, it’s changed how I handle all those little magical tradition moments now, and there’s a few small, low-effort things I do that other parents can try too. First, always set aside two full minutes after your kid falls asleep to read the entire letter, don’t just skim it for the request. I used to just check if they asked for extra money, and that was it, but now I read every line, even the messy half-written words that are hard to decipher. Second, if their request is something you can’t pull off at 10 PM, don’t brush it off or pretend it never happened. You don’t have to run out to the store in the dark. You can just say the Tooth Fairy can’t bring that tonight, but she worked out a plan with mom or dad to get it tomorrow. It doesn’t break the magic, it actually makes it feel more real, because it meets the kid where they are instead of forcing them to fit the expected tradition. Third, if your kid is asking the Tooth Fairy for something big that isn’t a toy, don’t panic that you have to fix it right away. A lot of the time, they just want someone to hear the thing they’re scared to say out loud to you. You don’t have to solve their sadness in one night, you just have to acknowledge it exists.
Last week, Lila lost her fourth tooth. She left another note, this one asking the Tooth Fairy if she can get a puppy next year for her birthday. I wrote back that that’s a really big question, and we’ll all talk about it as a family when her birthday gets closer, and the Tooth Fairy will put in a good word for her. It’s not a perfect system. Last month I forgot the Tooth Fairy entirely and had to apologize the next morning, and Lila just shrugged and said she’d leave the tooth out again that night. I still don’t always get it right. But now I know that those little crumpled notes to the Tooth Fairy aren’t just silly kid stuff. They’re the first draft of all the big things kids want to say, if we just slow down enough to read them.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What To Do When Your Kid Writes A Letter To The Tooth Fairy: Parenting Tips For Big Kid Feelings