When Teens Ask “Do People Really Find Life Worth Living?”: What Actually Helps, From a High School Teacher
It was 3:47 on a rainy Tuesday in October, and I was picking sprinkles off a stale birthday scone someone had left in the teacher’s lounge, grading college essays at my desk after the final bell. The radiator by the window clanked so loud it drowned out the sound of the hallway clearing out, and a half-dozen wet backpacks dripped onto the tile by the door. I was halfway through an essay about a student’s mission trip when Javi, a quiet 10th grader who sat in the back row and aced every quiz, hung back, scuffing the toe of his white sneaker against the linoleum.
“Ms. Carter?” He shifted his backpack higher on his shoulder, the faded skate brand logo peeling at the edge. “Can I ask you something that’s not about the essay?”
I closed my laptop and nodded, gestured to the empty desk across from mine. I figured he wanted an extension on the research paper due Friday, or a letter of rec for a summer program. Instead, he sat down, stared at his hands for 10 seconds, and said, “Do people really find life worth living? Like, actually. Not just the stuff people post about.”
I didn’t jump to answer. I’d heard almost the exact same question three months earlier, from my own 17-year-old daughter Lila, at 11:15 on a weeknight, perched on a kitchen stool picking at a leftover slice of frozen pepperoni pizza. She’d just failed a chemistry test and broken up with her first partner, and I’d made every mistake in the book that night. I listed her upcoming art show, the spring break coast trip we’d saved for, how proud she’d feel when college acceptances rolled in. I even trotted out the “it gets better” line I’d heard at a dozen school assemblies. She pushed her pizza away, said “you’re not even listening,” and shut herself in her room.
I sat at the counter wiping crumbs for 20 minutes after that, and realized she was right. I wasn’t answering her question. I was repeating the same script we sell all kids: check the boxes, get the grades, earn the prize, and happiness will follow. She wasn’t asking if big wins existed. She was asking if the regular, unremarkable days—the ones that make up 90% of most people’s lives—are worth showing up for.
I learned in my teacher training that the part of the brain that weighs small, daily satisfaction against long-term stress doesn’t finish maturing until the mid-20s. Teens are just developing the abstract thinking to see that decades of routine, bills, and unglamorous work stretch out after graduation, but they don’t yet have the lived experience to see how much unplanned good fits in between the hard parts. All they’re taught to track is grades, test scores, and acceptances—high-stakes, far-off markers that never mention the stuff that actually carries most people through the week.
That’s why I didn’t give Javi a speech about purpose or gratitude. First, I asked the calm, direct question I always ask when a kid brings this up: “I’m glad you told me. Have you thought about hurting yourself, or making plans to not be here at all, lately?”
He shook his head fast, like he was surprised I asked. “No, nothing like that. I just watch my brother. He’s 22, dropped out of community college, works 45 hours a week at the warehouse, and all he does when he’s home is play video games and complain about rent. My mom works two jobs and she’s always tired. No one ever talks about if it’s actually… fun. Or worth the hassle.”
I told him the truth, the same truth I’d finally said to Lila a week after that kitchen fight, when I brought her an iced tea (she hates warm herbal tea when she’s upset) and sat on the floor by her bed with no agenda. A lot of days are boring, I said. A lot of days are just folding laundry and waiting in line at the grocery store and grading papers while your shoulders ache. A lot of the things you’re told will make you happy don’t fix the tired, boring parts. Getting into a good college doesn’t mean you never have a bad Tuesday. Getting a good job doesn’t mean you never stress about money.
Most people I know don’t stay alive for the big, postable stuff, I told him. They stay for the tiny, throwaway stuff that no one grades or ranks or puts on a resume. I pointed to the doodle taped to the back of my laptop: a penguin holding a tiny grade book, left on my desk by a 9th grader a month earlier, no name attached. It took that kid 10 seconds to draw. It doesn’t count for anything. But it makes me smile every single time I open my laptop. I told him about the three minutes I get every morning at 6:30, when the house is still quiet, the neighbor’s tabby cat sits on the fence, and I drink my coffee before anyone needs anything from me. None of it is grand. None of it is a life goal. It just counts.
I didn’t assign him a big project or tell him to go find his passion. I gave him one low-stakes, no-grade, no-due-date task: for the next seven days, write down one tiny thing each day that didn’t suck. It could be as small as “the cafeteria fries were extra crispy” or “my dog slept on my feet” or “the rain sounded good on the roof while I did homework.” He didn’t have to show it to anyone. He didn’t even have to keep doing it after the week. It was just an experiment, to see if he could spot the stuff that normally slips past when you’re only looking for big wins.
I don’t want to downplay how serious this question can be, either. Two years ago, a quiet 11th grader named Mia hung back after a poetry unit and asked almost the exact same line Javi did. When I asked that same direct question about self-harm, she nodded and told me she’d been saving pills in her desk drawer for a month. I didn’t pull out the tiny moments exercise then. I grabbed my bag, asked the teacher next door to watch my room, and walked her straight to the school counselor’s office. I sat with her while she called her mom, and texted her every weekday for the first month she was in outpatient care. There’s no quick trick for that kind of pain, and pretending a list of good snacks can fix acute depression is dangerous. But the quiet, persistent existential doubt most teens wade through still deserves to be taken seriously, not brushed off as teen angst.
Javi didn’t bring the question up again for three weeks. He came to office hours, worked on his essay, left when the bell rang, same as always. Then last Tuesday, right as he was slinging his backpack over his shoulder to leave, he pulled a crumpled sheet of notebook paper out of his hoodie pocket and slid it across my desk. It was his seven-day list: cold chocolate milk, cat on his feet, new show episode early, beat his brother at Mario Kart, sun through gym windows, text back from his crush in two minutes, Ms. Carter didn’t give me a weird look when I asked that. He grabbed it back before I could say anything, stuffed it in his pocket, mumbled “see you tomorrow,” and headed out the door.
I still don’t have a perfect answer to the big question. Some nights, when I’m folding laundry at 10pm after back-to-back parent meetings, I find myself turning the same thought over, too. No amount of small good moments erase grief, burnout, or the long stretches where nothing feels like it’s going right.
But what I’ve learned is that we don’t have to prove life is worth living with grand speeches. We just have to stop lying about what it actually holds. We can mention offhand at dinner that the barista remembered your order, or that the walk to the car smelled like wood smoke, no life lesson attached. We can skip the “you have so much to be grateful for” line and just sit with the question for a minute, closed laptop, no rush to fix it.
Last week, Lila texted me from math class, just a blurry photo of a sparrow on the windowsill, no caption. I texted back a photo of the penguin doodle, no caption. She sent a heart emoji, and that was it. Javi still complains about college application fees and how expensive used cars are. Mia graduated last spring and sends me photos of her new rescue cat from her out-of-state college every few weeks. None of them have stopped asking the big questions, and I don’t expect them to. I’m just glad they know they don’t have to work through them alone.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » When Teens Ask “Do People Really Find Life Worth Living