What Should Stay Shared When Learning Becomes More Personalized: Teacher Tips For Classrooms And Home
The cinder block walls of my 4th grade classroom were still warm from the morning sun last week when I noticed Mia slouched in her reading nook, crumpling a neon sticky note in her fist. We’d been running personalized reading workshop for a semester now: every kid picks a genre and pace that matches their level and interest, so Mia was working her way through a set of graphic novels no one else in class had chosen. When I knelt down next to her, she mumbled, “The main character’s dog dies. No one else has read this. I don’t have anyone to be sad about it with.”
I’d spent the last two years training in our district’s personalized learning framework, and I believed in it. I’d seen a kid who refused to pick up a book fall into a personalized unit on skateboarding culture and finish three books in a month. I’d let advanced learners skip the 4th grade multiplication review they found boring and jump into early algebra work that kept them engaged. But that moment with Mia stopped me. Everyone talks about how great it is to meet kids where they are, adjust to their needs, give them their own path. But no one talks much about what we shouldn’t take away when we do that.
A few weeks before that, I’d noticed our math time had gone quiet. We switched to personalized skill problem sets, so half the class was working on multiplication, a quarter on fractions, and a small group was doing multi-step word problems. Before, when everyone did the same set, there was always quiet chatter: “Did you get number 7?” “How’d you solve that?” Now, everyone just stares at their own screen or worksheet, too focused on their own progress to ask anyone else anything. Javi, who talks nonstop about everything, finished his work 20 minutes early one day and just sat twisting his eraser, waiting for me to check it, instead of bugging the kid next to him about what they were doing.
I started small, first with reading workshop, then with math and science. Even if everyone is working on completely different things, we take the first five minutes of every work block to pair up and share one thing we’re confused by or excited about in our work that day. It doesn’t have to be on the same topic. Mia shared her confusion about the dog’s death the day after we started, and her partner, who was working on a rock science unit, said he’d lost his own dog last year and knew exactly how that felt. For parents doing more personalized learning at home—whether that’s letting your kid dive deep into their special interest or working on targeted skill practice at their own pace—this translates really easily. Instead of the generic “what did you learn today?” at dinner, ask “what’s one thing you thought about this week that you haven’t gotten to talk about yet?” It takes 30 seconds, and it doesn’t require rearranging your whole schedule.
The next thing I added was a monthly stuck share. Everyone writes one thing they got stuck on this month on a sticky note, no name, and we put them all up on the front board. We pick three to talk through, and anyone can share a trick they use when they get stuck. Last month, one sticky said “I get so bored when I have to practice my spelling words I want to stop” and another said “I can’t figure out how to end my story about space” and a third said “my marble roller coaster keeps breaking.” A kid who struggled with spelling said he draws little pictures next to his words to remember them, and that trick worked for both the speller and the kid writing the space story. A 9-year-old who liked building Legos gave the roller coaster kid the idea to tape the support sturdier, and they went and fixed it together after school.
At home, this can be as simple as sharing your own stuck moment before you ask your kid about theirs. If your kid is stuck on their math work, don’t just jump in to help. Say “I got stuck trying to figure out how to connect our new printer to my laptop yesterday. I had to watch three different videos before it worked. What’s one thing you could try here?” It normalizes struggling instead of making it something each kid has to handle alone.
I also stopped only celebrating individual progress. Now, when a kid hits a goal they’ve been working on, they get to pick three people to share a small treat with, or pick the song we listen to while we clean up at the end of the day. At home, that can be letting your kid pick the family dessert when they hit a goal, so everyone gets to join in the win instead of it just being their own private thing.
It’s not perfect. Some weeks we get so wrapped up in our projects that we skip the five minute share two days in a row. Sometimes the share turns into a 15 minute conversation about the latest Minecraft update and we have to scramble to get our work done. I still believe personalized learning meets kids’ needs in a way one-size-fits-all never did. But I’ve stopped thinking that personal means private. Learning is still something we do together, even when we’re all working on different things. Last week, Mia brought in the copy of the graphic novel her classmate lent her, and she read the sad part out loud to a little group of three girls at recess. No one assigned that, no one planned it. That’s just what learning feels like when we get the balance right. We’re still tweaking our routine, figuring out what works for this group of kids, but so far, that small bit of shared space has made all the difference.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Should Stay Shared When Learning Becomes More Personalized: Teacher Tips For Classrooms And Home