What It’s Really Like Being the New Kid in School (and Small, Practical Things That Actually Help)
Dismissal ran 12 minutes late yesterday, and by the time the last parent pulled up to the curb, only Mia was still in Room 12, shoving crayons into her dinosaur backpack one at a time. I was kneeling by the cubbies retying a first grader’s snow boot when I saw her crumple a sheet of construction paper and shove it to the bottom of her bag. When I asked what it was, she stared at her scuffed sneakers and mumbled that she’d drawn a picture of a tabby cat for the three girls at her table, but they’d already packed up and left before she could give it to them. Mia started three weeks ago, after her mom took a nursing job at the local hospital and moved them from a 12-student elementary school two hours west. This is my 11th year teaching third grade, and I’ve seen dozens of new kids cycle through our classroom. What most people get wrong about being the new kid doesn’t show up on the intake forms, and it rarely gets talked about at back-to-school night.
The first week Mia was here, I made the same mistake I’ve made a dozen times before: I asked Lila, our outgoing class president who always volunteers to help, to be Mia’s official buddy for the first week. That’s what all the teacher handbooks suggest, right? By day three, though, I saw Lila running ahead to the playground with her own friends, leaving Mia trailing 10 feet behind, clutching her lunch box tight to her chest. It didn’t help. It just made Mia stick out more, like she was a charity project everyone had to tend to instead of just another kid in the class.
After that, I fell back on the tricks I’ve picked up over the years from watching new kids settle in, the small stuff that doesn’t make it into handbooks but actually works. The first thing I did was give Mia a low-stakes, shared job that required small bits of interaction without forcing friendship. I knew she liked drawing from her mom’s intake note, so I asked her to be our class bulletin board border designer for our upcoming fall changes project. All she had to do was add small doodles around the edge of the board, and to do that, she had to ask every kid in class what their favorite fall thing was. It wasn’t “go make friends,” it was “we need this done, and you’re the best person for it.” Last week, two girls from her table stopped by her drawing spot to ask if she could doodle their mom’s pumpkin spice latte, since they get one every Saturday. They stood there for five minutes talking about how whipped cream gets all over the car seats, and that was that. No awkward forced buddy time, just a natural, low-pressure interaction.
I also talked to Mia’s mom about the questions she was asking at the end of the day. For the first two weeks, she’d asked Mia “did you make any new friends today?” every afternoon when she got in the car, and every day Mia cried the whole drive home. It’s such a natural question to ask, but it feels like a test to a new kid. If you don’t have a friend by day 10, that means you’re failing, right? I suggested she swap that question for something low-stakes, with no right or wrong answer. I gave her a few options: “what was the weirdest thing someone ate for lunch today?” “did any teacher say something weird today?” or even just “what part of the day didn’t suck?” She tried it the next day, and that night she texted me that Mia talked for 10 minutes straight about the kid who brought a whole jar of dill pickles for lunch and ate them with his hands. No tears, no pressure, just a normal after-school chat.
Another small trick I do for every new kid now is take 30 seconds one-on-one with them every morning for the first two weeks, just to point out one of the unwritten rules no one thinks to tell a newcomer. Stuff like, “Just a heads up, the water fountain by our classroom leaks all over the floor, so if you need a drink, use the one down the hall.” Or “If you need to go to the bathroom during reading time, you don’t have to raise your hand and ask, just go. No one asks anymore.” When you’re the new kid, you’re already overthinking every little thing. You don’t know the unspoken routines that every other kid has memorized, and that constant low-level anxiety makes you want to sit quiet and not draw attention to yourself. Those 30-second tips take away so much of that weight.
Back to the crumpled cat drawing. After Mia told me what it was, I didn’t say “I’m sure the girls will love it tomorrow” or “don’t be sad, everyone likes you.” That stuff is useless, it just makes a kid feel like their feelings are wrong. I just told her that my desk by the door had an old dinosaur drawing that got coffee spilled on it the week before, and I’d been needing a new picture to hang up. Could I have the cat? She nodded, then pulled out an extra copy she’d drawn, and said she could give the second one to the girl at her table who collects cat stickers. We walked over together, she handed it to her, and the girl stuck it right on the front of her pencil box. It’s not a best friendship, it’s just a small connection.
Last Saturday I saw Mia and her mom at the grocery store, pushing a cart down the cereal aisle. She waved at me, and I saw the girl with the cat drawing had given her a rainbow unicorn sticker that was stuck to the front of her water bottle. She still eats lunch alone most days, and she still doesn’t raise her hand to answer questions even when I know she knows the answer. That’s okay. I was the new kid in 7th grade, and I ate lunch in the library stacks for three months before I found two people who liked the same bad fantasy books as me. No one needs to force fit in in three weeks. The job of parents and teachers isn’t to get the new kid a best friend by the end of the first month. It’s just to leave enough small, low-pressure openings that they can step into when they’re ready. Some days that’s a cat drawing on a pencil box. Some days that’s a job drawing borders on a bulletin board. It doesn’t have to be more than that, right now.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What It’s Really Like Being the New Kid in School (and Small, Practical Things That Actually Help)