What Is the Best Age to Have Kids? An Honest Parent’s Perspective
The grill was smoking and my 10-year-old was sneaking potato chips into his hoodie pocket when the conversation turned to the one question no one ever agrees on. Lila, 22, just announced her first pregnancy, and half the backyard was whooping while the other half side-eyed each other. By the time I flipped the last burger, someone had asked it: “But really, what’s the best age to have kids anyway?”
I had my first at 26, so I’ve lived the early-parenting life. Back then, we lived in a one-bedroom apartment with a leaky faucet and a monthly budget that counted ramen as a “balanced meal.” My husband had just started his first engineering job, making $42,000 a year, and I quit my barista shift because we couldn’t afford $1,200 a month for daycare. I had so much energy back then. I’d chase my toddler around the playground for three hours after nap, go for a two-mile walk after dinner, and still stay up folding laundry until 11pm. I didn’t think twice about sleeping on the floor of his room when he had a cough, or crawling through the park tunnel with him just to make him laugh. But money was so tight we couldn’t afford a date night once every three months. I cried the first time he needed an antibiotic and we had to put the $85 copay on a credit card. I resented missing out on the early career moves my friends were making, the weekend trips to the beach, the ability to just get in the car and go somewhere without packing a diaper bag and planning for nap times.
Lila says her mom keeps telling her she’s too young, but she and her partner both work flexible barista shifts, live with his mom rent-free for another year, and have family close by that can help with babysitting. They’re happy to put off buying a house and fancy vacations to have their kid now, and that’s their call. On the other side of the patio that night was Mia, 38, holding her 3-month-old first baby. She waited almost 15 years to have kids, worked her way up to senior marketing director, paid off all her student loans, bought a three-bedroom house with a yard, and saved enough to cover a part-time nanny. She told me a week later she never loses her temper over spilled milk or a 2 a.m. wake-up. She’s got the patience to sit and stare at the baby batting at a mobile for 20 minutes, something I never had when I was 26 and stressed about paying the electric bill. But she wakes up with lower back pain after carrying the car seat up the stairs, and she says she’s already wiped out after a full day of work and baby care, something she didn’t expect. She worries she’ll be 60 when her kid graduates college, and that she won’t have the energy to run around with grandkids one day.
What I’ve realized after talking to all these friends, and living my own messy middle, is that your birth year matters a lot less than two concrete things most people don’t talk about. The first is how much buffer you have for the hard stuff. Buffer isn’t just money, though that helps. It’s having extra time to recover when you haven’t slept in three days. It’s having a partner or family member who can step in for an hour when you need a break. It’s having enough savings to cover an unexpected $500 ER bill without panicking. When I was 26, I had the energy buffer but zero financial buffer, and that made every small problem feel huge. When Mia is 38, she has the financial buffer but less energy buffer, so every long day leaves her wiped out for two days after.
The second thing is what your priorities are right now. If you’re desperate to switch careers or finish a degree or travel for six months in the next two years, having a kid will push that back, no matter if you’re 22 or 32. If you’re in a place where you’re happy to slow down for a few years to focus on a small person, that’s going to make the hard days easier, no matter your age. I had a friend who had her first at 41, and she’d already checked off every career and travel goal she had, so she was happy to stay home and do puzzles and read picture books every day. Another friend had hers at 21, and she always wanted to be a young mom who could keep up with her kids’ sports, so she doesn’t regret the early career trade-off at all.
By the end of the night, we’d cleared the paper plates off the picnic table and my kids were chasing fireflies in the backyard. Lila was sitting on the steps, twisting her engagement ring, and said she was scared everyone was right that she’s too young. I handed her a cold soda and said I still have days I wonder if I was too young. I think about how much easier things would be now if I’d waited until I had more savings, if I’d gotten that marketing degree I was working on before I got pregnant. Mia nodded from the porch, where she was rocking her sleeping baby, and said she still has days she wishes she’d had her kids younger, when her knees didn’t ache and she didn’t have to pay for fertility treatments and a mortgage all at once.
No one left the BBQ with a clear answer. We all packed up our coolers and our sticky kids and drove home, each of us with our own set of trade-offs. The best age isn’t a number on a doctor’s chart, it’s the age where you can accept the trade-offs you’re making. There’s no perfect time, just the time that works for you right now. Some days that will feel wrong, and some days it will feel exactly right. That’s just how it goes.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Is the Best Age to Have Kids