What Is The Best Age To Have Kids? A Parent’s Honest Breakdown Of Myths And Practical Checks
Last Saturday, I sat at my sticky corner booth at the neighborhood coffee shop, wiping lemonade off my sleeve with a crumpled napkin, when my 22-year-old cousin Lila slid across from me, twisting a crumpled positive pregnancy test in her jacket pocket. She’d just told her extended family the news, and everyone had an opinion. Her grandma said she was throwing her life away having kids so young. Her roommate, who’s saving for a house and planning to wait until 35, said Lila was being reckless. “So you’ve done both,” she said, nodding at my 4-year-old who was stacking blocks in the play corner, “what’s the best age?”
I had my first son when I was 21, my daughter when I was 32. So I’ve got a front row seat to both sides of the debate. When I had my son, I was still finishing my college degree, living in a 500-square-foot apartment that smelled like old takeout and baby detergent, and stretched a part-time bookstore paycheck to cover rent and diapers. I ate ramen for dinner five nights a week to afford his first birthday cake. But I also could stay up three straight nights with his colic, catch two hours of sleep between classes, and wake up ready to go with a single gas station coffee. I didn’t think twice about folding laundry while he sat on my chest watching Sesame Street, or carrying him on my hip for two miles around the neighborhood when he had a fever and wouldn’t settle. I was so scared of doing everything wrong back then, though. When his daycare teacher said he was “overly fussy” and wouldn’t nap, I believed it was my fault. When the pediatrician suggested an early occupational therapy evaluation for his late walking, I put it off for a year because I couldn’t afford the copay on my student insurance. I had energy and flexibility, but almost no stability or confidence to advocate for him.
Eleven years later, when I had my daughter, things looked totally different. My husband and I owned a small three-bedroom house, I had a steady full-time job with six months of paid parental leave, and I booked her OT evaluation before she turned six months old the second I noticed her persistent hand flapping. I don’t panic when she has a meltdown in the grocery store, I don’t apologize for her behavior to random strangers, I know that a little dirt on her pants or a skipped nap isn’t going to break her. But I also can’t chase her around the playground for an hour without my lower back aching for three days after. After a midnight feeding and a full work day, I’m in bed by 9 o’clock, and I still sleep through my alarm some mornings. I have the stability and the experience, but I don’t have the same endless reserve of energy I had when I was 21.
I leaned across the table to Lila, while my daughter screamed from the play corner that a boy took her blue block. I didn’t jump up to fix it, just yelled “ask for it back nicely” and turned back to her. That’s the thing about the “best age” question, I told her. Everyone acts like it’s a number that studies can prove, some magic window that guarantees a perfect life and perfect kids. But that’s not what I’ve seen. The best age isn’t about your birth year, it’s about a few small, concrete things that have nothing to do with how old you are.
First, can you cover your basic fixed expenses—rent, utilities, health insurance—for at least three months without a steady paycheck? You don’t need a six-figure salary or a paid off house. But if you lose your job, or need to take time off for a pregnancy complication or a sick kid, do you have enough savings or support to cover the basics? That’s a way more useful question than “am I financially ready.” Second, do you have at least one person who will answer your call at 2am, no questions asked, if you need someone to sit with your kid so you can go to the ER, or you just need someone to bring you coffee and sit with you while you cry? You don’t need a whole network of backup caregivers, just one person who doesn’t expect you to have it all together. Third, can you name one small, low-cost thing you can do to recharge when you’re exhausted? For me at 21, it was a 10 minute walk around the block alone with a $2 soda. For me now, it’s 15 minutes of sitting on the porch after everyone goes to bed eating a cheap candy bar. It doesn’t have to be fancy, it just has to exist.
Lila nodded, twisting the test in her pocket. She said she checked all three boxes: her roommate would help her in a pinch, she has three months of expenses saved from her barista job, and her 10-minute recharge is sitting on her fire escape with a single cigarette after work. That’s more than a lot of people 10 years older than her have, I told her.
She left a little while later, after my daughter climbed back in the stroller and we headed out. She’s still scared, and there’s still a dozen people telling her she’s doing it wrong. I don’t blame her. I was that scared at 22, I was that scared at 32 too.
Tonight, I’m picking my 16-year-old son up from soccer practice, then I have to get up at 6am tomorrow to get my daughter to gymnastics. My back still aches from chasing her around the zoo last weekend, and my son teases me that I already know half the songs he listens to because I had him young and grew up with that music alongside him. It’s messy. Some months we struggle to pay for all the kids’ activities, some days I’m too tired to read bedtime stories and we just listen to an audio book instead. There are things I love about having kids young, and things I love about having them older. There’s no perfect age, just the age that works for what you have right now. I don’t have a neat answer for anyone who asks, but that’s the truth I’ve found.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What Is The Best Age To Have Kids