What I Learned Watching My Teen Prep for a First Job: Connecting Education to the Job Market
The crumpled printout of Lila’s high school transcript sat next to a half-eaten honey granola bar on our kitchen table last month, and my 17-year-old was staring at it like it was written in a foreign language. She was applying for a part-time admin opening at the local architecture firm down the street, and she’d just gotten to the section labeled “relevant experience.” “All I have is AP Bio and a 3.98 GPA,” she said, tapping the screen so hard the laptop shook. “What does that have to do with answering phones and scheduling meetings?”
I offered to drive her to drop off the resume in person – the firm noted they preferred that over online submissions, and Lila was too nervous to go alone. When we arrived, we met Mrs. Henderson, the office manager who’d run the front desk for 22 years. She glanced over Lila’s transcript, asked her a few questions about availability, then after Lila stepped out to look at the firm’s display of local project photos, she leaned across the desk to me. “I get 20 of these a month from straight-A kids,” she said. “Half send emails with three typos in the first sentence. A quarter don’t show up to their interview at all – no text, no call, nothing. I’d take a kid who can show up 10 minutes early and ask how my day is over a 4.0 any day.”
Lila got the job. I’m pretty sure it wasn’t her GPA that won her over. It was that Lila heard Mrs. Henderson mention her golden retriever was getting knee surgery that week, so she asked about him first thing at her formal interview. And she’d spent three years helping me sort enrollment paperwork for my home daycare, so she already knew how to label and file documents neatly, no extra training required.
I’ve been a substitute teacher at the local high school for 10 years, so this gap between education and what the job market actually wants isn’t new to me. We spend so much time telling kids that good grades will get them good jobs that we skip the small, messy in-between steps that actually get them hired and keep them hired. Most high schools are pressured to prioritize test scores and college admission rates, so practical, on-the-job skills get pushed to the side or crammed into a one-semester senior class that most kids don’t take seriously. Last semester I subbed for an 11th grade college and career prep class, and the assignment was to write a cover letter. Out of 28 kids, 12 misspelled the hiring manager’s title in the first line, and 19 just listed generic traits (“I’m a hard worker”) instead of giving a single example of when they’d done the work the job asked for.
This doesn’t mean we have to overhaul our kids’ education or beg for fancy internships that are impossible for most teens to get. Over the past year, I’ve changed small, daily habits with Lila that take almost no extra time or money, and they’ve added up to way more practical job preparation than any extra credit assignment.
For example, when we planned our annual family camping trip this summer, I didn’t book the cabin myself. I asked Lila to compare three options, check for pet accessibility for our dog, and email each campground to ask about their cancellation policy. It took her 45 minutes, and she sent the first email with a typo in the campground’s name, but that’s how she learned to read it over twice before hitting send. When her cell phone bill had an extra $25 unauthorized charge last year, I didn’t call the company to fix it. I sat next to her on the couch, helped her practice what she wanted to say, and let her handle the whole call. It was 20 minutes of awkward pauses and a little anxiety, but it taught her more about clear communication and problem-solving than any public speaking assignment I’ve seen in high school.
Another small shift: when Lila was writing her first resume, I didn’t rewrite it for her to make it sound as impressive as possible. I pointed out typos, and suggested she add the part about organizing my daycare paperwork, but I let her write every word. It wasn’t the sleekest resume I’d ever seen, but it sounded like her, and that’s what caught Mrs. Henderson’s attention. Too many kids get to their first job and have no idea how to talk about their own experience, because adults have done all that work for them for years.
Lila’s been at the job for three months now. Two weeks ago, she double-booked two architects for the same meeting room. She came home shaking, convinced she’d get fired. But she went in the next day, told her boss immediately what happened, apologized, and called the client to reschedule at a time that worked for him. Her boss didn’t fire her. He told her that owning up to a mistake immediately was worth more than any perfect scheduling job. Lila told me that night that none of her AP classes had ever taught her how to write a professional apology email, or what to do when you mess up at work. That one mistake taught her more than any midterm score she’s ever gotten.
I still worry, of course. I don’t know what the job market will look like when Lila graduates college, or if all this small practice will add up to what she needs. I’ve just stopped fixating on that perfect 4.0 like I used to. Now, once a month, we carve out an hour to work on small, job-related things together: practice a quick introduction for a future interview, review a draft of an email, help her sort blueprints at the firm on a slow Saturday if she needs extra hours. It’s not fancy, it doesn’t look good on a college application checklist, but it’s working for us right now. We’re still figuring it out.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned Watching My Teen Prep for a First Job: Connecting Education to the Job Market