What I Learned From My Tween’s Obsession With Earning 100 Reddit Karma To Post
I was wiping spaghetti sauce off the dinner plates last Tuesday when my 12-year-old Jax huffed so loud I thought he’d dropped his phone in the garbage disposal. He leaned against the kitchen counter, thumb jabbing at his screen, and said, “Stupid. Why can’t I just post it?”
I wiped my hands on my jeans and leaned over to see. The bright white notification popped up clear as day: In order to post your account must be older than 10 days and have 100 positive karma.
Jax had just finished a 3-week build of a Republic outpost from the Clone Wars, all out of leftover bricks he’d scavenged from old sets and a bulk brick lot he’d saved up allowance to buy. He’d spent three evenings arranging the diorama, taking photos from different angles, and drafting a caption talking about how he’d modified the turret to rotate without gluing. He’d gotten banned from his old account a week prior, after he shared a meme from a movie in a general discussion thread and the auto-mod flagged it for copyright. So he’d made a new account, and now this.
My first thought was the same I have for most of my kid’s online stresses: it’s just a social media post, calm down. I almost said, “Who cares if 100 random people see your Lego? It’s cool, I think it’s cool.” But I caught myself. Jax doesn’t care what I think half as much as he cares what other people who love the same weird niche Lego stuff think. That’s the whole point of community, right?
I pulled out a chair and sat next to him. I asked him how much karma he had right now. He pulled up his profile: 37. He’d been commenting on every new post in the sub for three days, just saying “nice build” or “great work” to try to get upvotes. He’d skipped our after-dinner dog walk two nights in a row, and he’d snapped at his little sister when she borrowed his colored pencil to draw, because it interrupted his constant refreshing.
I started thinking about all the conversations we have about kids online. We talk about not sharing addresses, not talking to strangers, not getting sucked into endless scrolling. But we barely ever talk about these random, arbitrary-seeming rules that gate access to the spaces kids actually want to be part of. This 10-day, 100-karma rule isn’t some random gimmick—it’s the sub’s protection against spam bots and trolls that make new accounts after they get banned. But to a 12-year-old who just wants to share the thing he worked hardest on all month, it just feels like the whole world is against him.
I didn’t offer to let him post from my old Reddit account, even though I’ve had it for 10 years and have thousands of karma. That would have fixed the problem in two minutes, but it would have skipped the whole lesson, right? Instead, we made a small plan. I told him that generic comments like “cool build” don’t get upvoted much, because everyone leaves those. Instead, he could pick three posts a day that he actually likes, write one specific comment about what he likes or a question he has, and then close the app. No refreshing every five minutes. We added 10 minutes of commenting to his after-homework routine, right before he goes outside to ride his bike. That way it doesn’t bleed into everything else.
It sounded too simple to work, but it did. He stopped hovering over his phone at dinner. He joined us for the dog walk again. Most of his comments got one or two upvotes, some got none, but slowly the number crawled up. On the 11th day, after the 10-day waiting period was over, he hit 101 karma. He screamed so loud the dog ran under the couch. He posted his outpost that night, and ended up with 47 upvotes, three comments asking where he got the rare dark gray bricks, and one guy even said he was going to copy the turret design for his own build. Jax walked around with a grin on his face for two days.
Since then, I’ve noticed this kind of rule pop up all over the places my kid hangs out online. His Minecraft build server requires three positive forum posts before you can join the creative world. His art Instagram group requires you to comment on three other people’s posts before you can share your own. The rules are different, but the core is the same: you have to participate before you can contribute.
That’s the insight I didn’t expect. I used to write off all this online karma stuff as useless internet points. But for kids, it’s actually their first real lesson in how community works, online or off. If you join a local soccer team, you don’t just show up to the first tournament and start playing—you show up to practice, you pass to your teammates, you help pick up the cones before you get a spot. If you join a book club, you don’t just show up once and demand everyone talk about your favorite book—you listen to other people’s thoughts first. It’s the same rule, just online, with numbers.
Of course it’s not perfect. Last week Jax told me about a new kid in the Lego sub who got 98 karma, then one random downvote dropped him to 97, so he couldn’t post his build for another day. It’s unfair sometimes, and arbitrary, and it can feel cruel when you’re a kid who just wants to share something you made. But that’s also part of the lesson, isn’t it? Not all rules are fair, but most of them exist for a reason, and you can work through them without panicking.
We still have hard days sometimes. Last month Jax wanted to enter a build contest and was 12 karma short the day before entries closed, and he was stressed all afternoon. We sat down, picked four builds he liked, wrote real comments, and by the end of the night he hit 100. It worked out. I don’t know if this is preparing him for something big down the line, or if it’s just another weird phase of tween internet life. Right now, it’s working. He knows how to show up, participate a little, and wait for his turn. That’s more than I expected from a random online rule about karma.
Please indicate: Thinking In Educating » What I Learned From My Tween’s Obsession With Earning 100 Reddit Karma To Post